- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Discharge of contract by performance and by agreement
Explain what discharge of a contract means and how a contract ends by performance or by the parties' consent, including novation, alteration, rescission, remission, accord and satisfaction, waiver and merger.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain what discharge of a contract means.
- Explain discharge by actual and attempted performance.
- Explain discharge by agreement and each of the seven modes the textbook lists.
Every contract has a life: it is made, it runs, and it ends. When it ends, the rights and duties it created are over. The Tamil Nadu textbook calls this ending discharge of contract. Sometimes a new right arises as the old contract ends, such as a right to damages after a breach, but that new right is independent of the original contract. This lesson starts with the two most common and peaceful ways a contract is discharged.
Meaning of discharge
A contract is discharged when it ceases to operate and the rights and obligations created by it come to an end. The contractual relationship between the parties is terminated. The Act provides several modes of discharge, summarised in the diagram and explained across Lessons 1 to 3.
Modes of discharge of contract
-
By performance
- Actual performance
- Attempted performance (tender)
-
By agreement or consent
- Express consent
- Implied: novation, alteration, rescission, remission, accord and satisfaction, waiver, merger
-
By impossibility of performance
- Existing at the time of agreement
- Arising later (supervening)
-
By lapse of time
- Time limits under the Limitation Act, 1963
-
By operation of law
- Death
- Merger
- Insolvency
- Unauthorised material alteration
1. Discharge by performance
Performance means carrying out the obligations of the contract according to the real intention of the parties, and in the time and manner prescribed. As Chapter 30 explained, performance may be actual (the promise is fully carried out) or attempted (a valid tender is made and refused). Either way, the promisor is discharged.
2. Discharge by agreement or consent
What was made by agreement can be unmade by agreement. The textbook quotes the Latin maxim that a thing may be destroyed in the same manner in which it was constituted. Consent may be express, given at the time the contract is formed or later, or it may take one of the following forms, which the textbook groups under implied consent:
- Novation: a new contract is substituted for the old one, either between the same parties or with a new party. The old contract is discharged.
- Alteration: one or more terms of the contract are changed with the consent of all the parties; the original terms are discharged.
- Rescission: the parties agree to cancel all or some of the terms of the contract.
- Remission: the promisee accepts a lesser sum or a lesser performance than what was due, in full satisfaction.
- Accord and satisfaction: the parties agree to accept something different from what was promised (accord), and it is actually given (satisfaction).
- Waiver: a party deliberately gives up a right he has under the contract, releasing the other from the duty.
- Merger: an inferior right held by a person merges into a superior right acquired by the same person, so the inferior right ends.
A contract made by agreement can be ended by agreement: novation, alteration, rescission, remission, accord and satisfaction, waiver and merger.
Worked example 1: novation or alteration?
(a) Harini owes Imran ₹50,000. All three agree that Jaya (all made-up) will pay Imran instead, and Harini is released. (b) Imran and Harini agree to change the due date of the ₹50,000 from June to August. Reasoning: (a) a new contract with a new party replaces the old one: novation. (b) the same contract continues with one term changed by consent: alteration.
Worked example 2: remission
Karthik owes a wholesaler ₹40,000 (made-up). The wholesaler agrees to accept ₹35,000 in full settlement, and Karthik pays it. Working: amount given up = ₹40,000 − ₹35,000 = ₹5,000. Because the promisee freely accepted a lesser sum in full satisfaction, this is remission, and the whole debt is discharged; the wholesaler cannot later claim the ₹5,000.
Key takeaways: discharge ends the contractual relationship; a contract is discharged by actual performance or by a valid tender; it can also be discharged by express agreement or by novation, alteration, rescission, remission, accord and satisfaction, waiver or merger.
Check your understanding
-
1. Discharge of contract means:
- signing a contract
- termination of the contractual relationship between the parties
- registering a contract
- making a counter-offer
Show answer
Answer: B. A contract is discharged when it ceases to operate and the rights and obligations it created come to an end.
-
2. Substituting a new contract for an existing one is called:
- waiver
- remission
- merger
- novation
Show answer
Answer: D. Novation replaces the old contract with a new one, between the same or different parties.
-
3. A creditor accepts ₹9,000 in full settlement of a debt of ₹10,000. This is:
- remission
- alteration
- rescission
- breach
Show answer
Answer: A. Remission is acceptance of a lesser sum or performance than what was due, in full satisfaction.
-
4. Discharge by mutual agreement may involve:
- novation only
- rescission only
- novation, rescission and alteration
- alteration only
Show answer
Answer: C. Novation, rescission and alteration are all modes of discharge by agreement, along with remission, accord and satisfaction, waiver and merger.
-
5. A party deliberately gives up a right he has under a contract. This is:
- merger
- waiver
- novation
- accord
Show answer
Answer: B. Waiver means intentionally abandoning a contractual right, which releases the other party from that obligation.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.