- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Norms, criteria, grades and percentiles: avoiding traps
Tell norm-referenced from criterion-referenced interpretation in scenarios, work out simple percentile ranks, and compare absolute and relative grading and marking with grading.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Questions on interpretation and reporting often set traps with words like 'rank', 'standard', 'percentage' and 'percentile'. This lesson sorts these words out and practises simple calculations that appear in exams.
Norm-referenced or criterion-referenced?
Ask: is the learner being compared with other learners, or with a fixed standard? Norm-referenced interpretation describes position in a group: ranks, percentiles, 'above average'. It suits selection, where only a fixed number can be chosen. Criterion-referenced interpretation describes what the learner can do against a pre-set standard: 'can solve linear equations', 'reached 80% mastery of the unit'. It suits checking mastery and planning teaching. A useful test: in criterion-referenced assessment, every learner can in principle succeed; in norm-referenced assessment, someone must always be at the bottom.
Percentage and percentile are different
A percentage score is the proportion of marks earned: 36 out of 50 is 72%. A percentile rank is the percentage of learners in a group who scored below a given learner. A learner at the 72nd percentile scored higher than 72% of the group, whatever her marks. Percentage is about the test; percentile is about the group.
Absolute and relative grading
| Grading type | How grades are set | Reference |
|---|---|---|
| Absolute | Fixed mark ranges, decided in advance (for example 80 and above = A) | Criterion |
| Relative | Grades depend on position in the group (for example top tenth = A) | Norm |
With absolute grading, if everyone performs well, everyone can get an A. With relative grading, the proportion getting each grade is set by the group's spread. Grading in general reduces the weight given to small mark differences, cuts unhealthy competition over single marks, and can be applied to co-scholastic areas where exact marks make little sense. Its cost is less precise information.
A frequent trap mixes the reference with the tool. A multiple-choice test can be interpreted either way: compare scores with each other and it is norm-referenced; compare each score with a mastery standard and it is criterion-referenced. The interpretation, not the item type, decides the label.
CCE as an idea
Continuous and comprehensive evaluation, as a concept, links these choices together: frequent formative assessment, many tools (observation, portfolios, projects, rubrics), coverage of scholastic and co-scholastic areas, and reporting by grades with descriptive remarks rather than marks alone. A trap option says CCE means 'more tests every week'; the idea is wider and more varied assessment, not more of the same testing.
Worked example 1
In a class of 40, Kiran's score is higher than that of 30 students; no one tied with her. Find her percentile rank. Step 1: students below her = 30. Step 2: percentile rank = 30/40 × 100 = 75. Answer: 75th percentile. If her marks were 54 out of 90, her percentage would be 54/90 × 100 = 60%. The two numbers answer different questions.
Worked example 2
A school sets grades in advance: 90 and above A1, 80 to 89 A2, 70 to 79 B1. This year 22 of 30 students score 90 or more. Step 1: grades are tied to fixed ranges, not to position. Step 2: so all 22 receive A1. Answer: absolute grading, a criterion-referenced approach. Under relative grading with only the top tenth getting the highest grade, just 3 students (30 × 1/10) could receive it.
Compared with others: norm-referenced (ranks, percentiles, relative grading). Compared with a standard: criterion-referenced (mastery, absolute grading). Percentage is marks earned; percentile rank is the share of the group scoring below.
Key takeaways
- Norm-referenced suits selection; criterion-referenced suits mastery and teaching.
- Percentile rank = number scoring below ÷ number in group × 100.
- Absolute grading uses fixed ranges; relative grading depends on the group.
- Grading reduces focus on tiny mark differences but loses detail.
- CCE as an idea means varied, continuous, whole-child assessment, not more tests.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which purpose is best served by norm-referenced interpretation?
- Checking whether each child can read a clock
- Selecting the top 50 candidates for limited seats
- Planning remedial teaching for one skill
- Certifying mastery of a unit
Show answer
Answer: B. When a fixed number must be chosen, comparing learners with each other is needed.
-
2. In a group of 50, a student scored higher than 40 others and tied with no one. Her percentile rank is:
- 40
- 90
- 80
- 50
Show answer
Answer: C. 40/50 × 100 = 80.
-
3. A student scores 45 out of 60. What is his percentage score?
- 45%
- 60%
- 80%
- 75%
Show answer
Answer: D. 45/60 × 100 = 75%.
-
4. Grades fixed in advance as 'A for 85 and above, B for 70 to 84' are an example of:
- Relative grading
- Absolute grading
- Percentile ranking
- Norm-referenced selection
Show answer
Answer: B. Fixed mark ranges set beforehand make the grading absolute (criterion-referenced).
-
5. Which statement about CCE as an idea is correct?
- It uses varied tools across scholastic and co-scholastic areas throughout the year
- It means giving a written test every day
- It covers only mathematics and language
- It removes all assessment from schools
Show answer
Answer: A. CCE as a concept means continuous, varied assessment of the whole child.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.