• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Transfer of ownership: when property passes

Distinguish property from possession and apply the Act's rules on when ownership passes for specific goods, unascertained goods and goods sent on approval or on sale or return.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Distinguish property (ownership) from possession.
  • State when ownership passes in specific goods and in unascertained goods.
  • Apply the rules for goods sent on approval or on sale or return.

Transfer of ownership is the main object of a contract of sale. Knowing the exact moment it passes decides who bears the risk if the goods are lost, and whose creditors can claim them. The Act lays down rules for each situation.

Property and possession

Property in goods means ownership; possession means custody or control. A person holding a watch may have borrowed it, found it or even stolen it, so possession alone does not prove ownership. The transfer of title is called the passing of property.

Specific goods

  1. Unconditional contract, goods in a deliverable state - ownership passes when the contract is made; the time of payment or delivery does not matter.
  2. Goods not in a deliverable state - if the seller must do something to make them deliverable (such as painting, checking or dismantling), ownership passes only when that is done (and, under the Act, the buyer has notice).
  3. Price to be fixed by weighing, measuring or testing - ownership passes only after the seller completes it and the buyer knows it has been done.

Unascertained goods

No ownership can pass in unascertained goods until they are identified. The textbook explains three steps. Ascertainment is the seller alone identifying and setting apart the goods (a one-sided act). Appropriation is identifying and setting apart the goods with the consent of both seller and buyer; ownership then passes. For example, if the buyer supplies the bottles and the seller fills them with the oil sold, the buyer has consented and ownership passes on filling. Delivery to a carrier for transmission to the buyer counts as unconditional appropriation, provided the seller has not reserved the right of disposal; a railway receipt or bill of lading in the buyer's name shows that he has not.

Goods on approval or 'sale or return'

SituationOwnership passes
Buyer signals approval or acceptanceWhen the approval is communicated
Buyer does an act adopting the deal (e.g. sells or pledges the goods)When that act is done
Buyer keeps the goods without giving notice of rejection, a time was fixedWhen the fixed time expires
Buyer keeps the goods without giving notice of rejection, no time was fixedWhen a reasonable time has passed

Unascertained goods: the road to ownership

  1. Contract for generic goods No ownership yet.
  2. Ascertainment Seller identifies and sets the goods apart.
  3. Appropriation Both agree these goods are the buyer's, or goods are handed to a carrier without reserving disposal.
  4. Ownership passes Risk now follows to the buyer.

Specific goods ready to deliver: ownership passes at the contract. Anything still to be done, weighed or tested: after it is done and the buyer knows. Unascertained goods: only on appropriation.

Worked example 1: price by weighing

Made-up case: Arun agrees to buy a particular heap of groundnuts from Bala at ₹90 per kg; Bala must weigh the heap to fix the price. Half the heap (300 kg) is weighed and Arun is told; then a fire destroys everything before the remaining 300 kg are weighed. Reasoning: for the price to be fixed, weighing had to be finished and Arun informed. It was not finished, so ownership of the heap had not passed and Bala bears the loss. Working (what was at stake): the weighed half alone was worth 300 × 90 = ₹27,000, and the whole heap about 600 × 90 = ₹54,000; all of it is Bala's loss, and Arun owes nothing.

Worked example 2: sale or return with a time limit

A jeweller sends a necklace to Kavitha on sale or return for 10 days from 1 March. She neither returns it nor gives notice of rejection. It is stolen from her house on 13 March. Working: 10 days from 1 March ends on 11 March. On 13 March the fixed time had expired, so ownership had passed to Kavitha on its expiry and she bears the loss; she must pay the price. Had the theft been on 5 March, ownership would still have been the jeweller's.

Key takeaways: property means ownership, not possession; for specific goods ownership passes at the contract if the goods are ready and the contract unconditional, otherwise after the seller's act and the buyer's knowledge; unascertained goods pass on appropriation, including delivery to a carrier without reserving disposal; goods on approval pass on approval, an act of adoption, or expiry of the fixed or a reasonable time.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. 'Property in goods' under the Act means:

    1. possession of goods
    2. ownership of goods
    3. custody of goods
    4. insurance of goods
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Property in goods means ownership; possession means custody or control and does not by itself make one the owner.

  2. 2. Appropriation of goods to the contract requires:

    1. the seller alone to act
    2. the consent of both seller and buyer
    3. a court order
    4. payment in full
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Ascertainment is a one-sided act of the seller; appropriation is identifying and setting apart goods with the consent of both parties.

  3. 3. Goods are sent on sale or return for 7 days from 10 June. The buyer keeps them silently, and they are destroyed on 20 June. Who bears the loss?

    1. The seller, because no approval was given
    2. Neither party
    3. The carrier
    4. The buyer, because the fixed time expired on 17 June
    Show answer

    Answer: D. 7 days from 10 June ends on 17 June. Keeping the goods without notice of rejection after that passes ownership to the buyer, so the buyer bears the 20 June loss.

  4. 4. A seller hands goods to a railway for the buyer, taking the railway receipt in the buyer's name. When does ownership pass?

    1. On delivery to the carrier
    2. Only when the buyer pays
    3. Only when the buyer opens the parcel
    4. Never
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Delivery to a carrier without reserving the right of disposal is unconditional appropriation; a receipt in the buyer's name shows no such reservation.

  5. 5. A buyer on approval pledges the goods with a third person before deciding. What happens?

    1. Ownership stays with the seller for ever
    2. The pledge is void
    3. Ownership passes to the buyer, because pledging adopts the transaction
    4. The seller can recover the goods from the third person
    Show answer

    Answer: C. An act adopting the deal, such as pledging, passes ownership to the buyer. The seller can only claim the price from the buyer, not the goods from the pledgee.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery