- Practice
- About 26 min
- 5 practice questions
Thermodynamic principle of metallurgy and the Ellingham diagram
Use ΔG = ΔH − TΔS and coupled reactions to judge whether a reduction is feasible, read an Ellingham diagram, choose a reducing agent and temperature, and state the diagram's limitations.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why a reduction must have a negative ΔG for the coupled reaction.
- Describe what an Ellingham diagram plots and why most lines slope upwards while the C → CO line slopes down.
- Use the diagram to decide which element reduces which oxide and above what temperature.
- Calculate ΔG for a coupled reaction and state the diagram's limitations.
Why does coke reduce iron oxide but not alumina? Why must a blast furnace be so hot? The answers come from thermodynamics, summarised in a graph drawn by the British physical chemist H.J.T. Ellingham (1897–1975).
Coupled reactions and the sign of ΔG
Write the reduction of a metal oxide MxOy as its decomposition: (2/y)MxOy(s) → (2x/y)M(s) + O₂(g). On its own this has a large positive ΔG. A reducing agent takes the oxygen: C + O₂ → CO₂; 2C + O₂ → 2CO; or 2CO + O₂ → 2CO₂. Adding the decomposition to one of these gives the coupled reaction. A reaction is spontaneous when ΔG is negative, so the reducing agent is chosen to make ΔG of the coupled reaction as negative as possible.
ΔG = ΔH − TΔS, and ΔG° = −RT ln K. A reduction is feasible when ΔG°(coupled) = ΔG°(oxide of reducing agent) − ΔG°(metal oxide) is negative.
What the Ellingham diagram shows
Ellingham plotted the standard Gibbs energy of formation of oxides, ΔG°, on the y-axis against temperature on the x-axis, always per one mole of O₂ so that lines can be compared (for example 2Mg + O₂ → 2MgO, (4/3)Al + O₂ → (2/3)Al₂O₃, 2Fe + O₂ → 2FeO). Since ΔG° = ΔH° − TΔS°, and ΔH° and ΔS° change little with temperature, each line is nearly straight: its intercept at 0 K is ΔH° and its slope is −ΔS°.
Observations from the diagram
- Most metal-oxide lines slope upwards. Forming an oxide uses up O₂ gas, so ΔS° is negative, −TΔS° is positive and ΔG° becomes less negative as T rises.
- The line for 2C + O₂ → 2CO slopes downwards. One mole of gas gives two moles of gas, so ΔS° is positive and ΔG° grows more negative with temperature: CO becomes more stable when hot.
- The line for C + O₂ → CO₂ is almost horizontal: one mole of gas gives one mole of gas, so ΔS° ≈ 0.
- As T rises, a metal oxide line may reach ΔG° = 0; above that temperature the oxide is unstable and decomposes on its own.
- A sudden change of slope (for MgO, HgO and others) marks a phase change (melting or boiling) of the metal, which changes ΔS°.
Why the lines slope as they do
-
Metal + O₂ → metal oxide
- Gas consumed, solid formed
- ΔS° negative
- Slope (−ΔS°) positive: line rises
- Oxide less stable when hot
-
2C + O₂ → 2CO
- 1 mol gas gives 2 mol gas
- ΔS° positive
- Slope negative: line falls
- CO more stable when hot
-
C + O₂ → CO₂
- 1 mol gas gives 1 mol gas
- ΔS° almost zero
- Line almost flat
Applications of the Ellingham diagram
Reduction is a contest for oxygen between the metal and the reducing element. The lower the line, the more stable the oxide. So:
- Oxides at the top (Ag₂O, HgO) are unstable at moderate temperature and decompose on heating without any reducing agent; according to the textbook they decompose at about 600 K and 700 K respectively.
- A metal can reduce the oxide of any metal whose line lies above its own at that temperature. The Cr₂O₃ line lies above the Al₂O₃ line, so aluminium reduces Cr₂O₃ (aluminothermy). Aluminium cannot reduce MgO or CaO, whose lines lie below Al₂O₃.
- The falling C → CO line crosses many metal-oxide lines, so at a high enough temperature carbon can reduce those oxides. The temperature of crossing is the lowest temperature at which coke works.
Worked example 1: the lowest temperature for reducing FeO by carbon
Treat ΔH° and ΔS° as constant and use approximate standard values. For 2Fe + O₂ → 2FeO: ΔH° = −544 kJ, ΔS° = −0.138 kJ K⁻¹, so ΔG°₁ = −544 + 0.138T. For 2C + O₂ → 2CO: ΔH° = −221 kJ, ΔS° = +0.179 kJ K⁻¹, so ΔG°₂ = −221 − 0.179T. The lines cross where −544 + 0.138T = −221 − 0.179T, so 0.317T = 323 and T ≈ 1020 K. This matches the textbook's reading of the diagram, where the two lines meet at about 1000 K. Below it the FeO line is lower (FeO more stable than CO), so coke cannot reduce FeO; above it the CO line is lower and reduction is feasible.
Worked example 2: ΔG for the coupled reaction at 1500 K
Using the same estimates at T = 1500 K: ΔG°₁ = −544 + 0.138 × 1500 = −544 + 207 = −337 kJ; ΔG°₂ = −221 − 0.179 × 1500 = −221 − 268.5 = −489.5 kJ. Reverse reaction 1: 2FeO → 2Fe + O₂, ΔG° = +337 kJ. Add reaction 2: 2FeO + 2C → 2Fe + 2CO, ΔG° = +337 + (−489.5) = −152.5 kJ, about −76 kJ per mole of FeO. Negative, so reduction by coke is feasible at 1500 K. (Readings taken from the printed diagram give a somewhat smaller negative value; the conclusion is the same.)
Using the Ellingham diagram to plan a reduction
- Find the metal-oxide line Per mole of O₂, at the planned temperature.
- Find the reducing agent's line C → CO, CO → CO₂, Al → Al₂O₃ and so on.
- Compare positions Reducing agent's line must lie below the metal-oxide line.
- Read the crossing temperature Work above it, so ΔG° of the coupled reaction is negative.
Worked example 3: aluminium and magnesia
At ordinary furnace temperatures the Al₂O₃ line lies above the MgO line, so MgO is more stable: aluminium cannot reduce magnesia, but magnesium can reduce alumina. After magnesium boils, the MgO line becomes steeper, and at a very high temperature it crosses the Al₂O₃ line; only above that crossing could aluminium in principle reduce MgO. The rule is always the same: the element whose oxide line is lower at the working temperature wins the oxygen.
Limitations of the Ellingham diagram
- It is based only on thermodynamics: it tells whether a reduction is feasible, not how fast it goes (no information on rate or kinetics).
- It does not show other reactions that might take place at the same time.
- Interpreting ΔG assumes the reactants and products are in equilibrium, which is not always true in a furnace.
Key takeaways: feasibility needs ΔG°(coupled) < 0. Lines are per mole of O₂ with slope −ΔS°; metal-oxide lines rise, the C → CO line falls. A lower line reduces a higher one; the crossing point gives the minimum temperature. Thermodynamics says nothing about speed.
Check your understanding
-
1. An Ellingham diagram is a plot of
- ΔS° against T
- ΔG° against 1/T
- ΔG° against T
- ΔH° against T
Show answer
Answer: C. It shows the standard Gibbs energy of formation of oxides (per mole of O₂) on the y-axis against temperature on the x-axis.
-
2. Why does the line for 2C + O₂ → 2CO slope downwards?
- ΔH° is positive.
- ΔS° is positive, because 1 mol of gas gives 2 mol of gas.
- ΔS° is negative, because gas is consumed.
- CO becomes less stable at high temperature.
Show answer
Answer: B. Slope = −ΔS°. One mole of O₂ gives two moles of CO, so ΔS° > 0 and the slope is negative; ΔG° grows more negative and CO becomes more stable as T rises.
-
3. Which reduction is NOT thermodynamically feasible?
- Cr₂O₃ + 2Al → Al₂O₃ + 2Cr
- 3TiO₂ + 4Al → 2Al₂O₃ + 3Ti
- 2FeO + 2C → 2Fe + 2CO above about 1000 K
- Al₂O₃ + 2Cr → Cr₂O₃ + 2Al
Show answer
Answer: D. Al₂O₃ lies below Cr₂O₃ in the diagram (it is more stable), so chromium cannot take oxygen from alumina. The reverse, aluminium reducing Cr₂O₃, is feasible, as is reduction of FeO by carbon above the crossing temperature.
-
4. Using the illustrative values ΔG°(2Zn + O₂ → 2ZnO) = −480 kJ and ΔG°(2C + O₂ → 2CO) = −500 kJ at some temperature, what is ΔG° for ZnO + C → Zn + CO?
- −10 kJ
- −20 kJ
- −980 kJ
- +10 kJ
Show answer
Answer: A. Reverse the zinc reaction: 2ZnO → 2Zn + O₂, ΔG° = +480 kJ. Add 2C + O₂ → 2CO (−500 kJ): 2ZnO + 2C → 2Zn + 2CO, ΔG° = −20 kJ. Per mole of ZnO: −20 ÷ 2 = −10 kJ, so reduction is just feasible.
-
5. Which is a limitation of the Ellingham diagram?
- It cannot compare different metal oxides.
- It ignores temperature.
- It gives no information about the rate of the reduction.
- It works only for sulphides.
Show answer
Answer: C. The diagram compares oxides at different temperatures, but it is purely thermodynamic: a feasible reaction may still be too slow. It also ignores side reactions and assumes equilibrium.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.