• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

The unpaid seller and his rights

Define an unpaid seller and explain his rights against the goods (lien, stoppage in transit, resale, withholding delivery) and against the buyer personally (suits for price, damages, repudiation and interest), with worked cases.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Decide whether a seller is an unpaid seller.
  • Explain the right of lien, stoppage in transit and resale, and when each ends.
  • Explain the seller's rights against the buyer personally.

A seller who has parted with ownership but not received his money needs protection. The Act calls him an unpaid seller and gives him rights against the goods and against the buyer personally.

Who is an unpaid seller?

A seller is an unpaid seller when (a) the whole price has not been paid or tendered, or (b) a bill of exchange or other negotiable instrument received as conditional payment has been dishonoured. A seller who has received part of the price is still unpaid. 'Seller' includes an agent of the seller and a consignee who has paid for the goods.

Rights against the goods

  1. Right of lien - to retain the goods in his possession until paid. It needs possession, and applies when goods were sold without credit, or the credit period has expired, or the buyer has become insolvent. Lien depends on possession, so it survives even if documents of title have been sent to the buyer. After part delivery, he has a lien on the remainder, unless the part delivery was meant as delivery of the whole.
  2. Lien is lost when the seller hands the goods to a carrier for the buyer without reserving the right of disposal, when the buyer or his agent lawfully gets possession, or when the seller waives it.
  3. Right of stoppage in transit - when the goods are with a carrier (with neither seller nor buyer) and the buyer has become insolvent, the seller can stop them and regain possession. It ends when the goods are delivered to the buyer or his agent, or when, on arrival, the carrier tells the buyer that it holds the goods on his behalf.
  4. Right of resale - the unpaid seller may resell when the goods are perishable; or when, after exercising lien or stoppage, he has given notice of his intention to resell and the buyer does not pay within a reasonable time; or when the contract expressly reserves the right of resale.
  5. Right of withholding delivery - where ownership has not passed to the buyer, the unpaid seller can simply withhold delivery, a right similar to lien and stoppage.

Rights against the buyer personally

SuitWhen
Suit for priceOwnership has passed and the buyer wrongfully refuses to pay
Suit for damages for non-acceptanceThe buyer wrongfully refuses to accept the goods
Suit on repudiation before the due dateThe buyer cancels before delivery date: the seller may treat the contract as alive and wait, or sue at once
Suit for interestInterest as agreed, from the due date to payment; if not agreed, from a day the seller notifies to the buyer

Rights of an unpaid seller

  • Against the goods
    • Lien (goods with the seller)
    • Stoppage in transit (goods with a carrier, buyer insolvent)
    • Resale
    • Withholding delivery (ownership not passed)
  • Against the buyer personally
    • Suit for price
    • Damages for non-acceptance
    • Suit on early repudiation
    • Interest

Goods with the seller: lien. Goods with the carrier and buyer insolvent: stoppage in transit. Buyer still not paying after notice, or goods perishable: resale.

Worked example 1: is he an unpaid seller?

Made-up cases, each a sale of goods for ₹20,000: (a) buyer paid ₹19,800; (b) buyer paid by cheque, which bounced; (c) sold on one month's credit, only two weeks have passed; (d) one month's credit, period over, price unpaid. Reasoning: (a) the whole price is not paid (₹200 is due), so yes. (b) the negotiable instrument was dishonoured, so yes. (c) price is not yet due, so he cannot use lien now; he becomes able to act when credit expires (or at once if the buyer becomes insolvent). (d) yes, and lien is available if he still holds the goods.

Worked example 2: interest on late payment

Made-up terms: price ₹50,000, due on 1 April, with agreed interest at 12% a year. The buyer pays on 1 July. Working: from 1 April to 1 July is exactly 3 months (April, May, June), i.e. 3/12 of a year. Interest = 50,000 × 12/100 × 3/12 = 50,000 × 0.12 × 0.25 = ₹1,500. Total due = 50,000 + 1,500 = ₹51,500.

Worked example 3: lien or stoppage?

A made-up Salem trader sells 40 bags of turmeric to a buyer in Mumbai on credit. (a) Before dispatch, the buyer becomes insolvent; the bags are still in Salem. (b) Instead, the bags are on a lorry to Mumbai when the trader learns of the insolvency. Reasoning: (a) goods are in the seller's possession and the buyer is insolvent, so he exercises his lien and keeps them. (b) goods are with a carrier and the buyer is insolvent, so he uses stoppage in transit by telling the transporter not to deliver.

Key takeaways: a seller not paid in full, or whose cheque or bill bounced, is an unpaid seller; against the goods he has lien, stoppage in transit, resale and withholding delivery; against the buyer he can sue for price, damages for non-acceptance, early repudiation and interest.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A seller received ₹9,900 out of a price of ₹10,000. He is:

    1. not an unpaid seller, as most is paid
    2. an unpaid seller
    3. a buyer
    4. an agent only
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A seller is unpaid when the whole price has not been paid; even a balance of ₹100 makes him an unpaid seller.

  2. 2. The right of stoppage in transit can be used when:

    1. goods are with the seller and the buyer is solvent
    2. goods are with the buyer
    3. goods are with a carrier and the buyer has become insolvent
    4. the price has been fully paid
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Stoppage in transit requires the goods to be in transit with a carrier and the buyer to have become insolvent.

  3. 3. Which event ends the seller's right of lien?

    1. The seller sends the documents of title to the buyer but keeps the goods
    2. The buyer lawfully obtains possession of the goods
    3. The buyer becomes insolvent
    4. The credit period expires
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Lien depends on possession; it is lost when the buyer lawfully gets possession, when goods go to a carrier without reserving disposal, or by waiver. Sending documents alone does not end it.

  4. 4. Made-up terms: price ₹40,000 paid 6 months late, agreed interest 9% a year. Interest due is:

    1. ₹3,600
    2. ₹1,800
    3. ₹2,400
    4. ₹900
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Interest = 40,000 × 9/100 × 6/12 = 40,000 × 0.09 × 0.5 = ₹1,800.

  5. 5. An unpaid seller may resell the goods without waiting when they are:

    1. perishable
    2. made of steel
    3. insured
    4. already delivered to the buyer
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The textbook lists perishable goods as a case where the unpaid seller can resell; otherwise he gives notice and waits a reasonable time, unless the contract reserves resale.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery