- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Time, place and manner of performance: Sections 46 to 50
Apply the rules on performance within a reasonable time, on a fixed day with or without application by the promisee, when no place is fixed, and in the manner the promisee prescribes.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain what 'reasonable time' means under Section 46.
- Apply Sections 47 and 48 to promises due on a certain day.
- Apply Section 49 when no place is fixed and Section 50 when the promisee prescribes the manner or time.
The textbook highlights that time, place and manner form the core of performance. A delivery made at midnight, at the wrong godown, or in a form the buyer never agreed to may not count as performance at all. Normally the parties fix these details themselves; Sections 46 to 50 fill the gaps when they have not.
Section 46: no time fixed
Where no time is specified and the promisor is to perform without being asked, he must perform within a reasonable time. What is reasonable is a question of fact in each case: it depends on the circumstances, the usage of trade and the intention of the parties. A grocer's 'reasonable time' to deliver vegetables is much shorter than a builder's to finish a house.
Section 47: certain day, without application
When a promise is to be performed on a certain day and the promisor has undertaken to perform it without being asked by the promisee, he may perform it at any time during the usual hours of business on that day, and at the place where the promise ought to be performed.
Section 48: certain day, on application
When the promise is to be performed on a certain day only after the promisee applies for it, it is the promisee's duty to apply for performance at a proper place and within the usual hours of business. Until he applies, the promisor is not at fault.
Section 49: no place fixed
When a promise is to be performed without application by the promisee and no place is fixed, it is the promisor's duty to ask the promisee to appoint a reasonable place for performance, and then to perform it there.
Section 50: as the promisee prescribes
Performance of any promise may be made in any manner or at any time which the promisee prescribes or sanctions. Because performance is for the promisee's benefit, he may agree to accept it differently. For instance, a creditor may agree to take goods instead of part of the money owed.
| Section | Situation | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| 46 | No time fixed, no application needed | Perform within a reasonable time |
| 47 | Certain day fixed, no application needed | Perform during usual business hours on that day, at the proper place |
| 48 | Certain day fixed, application needed | Promisee must apply at a proper place within usual business hours |
| 49 | No place fixed, no application needed | Promisor must ask the promisee to appoint a reasonable place, then perform there |
| 50 | Promisee prescribes or sanctions | Perform in the manner and at the time he prescribes |
Time, place and manner form the core of performance: when the contract is silent, Sections 46 to 50 decide.
Worked example 1: no place fixed
Mani (made-up) agrees to deliver 1,000 kg of wheat to Nalini on 10 October; the contract names no place. Step 1: a fixed day, no application needed, no place: Section 49 applies. Step 2: Mani must ask Nalini to appoint a reasonable place, say her shop's godown. Step 3: he must deliver the 1,000 kg there, during usual business hours on 10 October. If he simply leaves the wheat at his own farm, he has not performed.
Worked example 2: manner prescribed by the promisee
Tamil owes Sathya ₹2,00,000 (made-up). Sathya agrees to accept Tamil's car, valued at ₹1,20,000, towards the debt. Working: under Section 50, delivering the car is performance in a manner the promisee has sanctioned, so it counts as part payment. Remaining debt = ₹2,00,000 − ₹1,20,000 = ₹80,000, which Tamil must still pay.
Key takeaways: no time fixed means a reasonable time (Section 46); on a fixed day, perform during usual business hours at the proper place (Section 47), or wait for the promisee's application where one is needed (Section 48); with no place fixed, ask the promisee to name a reasonable place (Section 49); the promisee may prescribe or sanction any manner or time (Section 50).
Check your understanding
-
1. Where no time for performance is fixed, the promise must be performed:
- immediately
- within a reasonable time
- within one year
- whenever the promisor wishes
Show answer
Answer: B. Section 46 requires performance within a reasonable time, judged from the circumstances, trade usage and intention of the parties.
-
2. A promise is due on a fixed day without application. The promisor delivers at 11 p.m. that day when the business is closed. Which rule is broken?
- Section 50
- Section 45
- Section 47: usual hours of business
- Section 61
Show answer
Answer: C. Section 47 allows performance at any time during the usual hours of business on that day, at the proper place. 11 p.m. outside business hours is not proper.
-
3. No place is fixed for delivery. Whose duty is it to have a reasonable place appointed?
- The promisee must find the promisor
- The court must fix it
- Any third person
- The promisor must ask the promisee to appoint a reasonable place
Show answer
Answer: D. Under Section 49 the promisor must apply to the promisee to appoint a reasonable place and then perform there.
-
4. A creditor owed ₹50,000 agrees to accept ₹20,000 worth of goods towards the debt. How much remains payable?
- ₹30,000
- ₹50,000
- ₹20,000
- Nothing
Show answer
Answer: A. Section 50 allows performance in the manner the promisee sanctions. Remaining = ₹50,000 − ₹20,000 = ₹30,000.
-
5. Under Section 48, when performance on a certain day depends on the promisee asking for it:
- the promisor must perform at midnight
- the contract is void
- the promisee must apply at a proper place within usual business hours
- the promisor must find a third person
Show answer
Answer: C. Where performance is on application, it is the promisee's duty to apply at the proper place and within usual business hours.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.