• Practice
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

St. Thomas Aquinas and Machiavelli: from faith and law to statecraft

Explain Aquinas's four kinds of law, his Aristotelian view of the state and the church-state relation, then Machiavelli's view of human nature, separation of politics from morality and religion, method and statecraft.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the four levels of law in Aquinas's Summa Theologica and his view of the state and the church.
  • Describe Machiavelli's view of human nature and his separation of politics from ethics and religion.
  • Explain Machiavelli's method, his double standard of morality and the purpose behind his advice.

This lesson brings together two thinkers who sit on either side of a great change. Aquinas, in the thirteenth century, joined Aristotle's ideas with Christian faith. Machiavelli, in Renaissance Italy, broke politics free of both religion and conventional morality.

St. Thomas Aquinas (1224/1225-1274)

Aquinas was born in the family castle of Roccasecca, north of Naples. In his century Aristotle's Politics re-emerged in Western Europe, and its secular ideas clashed with the religious ideas of Augustine accepted by the Church. Aquinas was the greatest of the theologians who reconciled the two. In the nineteenth century Pope Leo XIII declared his system to be official Catholic philosophy, and his tradition is called Thomism. His works include Summa Contra Gentiles (described as a manual defending Christian beliefs, for missionaries working in Spain), Summa Theologica and On Kingship.

Aquinas's four levels of law (united by reason)

  • Eternal law
    • Reason at work in the whole universe
    • The natural and ethical order set by God
    • Highest and most comprehensive
  • Divine law
    • A special part of eternal law
    • God's word revealed in Scripture
  • Natural law
    • Moral law found by reason alone (an idea going back to the Stoics)
    • The rational creature's share in eternal law
    • Example: we know murder is wrong without a criminal code
  • Human law
    • Human reason applying natural law
    • To particular earthly conditions

In On Kingship, Aquinas closely follows Aristotle. The state is natural, because humans are social and political animals; animals that live in herds do this by instinct, humans by reason. Political activity is necessary and good; the state is a moral community aiming at the good of its members; the best should rule for the public good, under law; and constitutions are classified, as by Aristotle, by number and quality. Aquinas departs from Aristotle in holding that all power comes from God, but he sees the ruler as natural (without binding decisions there would be anarchy) and as the representative of the governed.

On church and state, the textbook says each has a separate role and end, and the state does not depend on the church. But the church is not subordinate to the state, and the state must take the church into account because the church's end is higher. Aquinas compares them to body and soul: each has its role, but the soul's purpose is loftier.

Niccolo Machiavelli (1469-1527)

Born in Florence, the centre of the Italian Renaissance, Machiavelli served the republican government from 1498 to 1512 as Secretary to the Chancellery, dealing with diplomatic, military and administrative affairs. When the Medici returned in 1512 he lost his post and was briefly imprisoned. He then wrote The Prince (1513, addressed to Lorenzo de' Medici) and the Discourses on Livy (completed 1517); both were published after his death, in 1531.

  • Human nature: like Hobbes, deeply pessimistic. People are selfish, ungrateful, fickle and greedy, and become good only by necessity. Hence a ruler should prefer being feared to being loved: love is a bond people break when it suits them, but fear holds. People judge by appearances, and the ruler should trust his own judgement rather than his councillors.
  • Material gain: people love property; in the Discourses he says this is why they prefer a republic, where there are more chances of gain, to a monarchy.
  • Politics separated from morality and religion: Greek thought, and Plato, Aristotle and Aquinas, saw an ethical purpose in the state. Machiavelli gave politics its own standards. The prince should concentrate on preserving the state, setting aside traditional morality if success requires it, because his success will be judged by popular verdict.

Method: Machiavelli thought the right method was historical: human passions do not change, so the past helps explain the present and predict the future. He relied on observing behaviour and has been called a pioneer of behaviouralism. Critics reply that his method was only superficially scientific, neither truly inductive nor deductive, and that he ignored central questions such as why the state exists. George H. Sabine saw no inconsistency between his two books: both study how states rise, decline and are made lasting, The Prince for monarchies and the Discourses for the Roman republic.

Statecraft: Machiavelli set out a double standard of morality: the ruler's 'morality' is total commitment to strengthening the state, keeping order and defending it, judged by success, while servants and citizens must follow conventional morality. The ruler should give people security of life, property and honour, and so win their loyalty. The textbook's assessment is that he did not mean to destroy morality: as a patriot he wanted a strong nation-state in an Italy divided into five parts (Florence, Venice, Naples, Milan and the Church's territory). He preferred a republic but advised monarchy for the Italy of his time.

Aquinas and Machiavelli compared

  • Aquinas
    • State is natural and moral
    • Law rests on reason and God
    • Church's end higher than the state's
    • Politics serves virtue and salvation
  • Machiavelli
    • State is a tool of power
    • Politics has its own standards
    • Religion and ethics kept out of statecraft
    • Success of the state is the test

Aquinas joined Aristotle with Christian faith through four levels of law. Machiavelli separated politics from ethics and religion and judged the ruler by success in preserving the state.

— Summary to remember

Worked example 1: which level of law?

A made-up village has no written rule against cheating a blind shopkeeper, yet everyone knows it is wrong. Later the village council passes a by-law fining anyone who cheats customers. Step 1: the shared sense of wrong is reached by reason alone, so it is natural law. Step 2: the by-law applies that principle to local conditions, so it is human law. Answer: natural law, then human law.

Worked example 2: feared or loved?

Why did Machiavelli advise a prince to prefer being feared to being loved? Step 1: his premise is that people are selfish. Step 2: love depends on obligation, which selfish people break when their interest demands. Step 3: fear of punishment lasts whatever their interest. Conclusion: given his view of human nature, fear is the more dependable bond, though the textbook notes he also wanted the prince to be held in high esteem and to protect the people's life, property and honour.

Key takeaways: Aquinas reconciled Aristotle with Christianity, described eternal, divine, natural and human law, saw the state as natural, and gave the church a loftier end. Machiavelli, a Florentine patriot, held a pessimistic view of people, separated politics from ethics and religion, used a historical method and taught a double standard of morality for rulers.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In Aquinas's scheme, the moral law that human beings can discover by reason alone, without a written code, is:

    1. Eternal law
    2. Divine law
    3. Human law
    4. Natural law
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Natural law is the moral law found by reason alone and is the rational creature's share in eternal law. Divine law is revealed in Scripture; human law applies natural law to particular conditions.

  2. 2. Aquinas compared the relationship of the church and the state to that of:

    1. master and slave
    2. soul and body
    3. father and son
    4. king and parliament
    Show answer

    Answer: B. He likened church and state to soul and body: each has a separate role, but the soul's purpose is loftier.

  3. 3. Machiavelli wrote The Prince in 1513 and addressed it to:

    1. Lorenzo de' Medici
    2. Pope Leo XIII
    3. Philip II of Macedon
    4. William III
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The Prince was addressed to Lorenzo de' Medici. Pope Leo XIII is linked with Aquinas, Philip II with Aristotle, and William III with Locke.

  4. 4. Machiavelli has been called a pioneer of behaviouralism because he:

    1. based politics on revealed scripture
    2. used only deductive logic from first principles
    3. studied politics through history and observed human behaviour
    4. rejected any study of the past
    Show answer

    Answer: C. He placed politics on a historical and realistic foundation and relied on observing political behaviour, which is why he is called a pioneer of behaviouralism.

  5. 5. Machiavelli's 'double standard of morality' means:

    1. the ruler is judged by success in strengthening the state, while citizens must follow conventional morality
    2. the ruler and citizens follow exactly the same moral rules
    3. religion decides what is moral for everyone
    4. citizens may break moral rules but the ruler may not
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The ruler's morality is commitment to the state's strength, order and defence, judged by success; servants and citizens must keep to conventional morality, or the state's purpose is defeated.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery