- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Joint promisors and joint promisees: devolution of joint liabilities and rights
Explain how a joint promise must be performed during the joint lives of the promisors and after their deaths (Section 42), and who can claim performance of a promise made to several persons jointly (Section 45).
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- State the rule of devolution of joint liabilities under Section 42.
- State the rule of devolution of joint rights under Section 45.
- Work out who must perform, or who may claim, when one of several joint parties dies.
Many contracts involve more than two persons. Three partners may borrow jointly; a seller may promise to deliver goods to two buyers jointly. 'Devolution' means passing on. The questions here are: when several people share one promise, how does the duty or right pass on when one of them dies?
Devolution of joint liabilities (Section 42)
When two or more persons have made a joint promise, then, unless a contrary intention appears from the contract, all of them must jointly fulfil the promise during their joint lives. After the death of any of them, his legal representative must fulfil it jointly with the survivors. After the death of the last survivor, the representatives of all must fulfil it jointly.
Devolution of joint rights (Section 45)
When a person has made a promise to two or more persons jointly, then, unless the contract says otherwise, the right to claim performance rests with them jointly during their joint lives. After the death of any of them, it rests with his representative jointly with the survivors, and after the death of the last survivor, with the representatives of all jointly.
How a joint duty or right passes on
- While all are alive All the joint parties together
- After one dies The survivors together with the dead party's legal representative
- After the last survivor dies The legal representatives of all of them jointly
| Point | Section 42: joint liabilities | Section 45: joint rights |
|---|---|---|
| Who are joint | Two or more promisors | Two or more promisees |
| What passes on | The duty to perform | The right to claim performance |
| During joint lives | All promisors jointly | All promisees jointly |
| After one dies | His representative with the survivors | His representative with the survivors |
| After the last survivor dies | Representatives of all jointly | Representatives of all jointly |
| Exception | A contrary intention in the contract | A contract to the contrary |
Joint lives: all together. One dies: survivors plus his representative. All die: representatives of all, jointly.
Worked example 1: a joint loan
Anand, Bhavani and Chitra (made-up) jointly promise to repay ₹90,000 to Devi. Before repayment, Chitra dies. Step 1: this is a joint promise, so Section 42 applies. Step 2: one promisor has died, so the duty now rests with the survivors (Anand and Bhavani) together with Chitra's legal representative. Conclusion: the contract does not end; Anand, Bhavani and Chitra's representative must repay the ₹90,000 jointly.
Worked example 2: a joint right
A furniture maker (made-up) promises Elango and Fathima jointly to deliver 20 chairs to their new café. Elango dies before delivery. Step 1: the promise was made to two persons jointly, so Section 45 applies. Step 2: one promisee has died, so the right now rests with Fathima together with Elango's legal representative. Conclusion: they can jointly claim delivery of the 20 chairs. If Fathima also died, the representatives of both could claim jointly.
Key takeaways: a joint promise is fulfilled by all the promisors jointly; on a death, the survivors act with the deceased's legal representative; after the last death, all the representatives act jointly; Section 45 applies the same pattern to the right to claim performance; both rules yield to a contrary term in the contract.
Check your understanding
-
1. A, B and C jointly promise to pay ₹50,000 to D. C dies before payment. The contract:
- becomes void on C's death
- must be performed by A and B along with C's legal representative
- must be performed by A and B alone
- must be renewed between A, B and D
Show answer
Answer: B. Under Section 42, after one joint promisor dies, his legal representative must fulfil the promise jointly with the survivors.
-
2. Devolution of joint rights is dealt with in:
- Section 40
- Section 42
- Section 45
- Section 59
Show answer
Answer: C. Section 42 covers joint liabilities; Section 45 covers joint rights, that is, the right to claim performance.
-
3. After the death of the last surviving joint promisor, the promise must be fulfilled by:
- the representatives of all the promisors jointly
- the promisee alone
- nobody, since the contract ends
- the court
Show answer
Answer: A. Section 42 says that after the death of the last survivor, the representatives of all must fulfil the promise jointly.
-
4. The rules in Sections 42 and 45 apply:
- only to written contracts
- only to minors
- only to contracts with the government
- unless the contract shows a contrary intention
Show answer
Answer: D. Both sections apply 'unless a contrary intention appears' or 'unless there is a contract to the contrary'.
-
5. A seller promises two buyers jointly to deliver goods. While both buyers are alive, the right to claim delivery rests with:
- either buyer alone, separately
- the seller
- both buyers jointly
- the buyers' legal representatives
Show answer
Answer: C. During their joint lives, the right to claim performance of a joint promise rests with all the promisees jointly (Section 45).
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.