- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Discharge by impossibility of performance and by lapse of time
Explain Section 56 and the two kinds of impossibility (existing at the time of agreement and arising later), and how lapse of time under the Limitation Act, 1963 discharges a contract.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- State the maxims and the rule of Section 56 on impossible acts.
- Classify impossibility as initial (known or unknown) or supervening (beyond control, or caused by a party).
- Explain discharge by lapse of time under the Limitation Act, 1963.
Sometimes a contract cannot be performed however willing the parties are: the thing to be sold is destroyed, or the promised act was never possible. The law does not force anyone to do the impossible. This lesson also covers a quieter way contracts end: when the injured party waits too long to go to court.
3. Discharge by impossibility of performance
The rule rests on two maxims given in the textbook: the law does not recognise what is impossible, and what is impossible does not create an obligation. Section 56 states that an agreement to do an act impossible in itself is void. A contract that later becomes impossible, or unlawful, to perform becomes void when that happens.
Types of impossibility
-
Impossibility existing at the time of agreement (initial)
- Known to the parties
- Not known to the parties
- Either way the agreement is void from the start
-
Impossibility arising after the contract (supervening)
- By an event beyond the control of the parties
- By an act of the promisor or the promisee
- The contract becomes void when performance becomes impossible
Initial impossibility. If the act was impossible from the beginning, the agreement is void whether or not the parties knew it. An agreement to discover a new planet, or to sell a cow that had already died without the parties knowing, cannot be enforced.
Supervening impossibility. A contract that was possible when made may become impossible later. The cause may be an event beyond the control of the parties, for example destruction of the subject matter by fire or flood, the death or serious illness of a person whose personal skill was needed, or a change in law. Or it may be caused by an act of the promisor or the promisee, as when one party makes performance impossible.
4. Discharge by lapse of time
The Limitation Act, 1963 fixes time limits within which a legal action must be brought. If a contract is not performed and the promisee does not file a suit within the specified period, he loses his remedy at law, and in this sense the contract is discharged. The textbook links this with the rule from Chapter 29: a promise to pay a time-barred debt is enforceable only if made in writing.
What is impossible does not create an obligation (Section 56); a right not pursued within the limitation period loses its remedy in court.
Worked example 1: the burnt hall
A school (made-up) books a marriage hall for its annual day on 15 December for ₹60,000. On 10 December the hall is destroyed by an accidental fire. Step 1: the contract was possible when made, so this is not initial impossibility. Step 2: the fire is an event beyond the control of both parties: supervening impossibility. Conclusion: the contract becomes void and both are discharged; the hall owner cannot demand the ₹60,000 and the school cannot demand the hall.
Worked example 2: classify the impossibility
(a) Two persons (made-up) agree that one will travel back in time for a fee. (b) A cricketer agrees to play a friendly match but breaks his leg the day before. (c) A seller agrees to deliver a particular machine and then sells and ships it to someone else. Answers: (a) impossible from the start: initial impossibility, void. (b) personal performance became impossible by an event beyond control: supervening, the contract becomes void. (c) the impossibility was caused by the promisor's own act; he cannot use it as an excuse and is liable to the buyer for breach.
Key takeaways: under Section 56 an agreement to do an impossible act is void; impossibility may exist at the time of agreement (known or unknown) or arise later (by an event beyond control, or by a party's act); a party who fails to sue within the time fixed by the Limitation Act, 1963 loses his remedy, and the contract is discharged.
Check your understanding
-
1. An agreement to do an act impossible in itself, under Section 56, is:
- valid
- voidable
- void
- unenforceable only for a time
Show answer
Answer: C. Section 56 makes an agreement to do an act impossible in itself void.
-
2. A contract becomes impossible because the goods are destroyed by flood after it is made. This is:
- supervening impossibility by an event beyond the parties' control
- initial impossibility known to the parties
- lapse of time
- novation
Show answer
Answer: A. The contract was possible when made; the flood made it impossible later, and neither party controlled it.
-
3. Which Act fixes the time within which a suit on a contract must be filed?
- Indian Contract Act, 1872
- Income Tax Act, 1961
- Companies Act
- Limitation Act, 1963
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook refers to the Limitation Act, 1963 for the time limits within which a promisee must take legal action.
-
4. Which maxim underlies discharge by impossibility?
- Ignorance of law is no excuse
- What is impossible does not create an obligation
- Let the buyer beware
- Something for something
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook gives two maxims: the law does not recognise what is impossible, and what is impossible does not create an obligation.
-
5. Impossibility existing at the time of agreement may be:
- known or not known to the parties
- only known to the parties
- only caused by the promisee
- only caused by a change in law later
Show answer
Answer: A. The textbook divides initial impossibility into impossibility known to the parties and impossibility not known to them.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.