• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Reciprocal promises and appropriation of payments

Explain reciprocal promises (Section 2(f)) and their three kinds, and apply the rules of Sections 59 to 61 to decide which debt a payment settles.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Define reciprocal promises and classify them as mutual and independent, mutual and dependent, or mutual and concurrent.
  • Explain what appropriation of payments means and when the question arises.
  • Apply the three rules of Sections 59, 60 and 61 to numerical cases.

In most business deals each party is both a promisor and a promisee: the seller promises goods and is promised money; the buyer promises money and is promised goods. The order in which such promises must be kept matters. So does a related practical problem: when a debtor owes several debts to one creditor and pays only part, which debt has he paid?

Reciprocal promises: Section 2(f)

Promises which form the consideration, or part of the consideration, for each other are reciprocal promises. If Xavier promises to sell his house to Yamuna for ₹5,00,000 (made-up), Xavier is the promisor for the house and the promisee for the money; Yamuna is the promisee for the house and the promisor for the money.

Kinds of reciprocal promises

  • Mutual and independent
    • Each party performs without waiting for the other
    • Example: payment due on 10 June, delivery on 18 June, each on its own date
  • Mutual and dependent
    • One party's performance depends on the other performing first
    • Example: a builder's work depends on the owner first supplying cement
  • Mutual and concurrent
    • Both promises are performed at the same time
    • Example: cash paid and goods handed over across the counter
The three kinds named in the Tamil Nadu textbook.

Appropriation of payments: Sections 59 to 61

Appropriation means applying a payment to a particular debt. The question arises when a debtor owes several distinct debts to the same creditor and makes a payment that is not enough to clear all of them. The Act gives three rules, in order of priority.

  1. Section 59: the debtor decides. If the debtor expressly says, or the circumstances clearly show, which debt the payment is for, it must be applied to that debt. For instance, if the creditor has demanded one particular debt and the debtor sends exactly that sum, the payment goes to that debt.
  2. Section 60: the creditor decides. If the debtor gives no indication and the circumstances show none, the creditor may apply the payment at his discretion to any lawful debt actually due to him from the debtor.
  3. Section 61: the law decides. If neither party appropriates, the payment is applied to the debts in order of time, whether or not they are time-barred under the Limitation Act, 1963. If the debts are of equal standing (due on the same date), the payment is applied to each proportionately.

Debtor first (Section 59), creditor next (Section 60), law last (Section 61): oldest debt first, or in proportion if equal.

Worked example 1: express appropriation

Kannan owes Lakshmi three separate debts (made-up): ₹20,000, ₹30,000 and ₹50,000. He sends ₹50,000 with a note: 'for the third debt'. Rule: Section 59, express instruction. Result: the third debt of ₹50,000 is fully settled. Remaining debts: ₹20,000 + ₹30,000 = ₹50,000. Lakshmi cannot apply the money to the first two debts instead.

Worked example 2: neither party appropriates

Murali owes a supplier (made-up) two debts, both due on 1 July: ₹40,000 and ₹60,000. He pays ₹25,000 and neither side says which debt it is for. Rule: Section 61; the debts are of equal standing, so the payment is applied proportionately. Total debt = ₹40,000 + ₹60,000 = ₹1,00,000. Share for the first debt = 25,000 × 40,000 ÷ 1,00,000 = ₹10,000. Share for the second = 25,000 × 60,000 ÷ 1,00,000 = ₹15,000. Check: ₹10,000 + ₹15,000 = ₹25,000. Balances: ₹30,000 and ₹45,000. Had the debts fallen due on different dates, the whole ₹25,000 would have gone to the older one.

Key takeaways: reciprocal promises are promises that are consideration for each other, and may be mutual and independent, mutual and dependent, or mutual and concurrent; when one creditor is owed several debts, the debtor appropriates first (Section 59), then the creditor (Section 60), and failing both the law applies the payment in order of time or proportionately (Section 61).

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Promises which form consideration or part of consideration for each other are:

    1. joint promises
    2. contingent promises
    3. gratuitous promises
    4. reciprocal promises
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Section 2(f) defines reciprocal promises as promises forming the consideration, or part of it, for each other.

  2. 2. A builder agrees to construct a house and the owner agrees to supply cement first. The promises are:

    1. mutual and dependent
    2. mutual and independent
    3. mutual and concurrent
    4. not reciprocal
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The builder's performance depends on the owner supplying cement first, so the promises are mutual and dependent.

  3. 3. The question of appropriation of payments arises when:

    1. a debtor owes only one debt
    2. a debtor owes several debts to the same creditor and pays less than the total
    3. the creditor refuses all payment
    4. the debt is paid in full
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Appropriation decides which debt a payment settles. It matters only when there are several debts to one creditor and the payment is insufficient for all.

  4. 4. A debtor owes ₹10,000 due in January and ₹15,000 due in March to one creditor. He pays ₹10,000 and neither party appropriates it. Under Section 61 it settles:

    1. the March debt in part
    2. both debts proportionately
    3. the January debt
    4. neither debt
    Show answer

    Answer: C. When neither party appropriates, payment is applied in order of time. The January debt is older, so the ₹10,000 clears it.

  5. 5. Two debts of ₹30,000 and ₹20,000, both due on the same day, and an unappropriated payment of ₹10,000. How much goes to the ₹30,000 debt?

    1. ₹10,000
    2. ₹5,000
    3. ₹4,000
    4. ₹6,000
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Equal standing means proportionate application. Total = ₹50,000. Share = 10,000 × 30,000 ÷ 50,000 = ₹6,000 (and ₹4,000 to the other).

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery