• Practice
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

The social contract thinkers: Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau

Compare the views of Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau on human nature, the state of nature, the social contract and sovereignty, including Locke's limited government and Rousseau's general will.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain Hobbes's view of human nature, the state of nature as war, the social contract and absolute sovereignty.
  • Explain Locke's peaceful state of nature, its three defects, his two contracts and limited government.
  • Explain Rousseau's state of nature, the origin of inequality, the general will and popular sovereignty.

Why should anyone obey the state? Medieval thinkers answered: because rulers have divine sanction. The social contract thinkers gave a modern, secular answer: government is legitimate because people have consented to it. All three imagine life before the state (the state of nature), then a contract that creates it, but they reach very different conclusions.

Thomas Hobbes (1588-1679)

Hobbes, an English philosopher of the age of the scientific revolution, was born prematurely in Malmesbury in 1588, when the Spanish Armada was sighted; he later wrote that fear and he were born twins. He studied at Oxford, tutored William Cavendish and translated Thucydides. His main works are De Cive and Leviathan, which tries to build politics on a model of human psychology drawn from Galileo's physics.

  • Human nature: people are driven by passions and use their intellect to seek the most pleasure and least pain. The one desire common to all is power, a restless desire for power after power that ends only in death. So people are self-interested and naturally anti-social; 'Hobbesian' has come to mean this pessimistic view.
  • State of nature: absolute liberty (no laws, a right to everything) and absolute equality (roughly equal strength and intellect). The result is a war of all against all, with everyone living in constant fear.
  • Social contract: the state is created by mutual agreement; government is legitimate only as far as people have consented. Hobbes saw this as a logical, scientific analysis of the state.
  • Sovereignty: individuals hand over all power, and the sovereign holds it absolutely, so it can always enforce order. It may be one person or an assembly, though Hobbes preferred one. Liberty lies where the law is silent.

The textbook's assessment: Hobbes began a materialist, non-Aristotelian understanding of politics and influenced Locke, Rousseau and Kant.

John Locke (1632-1704)

Locke, called the father of philosophical liberalism, was born at Wrington in Somerset. After the Glorious Revolution of 1688 he returned to London and served William III. His works include A Letter Concerning Toleration (1689), An Essay Concerning Human Understanding (1690), Two Treatises of Government (1690) and Some Thoughts Concerning Education (1693).

  • Human nature: not pessimistic. Reason shapes human beings, who are social, rational, decent and capable of self-rule; they are naturally equal and free, and seek pleasure over pain.
  • State of nature: peaceful, with perfect freedom and equality under natural law, which gives rights and duties and is known through reason. It has three defects: no established law, no known and impartial judge, and no executive power to enforce decisions. The state remedies them. (The textbook notes this state of nature is a fiction, not history.)
  • Two contracts: the first creates civil society, the second sets up government. Consent is the bedrock. People do not surrender their natural rights; the state exists to protect them, so the contract is a 'charter of liberty', and people may resist a tyrannical government.
  • Limited sovereignty and separation of powers: absolute sovereignty is rejected. Power is divided among the legislature (the supreme power), the executive (including judicial power) and the federative power (external relations).

Locke's influence reached Voltaire, Diderot, Rousseau and the French Revolution; the textbook quotes Parrington's view that his Two Treatises became the textbook of the American Revolution, and Laski's judgement that Locke saw the conquest of freedom as the main problem of the state.

Jean-Jacques Rousseau (1712-1778)

Rousseau was born in Geneva and had an unsettled youth. In 1750 he won the Academy of Dijon's prize for an essay arguing about whether the arts and sciences had improved or corrupted morals. His major works, The New Heloise (1761), Emile (1762) and The Social Contract (1762), drew condemnation in his lifetime.

  • State of nature: perfect liberty, equality and innocence; people lived simply, alone, content and self-sufficient.
  • Its end: changes in climate and soil, organised work and above all private property split society into rich and poor and brought inequality, wars and the division into masters and slaves. Rousseau famously said the first man who fenced land, called it his and found others simple enough to believe him founded civil society. His call to 'return to nature' meant the rule of nature, not the destruction of society.
  • Social contract: each person places himself and all his power under the supreme direction of the general will and becomes an indivisible part of the whole. Unlike Hobbes and Locke, he proposes a total surrender to the community, not to a ruler. The state formed is a moral body with a will of its own. Natural liberty is exchanged for civil liberty and property rights, and obeying a law we prescribe for ourselves is true liberty.
  • Sovereignty and the general will: sovereignty is inalienable, indivisible, absolute and permanent, and belongs to the general will, which is popular sovereignty. Office-holders are only agents. The general will aims at the common good, unlike the will of all, which is a sum of private interests; it comes from all and applies to all, and cannot be represented.

Judgements of Rousseau vary, as the textbook shows: G. D. H. Cole praised The Social Contract as the best textbook of political philosophy, while Lord Morley wondered whether the world would have been better if Rousseau had never been born, because of his influence on the French Revolution. Critics also say that the general will can excuse a 'tyranny of the majority'.

Three social contract thinkers compared
PointHobbesLockeRousseau
Human natureSelfish, power-seeking, anti-socialRational, social, decentInnocent and content in nature
State of natureWar of all against allPeace under natural law, with three defectsIdyllic, until property brought inequality
What is given upAll power, to the sovereignNatural rights are kept; the state protects themEverything, to the community (general will)
SovereigntyAbsolute, preferably one rulerLimited, with separation of powersPopular, inalienable and indivisible
ResistanceNot allowedAllowed against tyrannySovereign is the people itself

Hobbes: fear leads to an absolute sovereign. Locke: reason and rights lead to limited government. Rousseau: equality and the general will lead to popular sovereignty.

— Comparison to remember

Worked example 1: identify the thinker

Statement: 'People keep their natural rights after the contract, and if the government turns tyrannical they may replace it.' Step 1: Hobbes allows no resistance and gives the sovereign all power. Step 2: Rousseau's surrender is to the community, not a government that might be tyrannical. Step 3: keeping rights and the right to resist are Locke's. Answer: John Locke.

Worked example 2: general will or will of all?

In a made-up housing colony, every family votes for the road to be repaired only outside its own house. Adding up these votes gives the will of all, a sum of private interests. If instead residents ask which repairs serve the whole colony and agree on the most dangerous stretch first, they are seeking the general will, aimed at the common good and applying to everyone.

Key takeaways: all three base government on consent. Hobbes's war of all against all leads to an absolute sovereign; Locke's peaceful but defective state of nature leads to a limited government that protects rights; Rousseau's innocent state of nature, spoilt by property, leads to the general will and popular sovereignty.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which thinker described the state of nature as a war of all against all?

    1. John Locke
    2. Jean-Jacques Rousseau
    3. Thomas Hobbes
    4. Thomas Aquinas
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Hobbes held that absolute liberty and equality without law lead to a war of all against all. Locke and Rousseau saw the state of nature as peaceful.

  2. 2. Which of the following is NOT one of the three defects of the state of nature identified by Locke?

    1. Absence of an established law
    2. Absence of a known and impartial judge
    3. Absence of an executive power to enforce decisions
    4. Absence of private property
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Locke's three defects are the lack of law, of an impartial judge and of an executive to enforce decisions. Property existed in his state of nature; protecting it is a purpose of government.

  3. 3. Locke divided the powers of government into the legislature, the executive and the:

    1. federative power
    2. judiciary as a separate fourth power
    3. church
    4. monarchy
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Locke's three powers are the legislature (supreme), the executive (including judicial power) and the federative power, which handles external relations.

  4. 4. According to Rousseau, how does the general will differ from the will of all?

    1. The general will is the will of the king
    2. The general will aims at the common good, while the will of all is a sum of private interests
    3. They are the same thing
    4. The will of all is always right
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Rousseau distinguished the general will, which seeks the common good and applies to all, from the will of all, which merely adds up private interests.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Locke called his social contract a charter of liberty. Reason (R): In Locke's contract individuals do not surrender their natural rights, since the state exists to protect them.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The textbook says Locke's contract is a charter of liberty rather than a licence for subjugation, precisely because people keep their rights and the state is their protector. R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery