• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Writing and choosing items: MCQs, essays, rubrics and portfolios

Spot flaws in multiple-choice and essay items, choose the right item type for an objective, and tell analytic from holistic rubrics and showcase from process portfolios.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Exams often show a badly written item and ask what is wrong with it, or describe an objective and ask which item type fits best. Knowing a handful of item-writing rules and a few rubric and portfolio types lets you answer in seconds.

Rules for good multiple-choice items

  • The stem states a complete problem and can be understood before reading the options.
  • Only one option is correct or clearly best.
  • Wrong options (distractors) are plausible, often based on common errors.
  • Options are similar in length and grammar, so the key does not stand out.
  • Avoid clues such as 'always' and 'never' in distractors only, or words repeated from the stem in the key.
  • Avoid negative stems where possible; if used, highlight NOT.

A common flaw is a grammatical clue: a stem ending 'an' when only one option begins with a vowel. Another is a longest-option clue, when the key is much more detailed than the others. Both let test-wise learners score without the knowledge, which lowers validity.

Other item types have their own rules. True-or-false statements should be wholly true or wholly false, avoid absolute words such as 'always' that signal falsity, and test one idea each. Matching items should keep both lists about one theme, and give more responses than premises, so the last pair cannot be found by elimination. Short-answer items should be worded so that only one brief answer is correct.

Matching item type to objective

Choose the item type that lets learners show the intended thinking. Recall of many facts suits multiple-choice, matching or short answer. Organising an argument, comparing views or expressing ideas suits an essay. Performing a skill, such as conducting an experiment or reading aloud, needs a performance task observed with a checklist or rubric. Essays allow freedom of response but cover fewer topics and are harder to mark consistently; restricted-response essays, with clear limits on length and content, are easier to mark than extended ones.

Essay marking becomes more consistent when the teacher prepares a model answer or marking scheme in advance, marks one question across all scripts before moving to the next, and hides students' names where possible. These steps reduce the influence of handwriting, earlier answers and the marker's impression of the student.

Analytic and holistic rubrics

Two rubric types
RubricHow it scoresBest for
AnalyticScores each criterion separately, then combinesDetailed feedback; diagnosis of strengths and weaknesses
HolisticGives one overall score from a description of the wholeQuick overall judgement of many pieces

Portfolio types

A process (working or growth) portfolio holds drafts and reflections and shows how the learner improved over time; it supports formative assessment. A showcase portfolio holds the learner's best finished pieces, usually chosen by the learner; it supports summative judgement and celebration. Either becomes stronger when learners write short reflections on why they chose each piece.

Worked example 1

Item: 'Photosynthesis takes place mainly in the: (i) roots (ii) leaves, which contain chlorophyll and receive sunlight for making food (iii) stem (iv) flower.' Step 1: check the options' length. The second is far longer and more detailed. Step 2: a test-wise student would pick it without knowing the science. Answer: longest-option clue. Fix it by making the key simply 'leaves'.

Worked example 2

A teacher wants feedback on four separate features of students' letters: format, content, language and neatness, so that each student knows what to improve. Step 1: separate scores per criterion are needed. Answer: an analytic rubric. A holistic rubric would give one overall score, which hides which feature needs work.

Write MCQs with a clear stem, one best answer, plausible distractors and no clues. Match the item to the thinking required. Analytic rubrics give scores per criterion; holistic give one score. Process portfolios show growth; showcase portfolios show best work.

Key takeaways

  • Clues such as grammar or option length lower validity.
  • Distractors should come from real errors.
  • Essays suit organisation and argument; performance tasks suit skills.
  • Analytic rubric: criterion by criterion; holistic rubric: one overall judgement.
  • Process portfolio: growth over time; showcase portfolio: best work.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A stem ends with 'an' and only one option begins with a vowel. This flaw is called a:

    1. Grammatical clue
    2. Longest-option clue
    3. Negative stem
    4. Double-barrelled stem
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The grammar of the stem points to the key, which is a grammatical clue.

  2. 2. Which item type is best for testing a student's ability to build and organise an argument?

    1. True or false
    2. Matching
    3. Essay
    4. Fill in the blank
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Organising and expressing an argument needs a constructed, extended response.

  3. 3. A rubric that gives one overall score for a piece of writing is:

    1. Analytic
    2. Diagnostic
    3. Norm-referenced
    4. Holistic
    Show answer

    Answer: D. A holistic rubric judges the work as a whole with one score.

  4. 4. A collection of drafts and reflections that shows how a student's writing improved over the year is a:

    1. Showcase portfolio
    2. Blueprint
    3. Process portfolio
    4. Holistic rubric
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Showing growth through drafts and reflections is the purpose of a process (growth) portfolio.

  5. 5. Which is good practice when writing distractors?

    1. Base them on errors students commonly make
    2. Make them obviously absurd
    3. Make them much shorter than the key
    4. Use 'all of the above' in every item
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Distractors drawn from real errors are plausible and reveal misconceptions.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery