- Practice
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Conditions and warranties, express and implied
Distinguish a condition from a warranty, learn the implied conditions (title, description, sample, fitness, merchantability, wholesomeness, trade usage) and implied warranties (quiet possession, no encumbrance, warning of danger), and apply them to cases.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define condition and warranty and state five differences.
- Explain the implied conditions with examples.
- Explain the implied warranties with examples.
When you buy something, you rely on certain promises about it: that it is what was described, that it works, that the seller actually owns it. The Act calls these promises stipulations and divides them into conditions and warranties, with different remedies when they are broken.
Condition and warranty
A condition is a stipulation essential to the main purpose of the contract; its breach allows the buyer to cancel (repudiate) the contract and claim damages. A warranty is a stipulation collateral (secondary) to the main purpose; its breach allows only a claim for damages, not cancellation. Which is which depends on the contract. In the textbook's style of example, a buyer who insists on a motorbike's mileage makes mileage a condition, while a preferred colour is a warranty: if the mileage is met but the colour is wrong, he cannot cancel but can make the seller bear the cost of repainting.
| Basis | Condition | Warranty |
|---|---|---|
| Meaning | Essential to the main purpose | Collateral to the main purpose |
| Importance | Breach goes to the root of the contract | Subsidiary; breach does not end the contract |
| Ownership | Does not pass unless conditions are fulfilled (as the book puts it) | Can pass even though a warranty is unfulfilled |
| Remedy | Cancel the contract and claim damages | Claim damages only |
| Conversion | A breach of condition may be treated as a breach of warranty | A breach of warranty cannot be treated as a breach of condition |
Implied conditions
Some terms are part of every sale even if nobody says them aloud; they are implied from the nature of the contract. The textbook lists seven implied conditions.
- Title - the seller has the right to sell. If a true owner later takes the goods back, the buyer can recover the full price from the seller.
- Description - goods sold by description must match the description (for example, a machine described as one year old must not be very old).
- Sample - in a sale by sample, the bulk must match the sample in quality, the buyer must have a reasonable chance to compare, and the goods must be free from hidden defects making them unsaleable.
- Quality or fitness - normally there is no implied condition of fitness for a particular purpose (the rule of caveat emptor), except when the buyer tells the seller the purpose, relies on the seller's skill and judgement, and the goods are of a kind the seller deals in.
- Merchantability - goods bought by description from a dealer in such goods must be saleable under that name; a watch that does not keep time or a pen that does not write is not merchantable.
- Wholesomeness - eatables must be fit to eat, not just merchantable.
- Trade usage - a condition about quality or fitness may arise from a custom of the trade, such as a custom of declaring defects at an auction.
Implied warranties
Implied warranties
- Quiet possession The buyer will enjoy the goods undisturbed; if someone with a better right takes them, the buyer can claim damages.
- Free from encumbrance No hidden charge in favour of a third party, such as a loan secured on the goods.
- Dangerous goods The seller must warn of a danger he knows of and the buyer does not; otherwise he must compensate for injury.
Breach of condition: cancel and claim damages. Breach of warranty: damages only. Fitness for purpose is implied only if the purpose is told, the seller's skill relied on, and he deals in such goods.
Worked example 1: condition or warranty?
A made-up farmer orders a water pump, telling the dealer it must lift water from a 60-metre well, and relying on the dealer's advice. He also asks for a blue body. The pump delivered is green and lifts water from only 30 metres. Reasoning: the farmer stated the purpose, relied on the dealer's skill, and the dealer sells pumps, so fitness for that purpose is an implied condition; it is broken, so he can reject the pump and claim damages. The colour is a warranty; on its own, a wrong colour would give only damages, such as the cost of repainting.
Worked example 2: quiet possession and damages
Made-up figures: Divya buys a second-hand bicycle for ₹4,000 and spends ₹600 on repairs. The police later seize it as stolen property and return it to its true owner. Working: the seller had no title and her possession was disturbed, so she can recover the price and her loss: 4,000 + 600 = ₹4,600, under the implied condition as to title and the warranty of quiet possession.
Key takeaways: a condition is essential (cancel and claim damages), a warranty collateral (damages only); implied conditions cover title, description, sample, fitness (in limited cases), merchantability, wholesomeness and trade usage; implied warranties cover quiet possession, freedom from encumbrance and warning about dangerous goods.
Check your understanding
-
1. Breach of a warranty entitles the buyer to:
- cancel the contract only
- claim damages only
- cancel the contract and claim damages
- nothing at all
Show answer
Answer: B. A warranty is collateral to the main purpose, so its breach gives a right to damages but not to cancel the contract.
-
2. A seller supplies bulk rice that does not match the sample shown. Which implied condition is broken?
- Sale by sample
- Quiet possession
- Title
- Trade usage
Show answer
Answer: A. In a sale by sample, the bulk must correspond with the sample in quality; mismatch breaks this implied condition.
-
3. Fitness for a particular purpose is implied only when the buyer has told the purpose, relies on the seller's skill and:
- pays in cash
- buys at an auction
- the goods are of a kind the seller deals in
- the goods are second-hand
Show answer
Answer: C. All three must hold: the purpose made known, reliance on the seller's skill or judgement, and goods of a description the seller supplies in his business.
-
4. A seller knows a tin's lid is faulty and may spray its contents when opened, but says nothing; the buyer is hurt. Which implied term is broken?
- Condition as to sample
- Free from encumbrance
- Condition as to description
- Warranty about dangerous goods
Show answer
Answer: D. A seller who knows of a danger the buyer does not must warn him; failing to do so makes him liable for the injury.
-
5. Made-up figures: a buyer pays ₹12,000 for a used scooter and ₹1,500 on repairs; it is then taken back by its true owner. What can he recover from the seller?
- ₹12,000
- ₹1,500
- ₹13,500
- ₹10,500
Show answer
Answer: C. Under the condition as to title and warranty of quiet possession, he recovers the price and his loss: 12,000 + 1,500 = ₹13,500.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.