- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Remedies for breach (1): rescission, specific performance and injunction
Explain rescission, when a court will and will not grant specific performance, and how an injunction enforces the negative terms of a contract.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain rescission as a remedy for breach.
- List when the court generally grants specific performance and when it does not.
- Explain injunction and the negative terms of a contract.
When a contract is broken, the injured party's first question is: what can I ask for? Sometimes the best answer is simply to walk away; sometimes money is not enough and the only fair result is that the promise be carried out; sometimes the need is to stop the other side from doing something. These are the first three remedies in the textbook.
(i) Rescission of contract
On a breach by one party, the other party may rescind (cancel) the contract. He is then absolved from all his own obligations under it. Rescission can be combined with a claim for damages for the loss caused.
(ii) Specific performance
Where damages would not be an adequate remedy, the court may direct the party in breach to actually perform the contract according to its terms. Specific performance is a discretionary remedy. The textbook lists when it is generally granted and when it is not.
The court generally grants specific performance when:
- Money compensation for non-performance would not be enough
- Money compensation is unlikely to be obtained
- There is no standard for working out the actual damage
The court does not grant specific performance when:
- Damages are an adequate remedy
- The contract is not certain
- The contract is inequitable to either party
- The contract is revocable in nature
- It is made by a trustee in breach of trust
- It is of a personal nature, such as a contract to marry
- It is made by a company beyond its Memorandum of Association (ultra vires)
- The court cannot supervise its being carried out
(iii) Injunction
An injunction is an order passed by a competent court restraining a person from doing an act. It is a way of securing the specific performance of the negative terms of a contract, that is, something a party has promised not to do. The court orders him not to do what he promised not to do. The textbook also lists situations in which a court may order an injunction: where the contract is voidable, where it becomes void, or on discovering that the contract is void.
Specific performance and injunction
-
Specific performance
- Positive order: do what you promised
- Used when money is not an adequate remedy
- Example: transfer the particular plot of land agreed
-
Injunction
- Negative order: do not do what you promised not to do
- Enforces negative terms of a contract
- Example: do not sing for a rival organiser during the agreed period
Rescission frees the injured party; specific performance makes the promise happen; injunction stops what was promised not to happen.
Worked example 1: rescission
Naveen (made-up) promises to deliver a car to Oviya on 1 January, and Oviya promises to pay for it on delivery. Naveen does not deliver. Reasoning: Naveen is in breach. Oviya may rescind the contract and is absolved from her promise to pay. She may also claim damages if she suffered loss, for example by paying more for a similar car elsewhere.
Worked example 2: which remedy fits?
(a) Pandian (made-up) agrees to sell an old family painting that is the only one of its kind, then refuses. (b) A singer agrees to perform only for one organiser during a festival season, then signs up to sing for a rival. (c) A seller refuses to deliver 100 ordinary steel chairs. Answers: (a) a unique item has no market substitute, so money is not enough: specific performance. (b) a negative term is being broken: injunction to stop her singing for the rival (the court will not force her to sing, since that is personal). (c) chairs can be bought elsewhere, so damages are adequate and specific performance will not be granted.
Key takeaways: rescission cancels the contract and frees the injured party; specific performance is ordered where money is inadequate, but not where damages suffice, terms are uncertain or unfair, the contract is personal or the court cannot supervise it; an injunction restrains a person from doing what he promised not to do.
Check your understanding
-
1. An order of a competent court restraining a person from doing some act is:
- rescission
- an injunction
- quantum meruit
- novation
Show answer
Answer: B. An injunction is a restraining order. It secures performance of the negative terms of a contract.
-
2. Specific performance is generally granted when:
- damages are an adequate remedy
- the contract is of a personal nature
- money compensation for non-performance would not be enough
- the court cannot supervise performance
Show answer
Answer: C. Specific performance is granted where money cannot adequately make good the loss. The other three are cases where it is refused.
-
3. A court will NOT grant specific performance of:
- a contract to marry
- a contract to sell a unique painting
- a contract to sell a particular plot of land
- a contract where actual damage cannot be measured
Show answer
Answer: A. Contracts of a personal nature, such as a contract to marry, are among the cases the textbook lists where specific performance is not granted.
-
4. After a breach, the injured party cancels the contract and is freed from his own obligations. This remedy is:
- injunction
- specific performance
- waiver
- rescission
Show answer
Answer: D. Rescission means cancelling the contract on breach, which absolves the injured party from his obligations.
-
5. An injunction enforces which terms of a contract?
- Terms about price
- Negative terms: things a party promised not to do
- Terms about delivery dates only
- Terms that are uncertain
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook defines injunction as a mode of securing specific performance of the negative terms of a contract.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.