Revision notes

Unit 7 Political Thought: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Plato: the ideal state, justice and the philosopher king

Plato's parallel between the soul and the state
Part of the soulSeat (as Plato placed it)Matching class in the ideal state
ReasonHeadRuling class (philosopher kings)
SpiritHeartMilitary or auxiliary class
AppetiteStomachEconomic or producing class

For Plato, justice is each part doing its own proper work: reason ruling, spirit defending, appetite producing, in the soul and in the state alike.

— Plato's idea of justice, in our own words

Plato's education as a series of eliminations

  1. Education for all children Stages suited to age, from childhood to adulthood
  2. First elimination Those suited to economic work are separated from those fit to rule or fight
  3. Second elimination Those fit to rule are separated from the soldiers
  4. Special training The few with most reason become philosopher kings

Plato's sequence of decline

  1. Aristocracy Rule of the best
  2. Timocracy Rule linked to honour and property
  3. Oligarchy Rule of the wealthy few
  4. Democracy Rule of the many
  5. Tyranny Rule of one in his own interest

Key takeaways: Plato, Socrates's disciple and founder of the Academy, built his ideal state on three classes matching reason, spirit and appetite. Justice is each part doing its own work. His education system selects philosopher kings, he distrusted democracy after Socrates's death, he classified five constitutions in a line of decline, and he taught through dialectic.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Aristotle: the natural state, citizenship and the cycle of constitutions

Aristotle's growth of the state

  1. Family Natural, prior to the state; the nucleus of moral life
  2. Growing needs The family alone cannot satisfy them
  3. Families combine Wider associations form
  4. State The perfect association, existing for the good life

Aristotle's cycle of constitutions, as given in the textbook

  1. Monarchy Rule of one for the common good
  2. Tyranny Monarchy degenerates
  3. Aristocracy People take power from the tyrant and give it to a few
  4. Oligarchy The few rule for themselves
  5. Polity People revolt and transfer power to the many
  6. Democracy The many lose sight of the common good; this again gives rise to monarchy

Then back to step 1: Monarchy

Aristotle's other views, as described in the textbook
TopicAristotle's view
SlaveryThe slave is the first of the master's living property and an instrument of action, not of production; Aristotle linked slavery to a lack of virtue. (Such views are rejected today, but they show the society he lived in.)
FamilyA natural institution that existed before the state; the starting point of moral life and the nucleus of the state
PropertySupported private property as essential to a good life, but with limits; opposed abolishing it (unlike Plato's communism)
LeisureCitizens need property and leisure so they can spend time deliberating on the good life of all
RevolutionCaused by constitutional change, large or small (for example monarchy turning into tyranny), or by the state losing its purpose even without a change of constitution

Aristotle: the state is natural, exists for the good life, and is best judged by how many rule and whether they rule for all. A citizen is one who takes part in ruling.

— Summary to remember

Key takeaways: Aristotle, founder of the Lyceum and author of Politics, is the father of political science. He saw the state as natural and existing for the good life, defined the citizen by participation, classified states by number and quality with a cycle of change, defended limited private property and explained revolution by constitutional change or loss of purpose.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

St. Thomas Aquinas and Machiavelli: from faith and law to statecraft

Aquinas's four levels of law (united by reason)

  • Eternal law
    • Reason at work in the whole universe
    • The natural and ethical order set by God
    • Highest and most comprehensive
  • Divine law
    • A special part of eternal law
    • God's word revealed in Scripture
  • Natural law
    • Moral law found by reason alone (an idea going back to the Stoics)
    • The rational creature's share in eternal law
    • Example: we know murder is wrong without a criminal code
  • Human law
    • Human reason applying natural law
    • To particular earthly conditions

Aquinas and Machiavelli compared

  • Aquinas
    • State is natural and moral
    • Law rests on reason and God
    • Church's end higher than the state's
    • Politics serves virtue and salvation
  • Machiavelli
    • State is a tool of power
    • Politics has its own standards
    • Religion and ethics kept out of statecraft
    • Success of the state is the test

Aquinas joined Aristotle with Christian faith through four levels of law. Machiavelli separated politics from ethics and religion and judged the ruler by success in preserving the state.

— Summary to remember

Key takeaways: Aquinas reconciled Aristotle with Christianity, described eternal, divine, natural and human law, saw the state as natural, and gave the church a loftier end. Machiavelli, a Florentine patriot, held a pessimistic view of people, separated politics from ethics and religion, used a historical method and taught a double standard of morality for rulers.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

The social contract thinkers: Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau

Three social contract thinkers compared
PointHobbesLockeRousseau
Human natureSelfish, power-seeking, anti-socialRational, social, decentInnocent and content in nature
State of natureWar of all against allPeace under natural law, with three defectsIdyllic, until property brought inequality
What is given upAll power, to the sovereignNatural rights are kept; the state protects themEverything, to the community (general will)
SovereigntyAbsolute, preferably one rulerLimited, with separation of powersPopular, inalienable and indivisible
ResistanceNot allowedAllowed against tyrannySovereign is the people itself

Hobbes: fear leads to an absolute sovereign. Locke: reason and rights lead to limited government. Rousseau: equality and the general will lead to popular sovereignty.

— Comparison to remember

Key takeaways: all three base government on consent. Hobbes's war of all against all leads to an absolute sovereign; Locke's peaceful but defective state of nature leads to a limited government that protects rights; Rousseau's innocent state of nature, spoilt by property, leads to the general will and popular sovereignty.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

John Stuart Mill and Karl Marx: liberty, representation and class struggle

Marx's key works and ideas, as described in the textbook
Work or ideaMain point
The Communist Manifesto (1848, with Friedrich Engels)The history of all existing society is the history of class struggle. In feudal society the struggle was between landowners and those who worked the land; in modern industry it is between the bourgeoisie (owners) and the proletariat (workers). Aims: raise the proletariat to ruling class, win the battle of democracy, replace private property with public control
Das Kapital (vol. 1, 1867)Called the 'Bible of the working class'. Volume 1 deals with the production of capital; volumes 2 and 3, edited by Engels and published in 1885 and 1894, with its circulation and the whole process
Dialectical materialismSociety is material and always in motion; change comes through the struggle of opposites, as contradictions within society build up and produce change
Surplus valueLabour is the source of value. The worker is paid less than the value his labour creates, often only enough to live on; the difference, kept by the capitalist, is surplus value

Marx's path from class struggle to a classless society

  1. Class division Bourgeoisie own the means of production; proletariat sell their labour
  2. Class struggle and revolution Workers become conscious of exploitation and overthrow bourgeois rule
  3. Dictatorship of the proletariat A transitional period: workers hold state power and take over production
  4. Classless society Class differences and antagonisms disappear
  5. Withering away of the state With no classes to oppress, the state is no longer needed

Mill: the only ground for interfering with a person's liberty is self-protection. Marx: class struggle leads through the dictatorship of the proletariat to a classless society in which the state withers away.

— Summary to remember

Key takeaways: Mill defended liberty of thought, discussion and individuality against both state and social pressure, limited interference to self-protection, and favoured representative government with active citizens. Marx explained history as class struggle, introduced dialectical materialism and surplus value, and predicted revolution, a dictatorship of the proletariat, a classless society and the withering away of the state.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery