• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Sale versus agreement to sell, and types of goods

Compare a sale with an agreement to sell on ownership, risk, remedies, nature and insolvency, and classify goods as existing (specific, ascertained, unascertained), future or contingent.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Distinguish a sale from an agreement to sell on six points.
  • Classify goods as existing, future or contingent.
  • Divide existing goods into specific, ascertained and unascertained.

Whether ownership has already passed or is still to pass decides who bears a loss, what the seller can sue for, and who gets the goods if someone becomes insolvent. That is why the difference between a sale and an agreement to sell is so often examined.

Sale and agreement to sell compared

BasisSaleAgreement to sell
OwnershipPasses to the buyer at oncePasses at a future time or on fulfilment of conditions
Risk of lossFalls on the buyer, even if goods are still with the sellerFalls on the seller, even if goods are with the buyer
If the buyer does not paySeller can sue for the priceSeller can sue for damages for breach
NatureExecuted (completed) contractExecutory contract (still to be performed)
Buyer becomes insolvent before payingOwnership is the buyer's, so the goods go to the Official Receiver; the seller gets only a rateable dividend (a proportionate share), subject to his rights as an unpaid sellerSeller may keep the goods, as he still owns them
Seller becomes insolventBuyer can claim the goods from the Official Receiver, as he already owns themBuyer cannot claim the goods; if he has paid, he gets only a rateable dividend

An agreement to sell becomes a sale when the time passes or the conditions are fulfilled and ownership moves to the buyer.

Types of goods

Types of goods under the Act

  • Existing goods Owned or possessed by the seller at the time of the contract.
    • Specific: identified and agreed on at the contract (a chosen saree)
    • Ascertained: identified, possibly after the contract
    • Unascertained or generic: not yet identified (any car of a model from the showroom)
  • Future goods To be made, grown or acquired by the seller after the contract.
    • Rice to be supplied later for a wedding feast
    • Spare parts to be made for a bus company
  • Contingent goods A kind of future goods whose acquisition depends on an uncertain event.
    • A painting the seller will sell only if he gets it from its present owner
    • Imported rice to be supplied only if the shipment arrives

Existing goods include goods 'possessed' by the seller, so a sale by an agent or a pledgee also concerns existing goods. Since future goods do not yet exist with the seller, a contract for future goods is always an agreement to sell, never an immediate sale.

Sale = ownership now, risk on buyer, executed. Agreement to sell = ownership later, risk on seller, executory. Future and contingent goods can only be agreed to be sold.

Worked example 1: who bears the loss?

(a) Meena buys a specific refrigerator in a shop, pays, and asks the shop to deliver it tomorrow. That night a fire destroys it. (b) Meena agrees to buy a refrigerator to be delivered after the shop gets new stock; the stock arrives and is burnt before any unit is picked for her. Reasoning: (a) is a sale: ownership passed when the contract was made, so Meena bears the loss. (b) is an agreement to sell: no unit was ever identified as hers, ownership never passed, so the shop bears the loss.

Worked example 2: classify the goods

(a) A farmer agrees to sell the crop he will harvest next season. (b) A buyer picks one particular laptop, serial number noted, from ten on display. (c) A trader agrees to sell 50 bags of sugar from his godown of 500 bags, bags not yet marked. (d) A collector agrees to sell a rare stamp if he wins it at an auction next week. Reasoning: (a) future goods. (b) specific goods. (c) unascertained goods. (d) contingent goods, because the event may not happen.

Key takeaways: in a sale ownership and risk pass at once and the seller can sue for price; in an agreement to sell they pass later and the seller sues for damages; insolvency rules follow ownership; goods are existing (specific, ascertained, unascertained), future or contingent.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. An agreement to sell is:

    1. an executed contract
    2. an executory contract
    3. a gift
    4. always illegal
    Show answer

    Answer: B. In an agreement to sell, ownership is still to pass, so the contract is still to be performed: executory. A sale is executed.

  2. 2. Goods that a seller will acquire only if an uncertain event happens are:

    1. specific goods
    2. ascertained goods
    3. existing goods
    4. contingent goods
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Contingent goods are future goods whose acquisition depends on a contingency that may or may not happen.

  3. 3. Under a sale, the goods are destroyed while still in the seller's shop. Who bears the loss?

    1. The buyer
    2. The seller
    3. The government
    4. Both equally by law
    Show answer

    Answer: A. In a sale ownership has passed to the buyer, and risk follows ownership, so the buyer bears the loss even though the seller has possession.

  4. 4. A buyer chooses one particular sofa, identified and agreed at the time of the contract. It is:

    1. future goods
    2. unascertained goods
    3. specific goods
    4. contingent goods
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Goods identified and agreed upon at the time of the contract are specific goods.

  5. 5. Under an agreement to sell, the seller becomes insolvent after the buyer has paid an advance. The buyer can:

    1. take the goods from the Official Receiver
    2. claim only a rateable dividend
    3. sue the government
    4. treat it as a sale
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Ownership has not passed, so the buyer cannot claim the goods; he can only claim a rateable dividend for what he paid.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery