- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Plato: the ideal state, justice and the philosopher king
Explain Plato's life and works, his ideal state of three classes, his theory of justice, his plan of education, his views on democracy and constitutions, and the dialectical method.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Outline Plato's life, the Academy and his three main works.
- Explain how his theory of justice links the three parts of the soul with the three classes of the ideal state.
- Describe his plan of education, his criticism of democracy, his classification of constitutions and his dialectical method.
Unit 7 of the Tamil Nadu textbook introduces nine thinkers whose ideas still shape how we argue about the state, from ancient Athens to industrial Europe. It begins with Plato, whom the textbook calls the most influential political philosopher of all time. Every thinker, it reminds us, is a child of his own time, and Plato's time was one of turmoil in Athens.
Life and works
Plato was born around 428/427 BCE into an aristocratic family of Athens, a Greek city-state. His real name was Aristocles; one account says his wrestling coach named him 'Platon', meaning broad, because of his build. He was a disciple of Socrates, and most of what we know about Socrates comes from Plato's writings. When the Athenian democracy condemned Socrates to death for his teachings, Plato was deeply shaken, and this shaped his politics. Around 387 BCE he founded the Academy, named after the Athenian hero Akademos, where he taught a political philosophy that included ethics, mathematics and the study of society. His three major works are The Republic, The Statesman and The Laws.
The ideal state and the idea of justice
Plato's ideal state, the best state for human beings to live in, is made of three classes: a ruling class, a military (auxiliary) class and an economic (producing) class. Why three? His theory of justice answers this. Plato held that justice lives both in the individual and in the state. Every person has three qualities in different proportions, which are the three parts of the soul:
| Part of the soul | Seat (as Plato placed it) | Matching class in the ideal state |
|---|---|---|
| Reason | Head | Ruling class (philosopher kings) |
| Spirit | Heart | Military or auxiliary class |
| Appetite | Stomach | Economic or producing class |
Justice in a person means each part doing its own proper work, so that the person is whole. Justice in the state means the same pattern written large: each class doing its own work and not interfering in the work of others.
For Plato, justice is each part doing its own proper work: reason ruling, spirit defending, appetite producing, in the soul and in the state alike.
Education
Plato's education as a series of eliminations
- Education for all children Stages suited to age, from childhood to adulthood
- First elimination Those suited to economic work are separated from those fit to rule or fight
- Second elimination Those fit to rule are separated from the soldiers
- Special training The few with most reason become philosopher kings
Plato also saw children as a national possession: the state had a duty to bring them up according to their aptitudes.
Democracy and constitutions
In The Republic Plato practically condemned democracy. Not everyone, he argued, is fit to rule; only specially trained philosophers should. The textbook links this to the execution of Socrates by the Athenian democracy. By 'constitution' Plato meant a whole way of life of a people, including customs and traditions as well as government. He named five constitutions and a tendency for each to decline into the next:
Plato's sequence of decline
- Aristocracy Rule of the best
- Timocracy Rule linked to honour and property
- Oligarchy Rule of the wealthy few
- Democracy Rule of the many
- Tyranny Rule of one in his own interest
The dialectical method
The Republic is written as a conversation in which questions are put to Socrates and he answers. This is the dialectical method: the learner starts with a vague idea and asks questions, the answers are questioned again, and step by step the idea is reformulated until the best understanding is reached. It differs from the didactic method, in which a teacher simply tells students what the teacher knows.
Worked example 1: matching soul and class
A young person in Plato's state is brave and loyal, but not especially reflective. Step 1: courage and loyalty come from spirit. Step 2: the class matching spirit is the military or auxiliary class. Answer: Plato's education would guide this person to the military class, not to ruling or producing.
Worked example 2: dialectic or didactic?
In a made-up class, a student says 'justice means paying back what you owe'. The teacher asks, 'Should you return a borrowed knife to a friend who has become violent?' The student revises the definition, and the teacher questions it again. Reasoning: the learner's idea is questioned and reformed rather than replaced by a lecture. Answer: this is the dialectical method.
Key takeaways: Plato, Socrates's disciple and founder of the Academy, built his ideal state on three classes matching reason, spirit and appetite. Justice is each part doing its own work. His education system selects philosopher kings, he distrusted democracy after Socrates's death, he classified five constitutions in a line of decline, and he taught through dialectic.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to the textbook, Plato's real name was:
- Akademos
- Ariston
- Aristocles
- Nicomachus
Show answer
Answer: C. Plato's real name was Aristocles. Akademos was the hero after whom the Academy was named, Ariston of Argos is named as his wrestling coach, and Nicomachus was Aristotle's father.
-
2. In Plato's scheme, the part of the soul that matches the ruling class is:
- Reason
- Spirit
- Appetite
- Courage
Show answer
Answer: A. Reason, seated in the head, matches the ruling class of philosopher kings. Spirit matches the military class and appetite the economic class.
-
3. Why, according to the textbook, did Plato practically condemn democracy in The Republic?
- Because democracy made Athens too rich
- Because Aristotle persuaded him
- Because democracy gave power to philosophers
- Because the Athenian democracy had condemned his teacher Socrates to death
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook links Plato's contempt for democracy to the execution of Socrates by the Athenian democracy, and to his belief that only trained philosophers should rule.
-
4. Which sequence shows Plato's line of decline of constitutions correctly?
- Aristocracy, oligarchy, timocracy, tyranny, democracy
- Aristocracy, timocracy, oligarchy, democracy, tyranny
- Monarchy, aristocracy, polity, democracy, tyranny
- Timocracy, aristocracy, democracy, oligarchy, tyranny
Show answer
Answer: B. Plato said aristocracy tends to degenerate into timocracy, timocracy into oligarchy, oligarchy into democracy and democracy into tyranny.
-
5. A method in which a learner's vague idea is questioned and reformulated again and again until it becomes clear is called:
- Didactic
- Inductive
- Dialectical
- Behavioural
Show answer
Answer: C. This is the dialectical method that Plato used in The Republic. The didactic method is a teacher telling students what the teacher knows.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.