Revision notes

Chapter 21 The Sale of Goods Act, 1930: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Contract of sale: meaning, essential elements and what counts as goods

Goods or not goods?

  • Goods (as the textbook lists)
    • Stocks and shares
    • Growing crops and grass
    • Things attached to land, agreed to be cut off before sale (e.g. trees to be felled)
    • Water, gas, electricity, power
    • Goodwill, copyright, trade marks, patents
  • Not goods
    • Money (current coins and notes)
    • Actionable claims (e.g. dividend due, FD receipt, insurance money due)
    • Immovable property (land, buildings)

Contract of sale = two parties + transfer of ownership + goods (movables, not money or actionable claims) + price in money. It covers both a sale and an agreement to sell.

Key takeaways: a contract of sale transfers ownership of goods for a money price; it needs two different parties, transfer of property, goods and price, and covers both sale and agreement to sell; goods are movables excluding money and actionable claims, and include shares, crops, utilities and intellectual property rights.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Sale versus agreement to sell, and types of goods

BasisSaleAgreement to sell
OwnershipPasses to the buyer at oncePasses at a future time or on fulfilment of conditions
Risk of lossFalls on the buyer, even if goods are still with the sellerFalls on the seller, even if goods are with the buyer
If the buyer does not paySeller can sue for the priceSeller can sue for damages for breach
NatureExecuted (completed) contractExecutory contract (still to be performed)
Buyer becomes insolvent before payingOwnership is the buyer's, so the goods go to the Official Receiver; the seller gets only a rateable dividend (a proportionate share), subject to his rights as an unpaid sellerSeller may keep the goods, as he still owns them
Seller becomes insolventBuyer can claim the goods from the Official Receiver, as he already owns themBuyer cannot claim the goods; if he has paid, he gets only a rateable dividend

Types of goods under the Act

  • Existing goods Owned or possessed by the seller at the time of the contract.
    • Specific: identified and agreed on at the contract (a chosen saree)
    • Ascertained: identified, possibly after the contract
    • Unascertained or generic: not yet identified (any car of a model from the showroom)
  • Future goods To be made, grown or acquired by the seller after the contract.
    • Rice to be supplied later for a wedding feast
    • Spare parts to be made for a bus company
  • Contingent goods A kind of future goods whose acquisition depends on an uncertain event.
    • A painting the seller will sell only if he gets it from its present owner
    • Imported rice to be supplied only if the shipment arrives

Sale = ownership now, risk on buyer, executed. Agreement to sell = ownership later, risk on seller, executory. Future and contingent goods can only be agreed to be sold.

Key takeaways: in a sale ownership and risk pass at once and the seller can sue for price; in an agreement to sell they pass later and the seller sues for damages; insolvency rules follow ownership; goods are existing (specific, ascertained, unascertained), future or contingent.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Transfer of ownership: when property passes

SituationOwnership passes
Buyer signals approval or acceptanceWhen the approval is communicated
Buyer does an act adopting the deal (e.g. sells or pledges the goods)When that act is done
Buyer keeps the goods without giving notice of rejection, a time was fixedWhen the fixed time expires
Buyer keeps the goods without giving notice of rejection, no time was fixedWhen a reasonable time has passed

Unascertained goods: the road to ownership

  1. Contract for generic goods No ownership yet.
  2. Ascertainment Seller identifies and sets the goods apart.
  3. Appropriation Both agree these goods are the buyer's, or goods are handed to a carrier without reserving disposal.
  4. Ownership passes Risk now follows to the buyer.

Specific goods ready to deliver: ownership passes at the contract. Anything still to be done, weighed or tested: after it is done and the buyer knows. Unascertained goods: only on appropriation.

Key takeaways: property means ownership, not possession; for specific goods ownership passes at the contract if the goods are ready and the contract unconditional, otherwise after the seller's act and the buyer's knowledge; unascertained goods pass on appropriation, including delivery to a carrier without reserving disposal; goods on approval pass on approval, an act of adoption, or expiry of the fixed or a reasonable time.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Conditions and warranties, express and implied

BasisConditionWarranty
MeaningEssential to the main purposeCollateral to the main purpose
ImportanceBreach goes to the root of the contractSubsidiary; breach does not end the contract
OwnershipDoes not pass unless conditions are fulfilled (as the book puts it)Can pass even though a warranty is unfulfilled
RemedyCancel the contract and claim damagesClaim damages only
ConversionA breach of condition may be treated as a breach of warrantyA breach of warranty cannot be treated as a breach of condition

Implied warranties

  • Quiet possession The buyer will enjoy the goods undisturbed; if someone with a better right takes them, the buyer can claim damages.
  • Free from encumbrance No hidden charge in favour of a third party, such as a loan secured on the goods.
  • Dangerous goods The seller must warn of a danger he knows of and the buyer does not; otherwise he must compensate for injury.

Breach of condition: cancel and claim damages. Breach of warranty: damages only. Fitness for purpose is implied only if the purpose is told, the seller's skill relied on, and he deals in such goods.

Key takeaways: a condition is essential (cancel and claim damages), a warranty collateral (damages only); implied conditions cover title, description, sample, fitness (in limited cases), merchantability, wholesomeness and trade usage; implied warranties cover quiet possession, freedom from encumbrance and warning about dangerous goods.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

The unpaid seller and his rights

SuitWhen
Suit for priceOwnership has passed and the buyer wrongfully refuses to pay
Suit for damages for non-acceptanceThe buyer wrongfully refuses to accept the goods
Suit on repudiation before the due dateThe buyer cancels before delivery date: the seller may treat the contract as alive and wait, or sue at once
Suit for interestInterest as agreed, from the due date to payment; if not agreed, from a day the seller notifies to the buyer

Rights of an unpaid seller

  • Against the goods
    • Lien (goods with the seller)
    • Stoppage in transit (goods with a carrier, buyer insolvent)
    • Resale
    • Withholding delivery (ownership not passed)
  • Against the buyer personally
    • Suit for price
    • Damages for non-acceptance
    • Suit on early repudiation
    • Interest

Goods with the seller: lien. Goods with the carrier and buyer insolvent: stoppage in transit. Buyer still not paying after notice, or goods perishable: resale.

Key takeaways: a seller not paid in full, or whose cheque or bill bounced, is an unpaid seller; against the goods he has lien, stoppage in transit, resale and withholding delivery; against the buyer he can sue for price, damages for non-acceptance, early repudiation and interest.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery