• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Expectancy and value, and flow: will I succeed, and is it worth it?

Use the expectancy-value idea (Can I do it? Do I want it?) and the four kinds of task value, and link challenge and skill to the state of flow, with worked examples.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

A pupil who is not trying is not always lazy. Often one of two questions has a discouraging answer: 'Can I succeed at this?' or 'Is it worth my effort?' Expectancy-value theory says that motivation depends on both questions together. This lesson explains the idea, the kinds of value a task can have, and the state of flow, which appears when challenge and skill are well matched.

Motivation as expectancy times value

John Atkinson and, later, Jacquelynne Eccles and Allan Wigfield developed the idea that motivation to do a task depends on two things. Expectancy is the belief about how likely one is to succeed. Value is how much the task matters to the person. The relationship is often written as expectancy x value. The sign 'x' matters: if either part is zero, the product is zero. A pupil who values a task highly but expects to fail will not try, and a pupil who expects to succeed but sees no value in the task will not try either. The numbers below are made up only to show how the rule works, not measurements.

CaseExpectancy (0 to 1)Value (0 to 10)Product
Confident, task matters0.854.0
Doubtful, task matters a lot0.392.7
Very confident, task seems pointless0.921.8
No belief in success at all0.0100.0

Kinds of task value

  • Attainment value: how important it is to do well, because it fits who I am ('I am a person who writes well').
  • Intrinsic (interest) value: the enjoyment of doing the task.
  • Utility value: how useful the task is for my future goals ('I need this to become a nurse').
  • Cost: what I have to give up, such as time, energy or the risk of failure; high cost lowers the value.

Motivation = expectancy (can I?) x value (is it worth it?). If either part is zero, motivation is zero. Raise expectancy by building success; raise value by showing meaning and usefulness.

Flow

The psychologist Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi described flow: a state of deep absorption in an activity in which time seems to pass quickly. Flow tends to occur when the challenge of the task matches the person's skill, when goals are clear, and when feedback is immediate. If the challenge is far above skill, the person feels anxiety. If the challenge is far below skill, the person feels boredom. A teacher who can adjust the challenge for each pupil can bring more pupils into the zone where flow is possible.

Challenge compared with skillLikely feeling
Challenge much higherAnxiety or frustration
Challenge matched to skillFlow, absorption
Challenge much lowerBoredom

Worked example 1: find the weak part

Three pupils are not doing their science project. Pupil A says, 'I know I can do it but it is of no use to me.' Pupil B says, 'It matters a lot to me but I know I will fail.' Pupil C says, 'I enjoy it and I can do it.' Which part of the expectancy-value product is weak for A and for B, and what should the teacher do? Step 1: A has high expectancy and low value, so show the usefulness and link it to A's interests. Step 2: B has high value and low expectancy, so break the project into small steps and arrange early successes. Step 3: C has both, so she needs only support. Answer: A needs value, B needs expectancy, C needs little.

Worked example 2: adjusting challenge

In the same maths class, Rani finds every question trivial and yawns, while Kabir cannot start any question and looks upset. How should the teacher apply the idea of flow? Step 1: Rani's challenge is far below her skill, so she is bored; give her harder problems or an open question. Step 2: Kabir's challenge is far above his skill, so he is anxious; give him a simpler starting question with a worked example, and increase difficulty gradually. Step 3: check that both receive quick feedback. Answer: raise Rani's challenge and lower the starting challenge for Kabir, so that both work near the edge of their skill.

Raising expectancy and value in school

  • Plan early successes and show progress charts, so that expectancy rises.
  • Explain how a topic connects to pupils' lives and futures, which raises utility value.
  • Use interesting contexts and choices, which raise interest value.
  • Reduce costs: avoid humiliation, give enough time, and make help easy to ask for.

Key takeaways: motivation depends on expectancy and value together, and a zero in either makes the product zero; values include attainment, interest, utility and cost; flow appears when challenge matches skill, with anxiety above and boredom below; teachers raise expectancy by engineering success and raise value by showing meaning and usefulness.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In expectancy-value theory, a pupil who is sure that she will fail will lose motivation because:

    1. Her expectancy of success is very low
    2. The task has too much intrinsic value
    3. Her utility value is very high
    4. She has too much autonomy
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A very low expectancy makes the expectancy x value product small however valuable the task is.

  2. 2. Saying 'I need this subject to become a nurse' refers to which kind of task value?

    1. Attainment value
    2. Intrinsic value
    3. Utility value
    4. Cost
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Usefulness for a future goal is utility value.

  3. 3. Flow is most likely when:

    1. The task is far too easy for the learner
    2. Challenge matches the person's skill
    3. The task is far too hard for the learner
    4. There is no feedback of any kind given
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Flow arises when challenge and skill are well matched, with clear goals and feedback.

  4. 4. A pupil who finds every task trivial and yawns is probably experiencing:

    1. Anxiety because challenge is above skill
    2. Flow because challenge is matched
    3. High cost of effort
    4. Boredom because challenge is below skill
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Challenge far below skill leads to boredom, so the teacher should raise the challenge.

  5. 5. Which action best raises a pupil's expectancy of success?

    1. Tell her that the exam decides her future
    2. Plan small, early successes with clear feedback
    3. Compare her marks with the best pupil in public
    4. Give her harder tasks every day without help
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Early success builds belief in one's ability. Threats, public comparison and unsupported difficulty reduce expectancy.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Final self-assessment: Motivation

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery