• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Who can demand performance and who must perform

Identify who can demand performance (promisee, legal representative, and third parties in special cases) and who must perform: the promisor, an agent, legal representatives or a third person (Sections 37, 40 and 41).

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain why, as a rule, only the promisee can demand performance.
  • Explain when the promisor must perform personally and when an agent may perform.
  • Explain the position of legal representatives and of a third person who performs.

A contract creates a link between particular persons. That raises two practical questions the textbook answers: who has the right to insist that the promise be kept, and who has the duty to keep it? The answers change when a party dies or when the work needs a personal skill.

Who can demand performance?

  1. The promisee: as a rule only the promisee can demand performance. A stranger to the contract cannot, even if the promise was to pay him.
  2. Legal representative: if the promisee dies, his legal representative can demand performance, except where a contrary intention appears from the contract or the contract is of a personal nature.
  3. Third party, in exceptional cases: the textbook notes special situations, such as a trust or a marriage settlement, where a person who is not a party can enforce a promise made for his benefit.

Who must perform?

  1. Promisor himself (Section 40, first paragraph): where the nature of the contract or the parties' intention shows that the promisor must perform personally, he must do so. Contracts needing personal skill, such as painting a portrait or singing at a concert, are of this kind.
  2. Agent (Section 40, second paragraph): where personal performance is not required, the promisor may employ a competent person, such as an agent, to perform.
  3. Legal representatives (Section 37): if the promisor dies before performance, his legal representatives are bound to perform, unless the contract depended on his personal skill or was founded on personal considerations; such a contract comes to an end on his death.
  4. Third person (Section 41): if the promisee accepts performance from a third person, he cannot afterwards enforce the same promise against the promisor.
  5. Joint promisors: where two or more persons have made a joint promise, they must perform together (Lesson 3).

Who may perform a promise

  • Promisor himself Required when personal skill or confidence is involved
  • Agent Allowed when personal performance is not required
  • Legal representatives Bound after the promisor's death, unless the contract is personal
  • Third person If the promisee accepts it, he cannot then sue the promisor
  • Joint promisors Perform jointly, as Sections 42 onward explain
Based on Sections 37, 40 and 41 as explained in the Tamil Nadu textbook.

Personal skill means personal performance; otherwise an agent may perform, and legal representatives are bound after death.

Worked example 1: death of the promisor

(a) Senthil (made-up) agrees to sell his motorbike to Farida for ₹60,000 in two weeks, and dies after ten days. (b) A famous singer (made-up) agrees to sing at a wedding and dies before the date. Reasoning: (a) selling a bike needs no personal skill, so Senthil's legal representatives must deliver the bike and Farida must pay them ₹60,000. (b) singing depends on the singer's personal skill, so the contract ends on her death and her representatives are not bound to find another singer.

Worked example 2: the stranger who cannot sue

Arun promises Bala that he will pay ₹10,000 to Charu (all made-up). Arun does not pay. Step 1: the promise was made to Bala, so Bala is the promisee. Step 2: Charu is a stranger to the contract. Conclusion: as a general rule, only Bala can enforce the promise against Arun; Charu cannot, unless the case falls under a special exception such as a trust in her favour.

Key takeaways: only the promisee, or after his death his legal representative, can normally demand performance, with exceptions such as trusts; the promisor must perform personally where skill or confidence matters, otherwise an agent may; legal representatives are bound except in personal contracts; accepting a third person's performance bars a later claim against the promisor.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which of these parties generally cannot demand performance of a promise?

    1. The promisee
    2. The promisee's legal representative after his death
    3. One of the joint promisees
    4. A stranger to the contract
    Show answer

    Answer: D. As a rule only the promisee (or his representative, or a joint promisee) can demand performance. A stranger to the contract cannot, except in special cases such as trusts.

  2. 2. X agrees to sketch a site map of Y's house using his special skill. Who must perform?

    1. Any competent agent of X
    2. X himself
    3. Y's agent
    4. X's legal representative
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Where the contract depends on the promisor's personal skill, Section 40 requires the promisor to perform personally.

  3. 3. Under Section 41, if the promisee accepts performance from a third person:

    1. he can still sue the promisor for the same promise
    2. the contract becomes void
    3. he cannot afterwards enforce it against the promisor
    4. the third person becomes the promisee
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Having accepted performance from a third person, the promisee cannot later enforce the same promise against the promisor.

  4. 4. Which person can perform a contract on behalf of the promisor when personal performance is not required?

    1. An agent
    2. The promisee
    3. A stranger chosen by the court
    4. Nobody
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Section 40 allows the promisor to employ a competent person, such as an agent, when the contract is not founded on personal considerations.

  5. 5. A contract to sell a car for ₹1,00,000 in a week; the seller dies after five days. Then:

    1. the contract ends automatically
    2. the buyer must pay the court
    3. only the buyer's family is bound
    4. the seller's legal representatives must sell the car, and the buyer must pay them
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Selling a car is not a personal-skill contract, so under Section 37 the legal representatives of the deceased are bound to perform, and the buyer must pay them.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery