• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Aristotle: the natural state, citizenship and the cycle of constitutions

Explain Aristotle's life and Politics, his views on the state as natural, its functions, citizenship, classification of states, slavery, family, property, leisure and revolution.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Outline Aristotle's life and why he is called the father of political science.
  • Explain his ideas of the state as natural, its function and his theory of citizenship.
  • Describe his classification of states, the cycle of change and his views on slavery, family, property and revolution.

Aristotle was Plato's student, yet he disagreed with his teacher on many things. Where Plato drew an ideal state, Aristotle looked for the best practicable state, one that could actually work. The Tamil Nadu textbook quotes William Ebenstein's view that no one in the history of political philosophy has surpassed Aristotle's encyclopaedic range.

Life and works

Aristotle was born in Stagira in 384 BCE into an upper middle-class family; his father Nicomachus was physician to King Amyntas of Macedon. He studied at Plato's Academy and, after Plato's death, founded his own school, the Lyceum, in 335 BCE. He tutored Alexander, at the request of Alexander's father, Philip II of Macedon. He wrote on subjects from literature to zoology, but his most famous work is Politics, a large work in eight books from which modern political science grew. That is why he is called the father of political science. He famously described man as by nature a political animal.

The state: natural, moral and purposeful

  • The state is natural: families could not meet people's growing needs, so they combined, through larger groups, into the state, the perfect association. The state is the individual 'writ large', because a person can seek perfection only within a state.
  • The state exists for an end: the supreme good of human beings in moral and intellectual life.
  • Functions: to promote the good life, creating conditions for people's mental, moral and physical development, and to turn good habits into good actions for a happy and honourable life.

Aristotle's growth of the state

  1. Family Natural, prior to the state; the nucleus of moral life
  2. Growing needs The family alone cannot satisfy them
  3. Families combine Wider associations form
  4. State The perfect association, existing for the good life

Citizenship

Aristotle rejected the idea that residence, legal rights or birth alone make a person a citizen. Function does: a citizen is one who takes part in the popular assembly that exercised sovereign power and shares in the decision-making of government. Citizenship for him was active participation, not a label.

Classification and the cycle of change

Aristotle classified states by quantity (one, few, many) and quality (good or perverted), giving monarchy/tyranny, aristocracy/oligarchy and polity/democracy, as you saw in Unit 6. The textbook adds his account of how one form gives way to the next:

Aristotle's cycle of constitutions, as given in the textbook

  1. Monarchy Rule of one for the common good
  2. Tyranny Monarchy degenerates
  3. Aristocracy People take power from the tyrant and give it to a few
  4. Oligarchy The few rule for themselves
  5. Polity People revolt and transfer power to the many
  6. Democracy The many lose sight of the common good; this again gives rise to monarchy

Then back to step 1: Monarchy

Slavery, family, property, leisure and revolution

Aristotle's other views, as described in the textbook
TopicAristotle's view
SlaveryThe slave is the first of the master's living property and an instrument of action, not of production; Aristotle linked slavery to a lack of virtue. (Such views are rejected today, but they show the society he lived in.)
FamilyA natural institution that existed before the state; the starting point of moral life and the nucleus of the state
PropertySupported private property as essential to a good life, but with limits; opposed abolishing it (unlike Plato's communism)
LeisureCitizens need property and leisure so they can spend time deliberating on the good life of all
RevolutionCaused by constitutional change, large or small (for example monarchy turning into tyranny), or by the state losing its purpose even without a change of constitution

Aristotle: the state is natural, exists for the good life, and is best judged by how many rule and whether they rule for all. A citizen is one who takes part in ruling.

— Summary to remember

Worked example 1: who is a citizen?

In a made-up Greek city, Kallias has lived there for 40 years and owns land but never attends or votes in the assembly; Theon, younger, sits in the assembly and helps decide laws. Applying Aristotle's test: residence and property are not enough; function is what counts. Answer: in Aristotle's sense Theon is a citizen, while Kallias, for all his years and land, is not acting as one.

Worked example 2: Plato and Aristotle on property

Question: how does Aristotle's view of property differ from Plato's? Step 1: Plato wanted his guardians to live without private property (his 'communism'). Step 2: Aristotle supported private property as essential for a normal, good life, though within limits, and opposed abolishing it. Conclusion: Aristotle is practical where Plato is ideal, which fits his search for the best practicable state.

Key takeaways: Aristotle, founder of the Lyceum and author of Politics, is the father of political science. He saw the state as natural and existing for the good life, defined the citizen by participation, classified states by number and quality with a cycle of change, defended limited private property and explained revolution by constitutional change or loss of purpose.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Aristotle is called the father of political science mainly because:

    1. he founded the Academy
    2. modern political science grew from his work Politics
    3. he wrote The Republic
    4. he was the first king of Macedon
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook says modern political science grew from Politics, which is why Aristotle is called its father. Plato founded the Academy and wrote The Republic.

  2. 2. According to Aristotle, what entitles a person to be a citizen?

    1. Function: taking part in the assembly and in decision-making
    2. Birth in the city
    3. Long residence
    4. Owning property
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Aristotle said it is function that entitles a person to citizenship: participating in the sovereign assembly and in government decisions. Birth, residence or legal rights alone are not enough.

  3. 3. The school founded by Aristotle in 335 BCE was the:

    1. Academy
    2. Stoa
    3. Lyceum
    4. Seminary
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Aristotle founded the Lyceum after Plato's death. The Academy was Plato's school.

  4. 4. According to Aristotle, revolutions can occur even without any change in the constitution when:

    1. the king has no son
    2. the state's population grows
    3. the citizens have too much leisure
    4. the state loses its purpose
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Aristotle gave two causes: constitutional change, large or small, and the loss of the state's purpose even though the constitution is unchanged.

  5. 5. Which statement about Aristotle's view of property is correct?

    1. He wanted all property abolished
    2. He supported private property with limits and opposed its abolition
    3. He thought property had no link with a good life
    4. He gave all property to the state
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Aristotle saw private property as essential for a good and normal life, prescribed limits to it, and objected to abolishing it.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery