- Practice
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
John Stuart Mill and Karl Marx: liberty, representation and class struggle
Explain Mill's On Liberty and Considerations on Representative Government, then Marx's main works, dialectical materialism, surplus value, class struggle, the dictatorship of the proletariat and the withering away of the state.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain Mill's harm (self-protection) principle, his defence of individuality and his views on representative government.
- Describe Marx's main works, dialectical materialism and the theory of surplus value.
- Explain class struggle, the dictatorship of the proletariat and the withering away of the state, with the textbook's assessment.
The chapter closes with two nineteenth-century thinkers who responded very differently to the new democratic and industrial societies of Europe. Mill feared that the majority would crush the individual; Marx argued that the capitalist economy divided society into classes that would one day be abolished.
John Stuart Mill (1806-1873)
Mill was born in London in 1806, the son of James Mill, and was trained from childhood by his father and Jeremy Bentham, the leading utilitarians. The textbook divides his development into three periods: that early training; his recovery from a mental crisis in his twenties, when he reshaped his thinking; and some thirty years of major works, including A System of Logic, Principles of Political Economy, On Liberty and Considerations on Representative Government. Although trained in utilitarianism, the idea of the greatest happiness of the greatest number, he gave it a different interpretation of his own.
On Liberty (1859)
Mill saw that as societies became democratic, the majority could become more powerful than any monarch, and not only through law: social pressure and expectation could force everyone to conform in thought, character and action. On Liberty therefore states one simple principle: the only purpose for which people, singly or together, may interfere with anyone's liberty of action is self-protection. The book then defends:
- Freedom of thought and discussion (argued against controls on expression).
- Freedom of character, or individuality: good for the person and for society. Mill compared human nature to a tree that must grow on all sides by its own inner forces, not a machine built to a pattern. Variety of character and culture drives a nation forward.
- Protection from social as well as legal coercion: he contrasted the self-denial of Victorian society with the Greek ideal of self-development.
Considerations on Representative Government (1861)
Mill was a convinced democrat, yet worried about the tyranny of the majority: he argued that the majority has power but the minority often has wisdom. He concluded that the ideal is representative government, with sovereignty in the whole community, every citizen having a voice and, at least sometimes, an actual part in public functions, local or national. The textbook stresses how strongly Mill valued the vote, comparing it to the air a political animal breathes.
Karl Marx (1818-1883)
For Marx, a theory should not only explain the world but help change it. His thought drew on earlier thinkers such as Hegel, Saint-Simon, Ricardo, Fourier and Louis Blanc, and was shaped by the 'dual revolution': the French Revolution of 1789 and the Industrial Revolution. His works aim at the self-emancipation of the working class.
| Work or idea | Main point |
|---|---|
| The Communist Manifesto (1848, with Friedrich Engels) | The history of all existing society is the history of class struggle. In feudal society the struggle was between landowners and those who worked the land; in modern industry it is between the bourgeoisie (owners) and the proletariat (workers). Aims: raise the proletariat to ruling class, win the battle of democracy, replace private property with public control |
| Das Kapital (vol. 1, 1867) | Called the 'Bible of the working class'. Volume 1 deals with the production of capital; volumes 2 and 3, edited by Engels and published in 1885 and 1894, with its circulation and the whole process |
| Dialectical materialism | Society is material and always in motion; change comes through the struggle of opposites, as contradictions within society build up and produce change |
| Surplus value | Labour is the source of value. The worker is paid less than the value his labour creates, often only enough to live on; the difference, kept by the capitalist, is surplus value |
Marx's path from class struggle to a classless society
- Class division Bourgeoisie own the means of production; proletariat sell their labour
- Class struggle and revolution Workers become conscious of exploitation and overthrow bourgeois rule
- Dictatorship of the proletariat A transitional period: workers hold state power and take over production
- Classless society Class differences and antagonisms disappear
- Withering away of the state With no classes to oppress, the state is no longer needed
Marx drew his account of class struggle partly from France in 1848-1850 (The Class Struggles in France): bourgeoisie and workers fought together to set up a republic, but the bourgeoisie then used the state and army against the workers. For Marx the state, in a class society, is an instrument of exploitation; hence it would wither away once classes vanished.
The textbook's assessment: Marx's influence is compared to that of religion; his ideas influenced leaders such as Lenin, Stalin and Mao, and countries including Russia, China, Cuba and Vietnam. The textbook notes that most former communist countries have since become democratic, but argues that because class differences and exploitation persist, Marx's ideas cannot be ignored. Later debates produced Neo-Marxism.
Mill: the only ground for interfering with a person's liberty is self-protection. Marx: class struggle leads through the dictatorship of the proletariat to a classless society in which the state withers away.
Worked example 1: applying Mill's principle
Case (made up): (i) a law forbids people from wearing unusual clothes; (ii) a law forbids driving after drinking. Test: is the restriction needed for self-protection, that is, to prevent harm to others? (i) Unusual clothes harm no one else, so Mill would oppose the law, and would also oppose social pressure that forced everyone to dress alike. (ii) Drunk driving endangers others, so restriction is justified. Answer: Mill would accept (ii) but not (i).
Worked example 2: surplus value with made-up figures
Suppose (made-up numbers) a worker's day of labour adds goods worth ₹1,200 to the materials, and the worker is paid ₹500. Step 1: value created by labour = ₹1,200. Step 2: wage paid = ₹500. Step 3: surplus value = ₹1,200 − ₹500 = ₹700, kept by the owner. Check: ₹500 + ₹700 = ₹1,200. In Marx's theory this gap between what labour produces and what it is paid is the source of profit and of exploitation.
Key takeaways: Mill defended liberty of thought, discussion and individuality against both state and social pressure, limited interference to self-protection, and favoured representative government with active citizens. Marx explained history as class struggle, introduced dialectical materialism and surplus value, and predicted revolution, a dictatorship of the proletariat, a classless society and the withering away of the state.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to Mill's On Liberty, the only purpose for which people may interfere with someone's liberty of action is:
- religious duty
- economic growth
- self-protection
- the wishes of the majority
Show answer
Answer: C. Mill's one simple principle is that self-protection is the sole end that warrants interference with anyone's liberty of action. He specifically feared majority pressure.
-
2. Mill compared human nature to:
- a tree that must grow on all sides by its own inner forces
- a machine built to a model
- a soldier obeying orders
- a river flowing to the sea
Show answer
Answer: A. Mill said human nature is not a machine built after a model but a tree that needs to grow and develop on all sides, which is his argument for individuality.
-
3. Which work is described in the textbook as the 'Bible of the working class'?
- The Communist Manifesto
- Principles of Political Economy
- Leviathan
- Das Kapital
Show answer
Answer: D. Das Kapital (first volume 1867) was called the Bible of the working class. The Communist Manifesto (1848) was Marx's joint work with Engels.
-
4. In Marx's theory, the 'dictatorship of the proletariat' is:
- the permanent rule of a single leader
- a transitional period in which the working class holds state power between the overthrow of bourgeois rule and a classless society
- rule by landowners
- the final stage after the state has withered away
Show answer
Answer: B. Marx used the phrase for the working class taking state power during the transition from bourgeois rule to a classless society; the withering away of the state comes after it.
-
5. Using made-up figures: a worker's labour creates goods worth ₹900 in a day and the worker is paid ₹350. What is the surplus value in Marx's sense?
- ₹350
- ₹1,250
- ₹550
- ₹900
Show answer
Answer: C. Surplus value = value created − wage paid = ₹900 − ₹350 = ₹550. Check: ₹350 + ₹550 = ₹900.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.