• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Why we succeed or fail: attributions, self-efficacy and learned helplessness

Classify a reason for success or failure on Weiner's three dimensions, explain Bandura's self-efficacy and its sources, and recognise learned helplessness.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

After a test, every student explains the result to themselves: 'I worked hard', 'the paper was tough', 'I am just bad at maths'. These explanations matter more than they seem, because they shape whether the student tries harder next time. This lesson covers three linked ideas: Bernard Weiner's attribution theory, Albert Bandura's self-efficacy, and learned helplessness.

Attribution theory (Weiner)

An attribution is the cause a person gives for a success or failure. Weiner described causes along three dimensions:

  • Locus: is the cause inside the person (internal) or outside (external)?
  • Stability: does the cause stay the same over time (stable) or can it change (unstable)?
  • Controllability: can the person control it (controllable) or not (uncontrollable)?
The four classic causes on Weiner's dimensions
CauseLocusStabilityControllability
AbilityInternalStableUncontrollable
EffortInternalUnstableControllable
Task difficultyExternalStableUncontrollable
LuckExternalUnstableUncontrollable

The most helpful explanation for a failure is usually lack of effort, because effort is internal, unstable and controllable: the student can change it next time. Blaming low ability is the most damaging, because ability is seen as stable and uncontrollable, so the student expects to fail again.

Worked example 1

Statement: 'I failed because I did not revise enough.' Step 1: revising is the student's own action, so locus is internal. Step 2: the amount of revision can change next time, so it is unstable. Step 3: the student decides how much to revise, so it is controllable. Answer: internal, unstable, controllable (an effort attribution).

Self-efficacy (Bandura)

Self-efficacy is a person's belief in their own capability to carry out a particular task or reach a particular goal. It is specific: a girl may have high self-efficacy for drawing and low self-efficacy for algebra. Students with high self-efficacy choose harder tasks, try longer and recover faster from setbacks. Bandura named four sources of self-efficacy:

  1. Mastery experiences: succeeding at the task oneself. This is the strongest source.
  2. Vicarious experiences: seeing someone similar succeed ('if she can, so can I').
  3. Verbal (social) persuasion: being told by a trusted person that one can do it.
  4. Physiological and emotional states: how calm or anxious one feels while doing the task.

Rule to remember: effort is the attribution to encourage, because it is internal, unstable and controllable. Self-efficacy grows most from the learner's own successes.

Learned helplessness

Learned helplessness is the state in which a person, after repeated experiences where their actions seemed to make no difference, stops trying even when success has become possible. Martin Seligman and his colleagues first described it in animal experiments. In school it appears as a child who says 'whatever I do, I will fail' and does not even attempt the question. It is linked to explaining failure by stable, uncontrollable causes such as low ability.

Worked example 2

Situation: Imran failed three maths tests in a row. Now he leaves the maths paper blank, saying 'I am not a maths person, there is no use.' Step 1: he has stopped trying altogether. Step 2: his reason is low ability, which he sees as stable and uncontrollable. Step 3: the pattern of giving up after repeated failure matches learned helplessness. Remedy: give him short tasks he can succeed at (mastery experiences), praise specific effort and strategies, and help him explain failures by effort or method instead of ability.

What teachers can do with these ideas

Teachers shape attributions through what they say. A comment such as 'you are clever' points to ability, which the child cannot control. A comment such as 'you planned your answer well' points to effort and strategy, which the child can repeat. When a student fails, the teacher can help the student find a controllable cause, such as practice or a better method, and then give a chance to succeed. This raises self-efficacy and protects against helplessness. The three ideas therefore work together: helpful attributions and small successes build self-efficacy, and strong self-efficacy keeps a learner trying.

Key takeaways: Weiner classified causes by locus, stability and controllability; effort is internal, unstable and controllable; self-efficacy is task-specific belief in one's capability, built most by mastery experiences; learned helplessness is giving up after repeated failure that seemed uncontrollable.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In Weiner's theory, 'luck' as a cause is:

    1. Internal, stable and controllable
    2. External, unstable and uncontrollable
    3. External, stable and controllable
    4. Internal, unstable and controllable
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Luck comes from outside the person, changes from time to time and cannot be controlled.

  2. 2. Which attribution for failure is most helpful for future effort?

    1. Low ability
    2. Lack of effort
    3. A very hard task
    4. Bad luck
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Effort is internal, unstable and controllable, so the student can change it next time. The others are outside the student's control.

  3. 3. Self-efficacy means:

    1. Belief in one's capability to perform a particular task
    2. General feeling of being liked
    3. The score on an intelligence test
    4. The need to control others
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Bandura defined self-efficacy as a person's belief that they can carry out a specific task successfully.

  4. 4. Which is the strongest source of self-efficacy according to Bandura?

    1. Mastery experiences
    2. Verbal persuasion
    3. Vicarious experiences
    4. Physiological states
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Succeeding at the task oneself gives the most powerful evidence of capability, so mastery experiences are the strongest source.

  5. 5. A child who has failed many times stops trying even on easy questions, saying nothing he does matters. This is:

    1. Intrinsic motivation
    2. Self-actualisation
    3. Learned helplessness
    4. Need for power
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Giving up after repeated failure that seemed uncontrollable is learned helplessness.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery