- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Performance of a contract: actual performance and valid tender
Explain what Section 37 requires of the parties, tell actual performance from attempted performance (tender), and list the essentials of a valid tender under Section 38.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- State the duty that Section 37 places on parties to a contract.
- Distinguish actual performance from attempted performance (offer to perform, or tender).
- List the essentials of a valid tender under Section 38 and apply them to cases.
Making a contract is only the first half of the story. The whole point of agreeing is that each side will later do what it promised. Performance is the normal way a contract ends: when both sides have done their part, the contract is discharged. This chapter of the Tamil Nadu textbook looks at how performance must be made, by whom, when and where.
The duty under Section 37
Section 37 says that the parties to a contract must either perform their respective promises or offer to perform them, unless performance is dispensed with or excused under the Act or any other law. So a party who is ready and makes a proper offer to perform has done his duty even if the other side refuses to accept.
Two ways of performing a contract
-
Actual performance
- The party actually does what he undertook
- All obligations are fulfilled
- Example: seller delivers the goods and buyer pays
-
Attempted performance (tender)
- The party offers to perform
- The promisee refuses to accept
- A valid tender counts as performance of the promise
Essentials of a valid tender (Section 38)
A tender protects the promisor only if it is made properly. The textbook lists these requirements:
- It must be unconditional: the promisor cannot attach new terms of his own.
- It must be for the whole obligation, not in instalments, when the contract requires performance in full.
- It must be made by a person who is able and willing to perform.
- It must be made at the proper time and place.
- It must be in the proper form, for instance the right goods or the agreed kind of payment.
- It must be made to the proper person: the promisee or his authorised agent.
- In a tender of goods, the promisee must be given a reasonable opportunity to inspect them.
- Where there are several joint promisees, a tender may be made to any one of them.
A valid tender of performance is treated as performance of the promise: the promisor is not responsible if the promisee refuses it.
Worked example 1: is the tender valid?
Ganesh (made-up) contracts to deliver 50 bags of rice to a mill on Monday. He arrives on Monday during working hours with all 50 bags, invites the manager to inspect them, and the manager refuses to take delivery. Check: unconditional (yes), whole quantity (yes), able and willing (yes), proper time and place (yes), proper person (the manager acting for the mill, yes), chance to inspect (yes). Conclusion: this is a valid tender. Ganesh has done his duty and is not liable for non-performance.
Worked example 2: an invalid tender
Revathi (made-up) owes Dinesh ₹30,000 payable in one sum on 1 March. On 1 March she offers ₹10,000, saying she will pay the rest 'later'. Dinesh refuses. Check: the contract requires full payment, but Revathi offers part only, so the tender is not for the whole obligation. It is also, in effect, conditional on Dinesh accepting delay. Conclusion: not a valid tender; Revathi remains liable for the full ₹30,000.
Key takeaways: under Section 37 parties must perform or offer to perform their promises; performance may be actual or attempted; a valid tender (Section 38) must be unconditional, for the whole obligation, by a willing and able person, at the proper time, place and form, to the proper person, with a chance to inspect goods, and may be made to one of several joint promisees.
Check your understanding
-
1. An offer to perform which the promisee refuses to accept is called:
- actual performance
- attempted performance or tender
- breach of contract
- novation
Show answer
Answer: B. When the promisor offers to perform and the promisee does not accept, the textbook calls it attempted performance, also called offer of performance or tender.
-
2. Which section lays down the essentials of a valid tender?
- Section 38
- Section 10
- Section 56
- Section 73
Show answer
Answer: A. Section 38 deals with the effect and requirements of an offer to perform (tender).
-
3. A seller tenders goods but locks them in a van and refuses to let the buyer look at them. The tender is invalid because:
- it was made at the wrong place
- it was in instalments
- it was made to the wrong person
- the buyer had no reasonable opportunity to inspect the goods
Show answer
Answer: D. In a tender of goods, the promisee must have a reasonable chance to inspect them, to see that they are what the contract requires.
-
4. Where there are three joint promisees, a tender of performance may be made to:
- all three together only
- a court officer only
- any one of them
- nobody until all agree
Show answer
Answer: C. The textbook's list includes that a tender may be made to one of several joint promisees.
-
5. On valid performance of the contractual obligations by both parties, the contract:
- is discharged
- becomes void
- becomes illegal
- becomes voidable
Show answer
Answer: A. Performance is the normal mode of discharge: the rights and obligations under the contract come to an end.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.