• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Discharge by operation of law, and breach of contract

Explain how death, merger, insolvency and unauthorised material alteration discharge a contract by operation of law, and what breach of contract and the aggrieved party mean.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the four ways the textbook lists for discharge by operation of law.
  • Define breach of contract and the aggrieved (injured) party.
  • Name the five remedies available on breach, studied in Lessons 4 and 5.

Not every contract ends because the parties want it to. Sometimes the law itself brings it to an end, because of an event such as death or insolvency. And sometimes a contract ends badly, because one side simply refuses to keep its promise. This lesson covers both, and sets up the remedies that follow.

5. Discharge by operation of law

  1. By death: a contract that depends on the personal skill or ability of the promisor is discharged on his death. (Contracts not of a personal nature bind his legal representatives, as Chapter 30 showed.)
  2. By merger: when an inferior right and a superior right come to the same person, under the same or another contract, the inferior right merges into the superior one and ends. For example, a tenant who buys the house he rents no longer needs his tenancy: his right as owner absorbs it.
  3. By insolvency: when a person is adjudged insolvent by a court, he is discharged from the liabilities incurred before the adjudication, under the insolvency law.
  4. By unauthorised material alteration: if one party makes a material change in the terms of a written contract without the other's consent, the other party can avoid the contract.

Breach of contract

All parties to a contract are expected to perform their promises. When one party refuses or fails to perform his promise, there is a breach of contract. The party who suffers is called the aggrieved or injured party. Breach also discharges the contract in the sense that the injured party is released from his own obligations, and in place of performance he gets a right to a remedy.

Remedies for breach of contract

  • Rescission Cancel the contract and be freed from one's own obligations
  • Specific performance Court orders the promise to be carried out
  • Injunction Court orders a party not to do something
  • Quantum meruit Payment for as much as has been done
  • Damages Money compensation for loss (Section 73)
The five remedies listed in the Tamil Nadu textbook.

Breach turns a promise into a claim: the injured party is freed from his side and may seek rescission, specific performance, injunction, quantum meruit or damages.

Worked example 1: which mode of discharge?

(a) Lalitha (made-up), a tenant, buys the flat she has been renting. (b) A dance teacher engaged for six months dies after two. (c) A supplier secretly changes the quantity in a signed written order from 100 to 150 units. Answers: (a) her tenancy (inferior right) merges into ownership (superior right): merger. (b) the contract depended on her personal skill: discharge by death. (c) a material alteration without consent: the buyer can avoid the contract.

Worked example 2: spotting the breach

Mohan (made-up) agrees to supply 200 school uniforms to a school by 1 June for ₹1,40,000. On 1 June he informs the school that he will not supply them. Step 1: Mohan has refused to perform: breach of contract. Step 2: the school is the aggrieved party. Step 3: the school is released from its promise to pay ₹1,40,000 and may choose a remedy, for example rescinding the contract and claiming damages if it has to buy elsewhere at a higher price (Lesson 5).

Key takeaways: by operation of law, a contract ends on the death of a promisor whose personal skill was required, by merger of an inferior right into a superior one, by insolvency, and by an unauthorised material alteration; breach is a party's refusal or failure to perform, and the aggrieved party may seek one of five remedies.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A tenant buys the house in which he is living on rent. His tenancy ends by:

    1. novation
    2. insolvency
    3. merger
    4. waiver
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The inferior right (tenancy) merges into the superior right (ownership) now held by the same person.

  2. 2. When one party refuses to perform his promise, there is:

    1. a breach of contract
    2. a valid tender
    3. a remission
    4. an accord
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Breach of contract takes place when a party refuses or fails to perform his promise.

  3. 3. The party who suffers because of a breach is called the:

    1. promisor
    2. agent
    3. guarantor
    4. aggrieved or injured party
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The textbook calls the other party, who suffers from the breach, the aggrieved or injured party.

  4. 4. Which of these is NOT a mode of discharge by operation of law in the textbook's list?

    1. Death
    2. Insolvency
    3. Remission
    4. Unauthorised alteration
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Remission is discharge by agreement. Death, merger, insolvency and unauthorised material alteration are by operation of law.

  5. 5. If one party makes a material alteration in a written contract without the other's consent, the other party:

    1. must still perform
    2. can avoid the contract
    3. becomes insolvent
    4. must pay damages
    Show answer

    Answer: B. An unauthorised material alteration allows the other party to avoid the contract.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery