- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Contract of sale: meaning, essential elements and what counts as goods
Define a contract of sale of goods, learn its essential elements - two parties, transfer of ownership, goods, price, and sale or agreement to sell - and decide what counts as goods under the Sale of Goods Act, 1930.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define a contract of sale of goods and explain why ownership is the key idea.
- List and explain the five essential elements of a contract of sale.
- Decide whether a given item is 'goods' under the Act.
Chapter 21 opens Unit VIII. Buying a pen, a scooter or a sack of rice is a contract, and the Sale of Goods Act, 1930 sets the special rules for it. Before 1930, sales were governed by Chapter VII of the Indian Contract Act, 1872. The general principles of the Contract Act (offer, acceptance, free consent, capacity and so on) still apply to sales wherever the 1930 Act does not say otherwise.
Meaning of a contract of sale
A contract of sale of goods is a contract by which the seller transfers or agrees to transfer the property (ownership) in goods to the buyer for a price. The textbook stresses that ownership is the heart of it. Sale means selling ownership, not just handing over physical possession. Possession alone does not make a person owner; ownership gives the buyer full freedom to use or dispose of the goods, with rights good against the whole world.
Essential elements
- Two parties - a seller and a buyer, who must be different persons. A person cannot buy his own goods. The textbook mentions a court ruling that when a partnership was dissolved and its goods were divided among the partners, it was not a sale, because the partners were joint owners. Exception: when a person's goods are sold in execution of a court decree, he may himself buy them.
- Transfer of property - the seller must transfer, or agree to transfer, ownership. A mere transfer of possession (as in lending or pledging) is not a sale.
- Goods - the subject matter must be goods (see below).
- Price - the consideration must be money. Exchanging goods for goods is barter, not sale; but goods given partly for goods and partly for money is a sale.
- Includes both sale and agreement to sell - if ownership passes at once, it is a sale; if it is to pass at a future date or on fulfilment of a condition, it is an agreement to sell.
What counts as goods
Goods means every kind of movable property other than money and actionable claims. Immovable property such as land and buildings is also excluded. An actionable claim is a right to recover a debt or money that can be enforced only by legal action; the textbook's examples include a debt secured by a mortgage of immovable property, a fixed deposit receipt, a dividend due on shares, an amount due under a life insurance policy, and rent falling due in future.
Goods or not goods?
-
Goods (as the textbook lists)
- Stocks and shares
- Growing crops and grass
- Things attached to land, agreed to be cut off before sale (e.g. trees to be felled)
- Water, gas, electricity, power
- Goodwill, copyright, trade marks, patents
-
Not goods
- Money (current coins and notes)
- Actionable claims (e.g. dividend due, FD receipt, insurance money due)
- Immovable property (land, buildings)
Contract of sale = two parties + transfer of ownership + goods (movables, not money or actionable claims) + price in money. It covers both a sale and an agreement to sell.
Worked example 1: is it a contract of sale?
(a) Kumar agrees to sell 200 shares to Latha for ₹20,000. (b) Kumar agrees to sell his house to Latha. (c) Kumar gives a gold chain to his niece as a gift. (d) Kumar pledges his car with a moneylender as security for a loan. Reasoning: (a) shares are goods and the price is money, so yes. (b) a house is immovable property, so it is not a sale of goods. (c) there is no price, so it is a gift, not a sale. (d) only possession is transferred as security, not ownership, so it is a pledge, not a sale.
Worked example 2: barter or sale?
Made-up figures: Ravi gives 100 kg of rice worth ₹30 per kg to Selvi in exchange for 150 kg of wheat worth ₹24 per kg, and the difference is settled in cash. Working: rice = 100 × 30 = ₹3,000; wheat = 150 × 24 = ₹3,600. Ravi pays the difference, 3,600 - 3,000 = ₹600, in cash. Because the consideration is partly goods and partly money, the textbook treats this as a sale, not pure barter. If no cash changed hands at all, it would be barter.
Key takeaways: a contract of sale transfers ownership of goods for a money price; it needs two different parties, transfer of property, goods and price, and covers both sale and agreement to sell; goods are movables excluding money and actionable claims, and include shares, crops, utilities and intellectual property rights.
Check your understanding
-
1. Before the Sale of Goods Act, 1930, sale of goods was governed by:
- the Companies Act
- Chapter VII of the Indian Contract Act, 1872
- the Consumer Protection Act
- the Negotiable Instruments Act
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook says sale of goods was earlier governed by Chapter VII of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, whose general principles still apply.
-
2. Which of these is NOT goods under the Act?
- Shares of a company
- Growing crops
- A dividend that has become due on shares
- Electricity
Show answer
Answer: C. A dividend due is an actionable claim, which is excluded. Shares, growing crops and electricity are goods.
-
3. Exchanging 10 goats for 2 cows with no money involved is:
- a sale
- barter
- an agreement to sell
- a pledge
Show answer
Answer: B. When goods are exchanged only for goods, there is no money price, so it is barter, not sale.
-
4. Made-up figures: 50 kg of sugar at ₹40 per kg is exchanged for 40 kg of dal at ₹90 per kg, the balance paid in cash. How much cash is paid?
- ₹1,600
- ₹2,000
- ₹3,600
- ₹1,400
Show answer
Answer: A. Sugar = 50 × 40 = ₹2,000. Dal = 40 × 90 = ₹3,600. Cash = 3,600 - 2,000 = ₹1,600. Because money is part of the price, it is a sale.
-
5. Why is pledging a watch with a lender not a sale?
- Watches are not goods
- There are three parties
- Only possession, not ownership, is transferred
- There is too much money involved
Show answer
Answer: C. A sale requires transfer of ownership. In a pledge, only possession passes as security, so it is not a sale.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.