- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Council of Ministers: size, categories and responsibility
Practise the size limit of the Council, the three ranks of ministers and the difference between collective and individual responsibility.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Many questions separate the Cabinet from the larger Council of Ministers and ask which kind of responsibility applies.
Size and ranks
The 91st Amendment (2003) limits the total Council of Ministers to fifteen per cent of the strength of the Lok Sabha. The Council has three ranks: Cabinet ministers, Ministers of State and Deputy Ministers. The Cabinet is the smaller inner group of senior ministers that takes the major decisions.
Responsibility
| Kind | Meaning | Article |
|---|---|---|
| Collective | The Council is jointly responsible to the Lok Sabha; if it loses confidence the whole Council must resign | 75(3) |
| Individual | Ministers hold office during the pleasure of the President, in practice on the Prime Minister's advice | 75(2) |
Worked example 1: fifteen per cent
Question: If the Lok Sabha had 500 members, what is the maximum size of the Council under the 15 per cent rule? Working: 15 per cent of 500 is 75. Answer: 75 ministers.
Worked example 2: who must resign
Question: The Lok Sabha passes a no-confidence motion. Who must go? Working: Collective responsibility means the whole Council resigns, led by the Prime Minister. Answer: The entire Council of Ministers.
Council of Ministers collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha; limit of 15 per cent of its strength; three ranks.
Key takeaways: Distinguish Cabinet from Council, and collective from individual responsibility.
Check your understanding
-
1. If the Lok Sabha had 480 members (an illustrative figure), the maximum size of the Council of Ministers would be
- 48
- 72
- 80
- 96
Show answer
Answer: B. 15 per cent of 480 = 0.15 x 480 = 72.
-
2. Which is NOT a rank of minister in the Union Council of Ministers?
- Cabinet minister
- Minister of State
- Chief Minister
- Deputy minister
Show answer
Answer: C. The three ranks are Cabinet ministers, Ministers of State and deputy ministers. A Chief Minister heads a State government.
-
3. 'Ministers hold office during the pleasure of the President.' This is the basis of
- collective responsibility, under Article 75(3)
- judicial review, under Article 13
- the Prime Minister's duties, under Article 78
- individual responsibility, under Article 75(2)
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 75(2), the pleasure clause, is the basis of individual responsibility; in practice the pleasure is exercised on the Prime Minister's advice.
-
4. The Lok Sabha passes a no-confidence motion. Who must resign?
- The entire Council of Ministers, led by the Prime Minister
- Only the Cabinet ministers
- Only the minister whose department was criticised
- The Speaker of the Lok Sabha
Show answer
Answer: A. Under collective responsibility (Article 75(3)) the whole Council resigns together.
-
5. The limit on the size of the Council of Ministers was introduced by
- the 42nd Amendment, 1976
- the 91st Amendment, 2003
- the 61st Amendment, 1988
- the 97th Amendment, 2011
Show answer
Answer: B. The 91st Amendment (2003) limited the Council of Ministers to 15 per cent of the strength of the Lok Sabha.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.