- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Remedies for breach (2): quantum meruit and damages
Explain a claim on quantum meruit and when it arises, and the purpose and four kinds of damages under Section 73: ordinary, special, vindictive or exemplary, and nominal.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain quantum meruit and list the situations in which it arises.
- State the purpose of damages and the section that deals with them.
- Distinguish ordinary, special, vindictive and nominal damages and work out simple claims.
Money is the most common remedy in commerce. But there are two different money claims. One asks to be paid for work already done when the contract has broken down. The other asks to be compensated for the loss that the breach has caused. This lesson covers both.
(iv) Quantum meruit
Quantum meruit means 'as much as earned' (the textbook writes it as 'quantum merit'). When one party has done part of the work and the contract is then discharged by the other party's breach, the first party can claim payment for what he has done. The claim does not rest on the original contract, which has been discharged or is void, but on an implied promise by the other party to pay for what has been done.
- When a contract is found to be void.
- When something is done without any intention of doing it free of charge.
- When one party abandons or refuses to perform the contract.
- When a contract is divisible.
- When a contract is performed badly (paid for what was done, less the cost of the defects).
(v) Damages
Damages are money compensation awarded by the court to the injured party for the loss or injury he has suffered because of the breach. Section 73 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 deals with compensation for loss or damage caused by breach. The purpose is to put the injured party, as far as money can, in the position he would have been in if the contract had been performed; the textbook calls this making good the loss, or the doctrine of restitution.
| Kind | Meaning | Illustration |
|---|---|---|
| Ordinary damages | Loss that arises naturally, in the usual course of things, from the breach | Extra price paid to buy the same goods elsewhere |
| Special damages | Loss arising from special circumstances, recoverable only if both parties knew of them when the contract was made | Loss of a known profitable resale contract |
| Vindictive or exemplary damages | A larger sum meant to punish the party in breach, awarded only in special cases | Breach of promise to marry; a bank wrongly refusing to honour a customer's cheque |
| Nominal damages | A token amount where a right has been broken but no real loss has been suffered | ₹1 to recognise the breach |
Quantum meruit pays for what was done; damages (Section 73) compensate for what was lost.
Worked example 1: quantum meruit
Queenie (made-up) agrees to write and design 10 chapters of a guidebook for a publisher at ₹6,000 per chapter. After she has completed 4 chapters, the publisher cancels without reason. Step 1: the publisher has refused to perform, so the contract is discharged by its breach. Step 2: Queenie did the work with no intention of doing it free. Step 3: claim on quantum meruit = 4 × ₹6,000 = ₹24,000 for work done. (She may also claim damages for loss caused by the breach.)
Worked example 2: ordinary damages
Ramya (made-up) agrees to buy 500 kg of sugar from a wholesaler at ₹40 per kg for delivery on 1 March. The wholesaler fails to deliver, and on 1 March the market price is ₹44 per kg. Contract price = 500 × 40 = ₹20,000. Market price = 500 × 44 = ₹22,000. Ordinary damages = ₹22,000 − ₹20,000 = ₹2,000. This loss arises naturally from the breach, so it is recoverable. If Ramya also lost a special order from a bakery that the wholesaler was never told about, that extra loss would be special damage and not recoverable.
Key takeaways: quantum meruit ('as much as earned') pays for work done when a contract is void, abandoned, divisible, badly performed, or done without intent to be free; damages under Section 73 compensate for loss caused by breach and are ordinary, special, vindictive (exemplary) or nominal.
Check your understanding
-
1. Quantum meruit means:
- let the buyer beware
- something for something
- as much as earned
- a thing speaks for itself
Show answer
Answer: C. The textbook explains the phrase as 'as much as earned': payment for what has actually been done.
-
2. Which section of the Indian Contract Act deals with compensation for loss caused by breach?
- Section 73
- Section 56
- Section 10
- Section 38
Show answer
Answer: A. Section 73 deals with compensation for loss or damage caused by breach of contract.
-
3. Damages awarded to punish the party in breach, as for breach of a promise to marry, are:
- nominal damages
- ordinary damages
- special damages
- vindictive or exemplary damages
Show answer
Answer: D. Vindictive or exemplary damages go beyond compensation and are meant to punish; they are awarded only in special cases such as these.
-
4. A buyer's contract price is ₹30,000; on the delivery date, the same goods cost ₹33,500 in the market and the seller fails to deliver. Ordinary damages are:
- ₹33,500
- ₹3,500
- ₹30,000
- ₹63,500
Show answer
Answer: B. Ordinary damages = market price − contract price = ₹33,500 − ₹30,000 = ₹3,500.
-
5. A token amount awarded where a right is breached but no real loss is suffered is called:
- special damages
- quantum meruit
- nominal damages
- exemplary damages
Show answer
Answer: C. Nominal damages simply recognise that the injured party's legal right was broken, without real loss.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.