• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Goals and mindsets: mastery and performance goals, growth and fixed mindset

Distinguish mastery from performance goals, describe Dweck's fixed and growth mindsets, and apply Locke's rules for useful goals to classroom work.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Motivation is not only how strong a pupil's effort is but what the pupil is trying to achieve. Two pupils may work equally hard; one wants to understand the topic, and the other wants to look clever. Psychologists call these different goal orientations, and they lead to very different behaviour when work becomes difficult. This lesson covers the two kinds of goal, the beliefs about ability that go with them, and what makes a goal useful.

Mastery goals and performance goals

A learner with a mastery goal (also called a learning or task goal) wants to understand, improve and master the material. Success is measured against her own earlier performance. A learner with a performance goal (also called an ego goal) wants to show ability, get better marks than others, or avoid looking stupid. Success is measured against other people. Researchers who developed these ideas include Carol Dweck, Carole Ames and John Nicholls.

ItemMastery goalPerformance goal
AimUnderstand and improveLook able and beat others
StandardMy own progressOther people's results
MistakesInformation about what to learn nextSigns of failure to be hidden
Hard taskChosen as a chance to learnAvoided if there is a risk of looking poor
When stuckKeeps trying or asks for helpMay give up or avoid help

Mindsets

Dweck also described beliefs about ability. A fixed mindset is the belief that intelligence or talent is a fixed amount that cannot change much. A growth mindset is the belief that ability can be developed by effort, good strategies and help from others. Pupils with a growth mindset tend to take mastery goals and see mistakes as part of learning; pupils with a fixed mindset tend to take performance goals and fear mistakes, because a mistake seems to prove a lack of ability. The link is a tendency and not a rule, and mindsets can be shifted by how teachers talk.

Mastery goal = to understand and improve (self-referenced). Performance goal = to look able or beat others. Growth mindset = ability can grow. Fixed mindset = ability is fixed.

Goals that work

Edwin Locke and Gary Latham's research on goal setting found that goals raise effort when they are specific (a clear target, not 'do your best'), challenging but attainable, accepted by the person who will work towards them, and accompanied by feedback on progress. A goal that is too easy requires little effort; a goal that seems impossible is dropped. Breaking a far goal into short-term steps lets learners see progress and keeps motivation alive.

Worked example 1: classify the pupil

Identify the goal orientation of each pupil. (a) Mohan chooses an easy puzzle in front of friends so that he will not make mistakes. (b) Sita picks the harder puzzle because she wants to learn how it works, even though she may fail the first time. (c) Joseph asks the teacher 'What marks did Ali get?' before looking at his own corrections. Step 1: (a) avoiding risk of looking poor, so performance goal. Step 2: (b) wanting to learn, so mastery goal. Step 3: (c) comparing with others, so performance goal. Answer: performance, mastery, performance.

Worked example 2: improve a goal

A teacher tells a pupil, 'Try to do better in maths.' Rewrite it as a useful goal. Step 1: the goal is vague, so make it specific: 'Learn the eight tables up to ten times each.' Step 2: make it challenging but possible by checking where the pupil is now: she knows five of the eight. Step 3: add a short time frame and feedback: 'Learn one new table every two days, and we will check after six days.' Step 4: let the pupil agree to it. Answer: a goal that is specific, challenging but attainable, accepted, and supported by feedback. The pupil's progress (five known, eight to learn, so three new tables) is visible, which supports motivation.

How teachers shape goals and mindsets

  • Praise effort, strategy and improvement ('You tried a new method and it worked') rather than fixed ability ('You are so clever').
  • Treat mistakes as part of learning; ask 'What did we learn from this?'
  • Compare pupils with their own earlier work, not with each other.
  • Avoid public ranking by marks; use private feedback.
  • Offer tasks of varied difficulty and let pupils choose challenges.

Key takeaways: mastery goals aim at understanding and self-improvement and performance goals at looking able or beating others; growth mindset sees ability as developable and fixed mindset as unchangeable; useful goals are specific, challenging but attainable, accepted and supported by feedback; teachers shape goals through the praise and comparisons they use.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A pupil works on a hard puzzle because she wants to learn how it works. This is a:

    1. Performance goal
    2. Fixed mindset
    3. Mastery goal
    4. Extrinsic reward
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Aiming to understand and improve is a mastery (learning) goal.

  2. 2. Which statement describes a growth mindset?

    1. Ability can grow through effort and good strategies
    2. Ability is fixed from birth and can hardly ever change
    3. Needing effort proves that a person lacks ability
    4. Mistakes prove that a task is quite impossible to do
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A growth mindset is the belief that ability can grow. The other options describe a fixed mindset.

  3. 3. A pupil chooses easy tasks so as not to look foolish in front of the class. This shows:

    1. A mastery goal
    2. A need for physiological safety
    3. An internal and unstable attribution
    4. A performance goal
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Avoiding the risk of looking poor is typical of a performance goal, which is measured against others.

  4. 4. According to goal-setting research, which goal is most useful?

    1. 'Try to do better'
    2. 'Learn three new tables by Friday'
    3. 'Do your best'
    4. 'Become the best student in the world'
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A specific, achievable goal with a deadline and a way to check progress is most effective; vague goals give little direction.

  5. 5. Which teacher comment best supports a growth mindset?

    1. 'You tried a new method and it worked. Good thinking.'
    2. 'You are naturally gifted at maths, just like your sister.'
    3. 'You are the cleverest pupil in the whole class today.'
    4. 'Not everyone can be good at maths, and that is fine.'
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Praise for effort and strategy supports a growth mindset. Praise for fixed talent or comments about limits support a fixed mindset.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery