- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Observation tools, feedback and marker errors
Choose between a checklist, rating scale and anecdotal record, write feedback that helps learning, and name the marker errors (halo, leniency, severity, central tendency) that make marks unreliable.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Not everything worth assessing can be tested on paper: participation, cooperation, laboratory skills and habits are seen in action. Teachers use observation tools for these, and then give feedback. Exams ask which tool fits, what makes feedback useful, and which error a marker has made.
Non-test tools
| Tool | What it records | Typical use |
|---|---|---|
| Checklist | Whether a behaviour or step is present or absent (yes or no) | Did the child wash hands, measure first, then pour? |
| Rating scale | The degree or frequency of a behaviour on a scale | Never, sometimes, often, always |
| Anecdotal record | A short, factual description of a significant incident | One event in the playground, with date and place |
| Sociometry | Who chooses whom as a friend or partner | Seeing the pattern of group preferences |
| Cumulative record | Information over the years in one file | Tracking growth across classes |
The key difference is that a checklist asks 'was it done?' while a rating scale asks 'how well, or how often?'. An anecdotal record should state what happened, not what the teacher concludes. 'Ravi pushed Amit twice during the queue' is a record; 'Ravi is a bully' is a judgement, and it belongs in a separate comment.
Feedback that helps
Useful feedback is specific, timely, linked to the criteria and points to the next step. Research on feedback (Hattie and Timperley are the usual names) frames it as three questions: where am I going, how am I going, and where to next? A bare grade or 'good' tells the learner nothing to act on. 'Your argument is clear, but two of your examples do not support it; add evidence from the passage' does. Feedback on the task and the strategy helps more than praise or criticism of the person.
Marker errors
| Error | What happens |
|---|---|
| Halo effect | A general impression (neat writing, good behaviour) colours marks on specific features |
| Leniency error | Marks are generally too generous |
| Severity error | Marks are generally too harsh |
| Central tendency | The marker avoids high and low marks and gives everyone the middle |
| Contrast effect | A script is judged by comparison with the one just before it |
Remedies include a rubric or marking scheme prepared in advance, marking one question across all scripts, covering names, shuffling the order, and a second marker or moderation.
Worked example 1: choose the tool
(a) A teacher records, for each child, whether the apparatus was set up, the reading taken and the table completed. (b) A teacher records how often each child shares materials: never, sometimes, often or always. Answer: (a) a checklist, since each step is present or absent; (b) a rating scale, since it measures how often. If the teacher wrote a short factual note about one quarrel at the water tap, that would be an anecdotal record.
Worked example 2: name the error
A teacher gives a well-behaved student 18 out of 20 for an essay whose content is weak but neatly written, and gives 10 out of 20 to a rebellious student whose ideas are strong. Step 1: the general impression of the student and the neat appearance is shaping the marks. Answer: halo effect. A rubric that scores content, language and organisation separately, with names hidden, would reduce it.
Worked example 3: spotting leniency
Two teachers mark the same 10 scripts out of 20. Teacher A's mean mark is 17, which is 85%. Teacher B's mean is 13, which is 65%. Step 1: the difference is 4 marks, or 20 percentage points, on identical scripts. Step 2: because the scripts are the same, the gap comes from the markers, not the students. Answer: A may be lenient or B severe; moderation against a common marking scheme is needed before the marks are used.
Checklist: present or absent. Rating scale: how much or how often. Anecdotal record: facts, not judgements. Halo: impression colours the marks.
Key takeaways
- Choose the tool to fit the behaviour: presence, degree or incident.
- Keep facts and interpretation apart in anecdotal records.
- Good feedback is specific, timely and points forward.
- Name the marker error from the pattern of marks.
- Rubrics, anonymity and moderation raise reliability.
Check your understanding
-
1. A teacher wants to record only whether each child completed each step of an experiment. The best tool is:
- A checklist
- A rating scale
- A sociogram
- A cumulative record
Show answer
Answer: A. Each step is either done or not done, which is what a checklist records. A rating scale would grade the degree.
-
2. Which entry is a proper anecdotal record?
- Neha is the most caring girl in the whole class
- Neha will obviously become a leader later in life
- On 5 July in the library, Neha helped a classmate find a book and stayed to read with him
- Neha was far kinder than any other pupil, which proves her good character
Show answer
Answer: C. A proper record describes what happened, where and when, without interpretation. The others are judgements.
-
3. A marker who gives almost every paper a mark close to the middle of the range shows:
- Leniency error
- Central tendency
- Halo effect
- Severity error
Show answer
Answer: B. Avoiding both high and low marks and clustering around the middle is the central tendency error.
-
4. Which comment is the most useful feedback on an essay?
- Good work overall, so keep it up and try a little harder next time
- Grade B, which is lower than the grade your friend received
- You are not good at writing, so practise much more at home
- Your opening is clear; add an example in paragraph two to back it up
Show answer
Answer: D. Useful feedback is specific, tied to the work and shows the next step. The others give a vague verdict or compare people.
-
5. Marking a script higher because the previous script was very poor is the:
- Halo effect
- Contrast effect
- Split-half effect
- Spearman effect
Show answer
Answer: B. Judging a script against the one before it, rather than against the criteria, is the contrast effect.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.