• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Motivating learners in the classroom: rewards and the overjustification effect

Use rewards wisely, explain the overjustification effect, and choose classroom strategies that build lasting motivation.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Teachers use rewards every day: stars, stickers, marks, praise and prizes. Rewards can help, but used carelessly they can damage the very interest a teacher wants to build. This lesson brings together the earlier ideas into practical classroom rules, and introduces one important warning, the overjustification effect.

The overjustification effect

The overjustification effect is the finding that giving an expected, tangible reward for an activity a person already enjoys can reduce their intrinsic interest in it. The person begins to explain their own behaviour by the reward ('I am doing this for the prize') instead of by enjoyment. When the reward is later taken away, they may do the activity less than before. In a well-known experiment, nursery children who already liked drawing were promised a certificate for drawing; afterwards, in free time, they chose to draw less than children who had not been promised a reward.

Not every reward has this effect. The risk is greatest when the reward is expected (promised beforehand), tangible (a prize, money or sticker), and given for an activity the learner already found interesting. Unexpected rewards and sincere, specific verbal feedback are much less likely to harm interest. For dull tasks that the learner has no interest in, extrinsic rewards can be useful to get them started.

Rule to remember: do not pay children for what they already love doing. Expected tangible rewards for an already enjoyable task can turn play into work and reduce intrinsic interest.

Worked example 1

Situation: Leela reads storybooks every evening for pleasure. Her school starts a scheme: 10 rupees for every book read. After the scheme ends, Leela reads much less. Step 1: was she intrinsically motivated before? Yes, she read for pleasure. Step 2: was a reward expected and tangible? Yes, money was promised for each book. Step 3: what happened after the reward stopped? Reading fell below the earlier level. Answer: this is the overjustification effect.

Practical strategies that build motivation

The ideas from the whole course point to a small set of strategies that most educational psychology textbooks agree on:

  • Arouse curiosity: begin with a puzzle, a surprising fact or a question linked to students' lives.
  • Meet basic needs first: a safe, orderly and friendly classroom (Maslow).
  • Set moderately challenging goals: hard enough to matter, possible enough to reach (McClelland).
  • Give quick, specific feedback: say what was done well and what to improve next.
  • Praise effort and strategy, not 'cleverness': this encourages effort attributions (Weiner).
  • Build self-efficacy: plan small successes and show similar peers succeeding (Bandura).
  • Offer some choice: letting students choose a topic or method supports interest.
  • Use rewards carefully: keep tangible rewards for tasks that lack interest, and do not promise them for activities students already enjoy.

Worked example 2

Situation: A Class 6 teacher finds that half the class have lost interest in science. Which plan is best: (i) announce a prize for the top scorer in the next test, or (ii) start each lesson with a simple experiment, let groups choose a question to investigate, and give each group specific comments on its work? Step 1: plan (i) motivates only those who believe they can top, and is purely extrinsic. Step 2: plan (ii) arouses curiosity, gives choice, and provides feedback, all of which build intrinsic interest and self-efficacy. Answer: plan (ii).

Competition and comparison

Competition in which only one student can win tends to motivate the few who expect to win and discourage the rest. Comparing a learner with his or her own earlier work is usually more motivating than comparing with classmates, because everyone can improve. This links back to high achievers, who like to measure themselves against a standard.

Key takeaways: expected tangible rewards for already-enjoyed activities can reduce intrinsic interest (the overjustification effect); rewards help most with tasks that lack interest; curiosity, safety, moderate challenge, specific feedback, effort praise, choice and small successes build lasting motivation.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The overjustification effect is most likely when:

    1. An unexpected word of praise is given once
    2. A dull task is rewarded to get it started
    3. An expected tangible reward is given for an activity already enjoyed
    4. No reward is given at all
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The effect occurs when a promised, tangible reward is attached to something the person already finds interesting.

  2. 2. Which kind of praise best encourages effort attributions?

    1. 'You are naturally brilliant.'
    2. 'You were lucky today.'
    3. 'You checked every step carefully, that is why you got it right.'
    4. 'That was an easy one anyway.'
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Praising the specific effort and strategy points to an internal, controllable cause the student can repeat. The other comments point to ability, luck or task ease.

  3. 3. A teacher wants students to feel safe before expecting high-level thinking. Which theory supports this?

    1. The overjustification effect
    2. McClelland's need for power
    3. Learned helplessness
    4. Maslow's hierarchy of needs
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Maslow argued that lower needs such as safety generally have to be met before higher needs become the focus.

  4. 4. For a learner with no interest at all in a routine task, an extrinsic reward:

    1. Can be useful to get the learner started
    2. Always destroys intrinsic motivation
    3. Has no effect on behaviour
    4. Turns the learner into a self-actualiser
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Rewards for uninteresting tasks carry little risk of undermining interest and can help a learner begin.

  5. 5. Which comparison is usually most motivating for the whole class?

    1. Each student with his or her own earlier work
    2. Each student with the class topper
    3. Each student with the slowest learner
    4. Boys with girls
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Comparing with one's own past work lets every student see improvement, while ranking against a topper discourages most students.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery