- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Self-determination theory: autonomy, competence and relatedness
State the three basic psychological needs of self-determination theory and use them to judge classroom practices as supporting or controlling.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Earlier lessons in this course looked at the difference between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation and at the effect of rewards. Self-determination theory, developed by Edward Deci and Richard Ryan, goes a step further. It asks what conditions help people feel that their effort belongs to them, and it names three needs that must be met for motivation to flourish. Teachers can use these three needs as a simple checklist for a classroom.
The three basic psychological needs
| Need | Meaning | What it feels like for a pupil |
|---|---|---|
| Autonomy | Feeling that you are choosing and directing your own actions | 'I have a say; this is my work' |
| Competence | Feeling effective and able to master challenges | 'I can do this, and I am getting better' |
| Relatedness | Feeling connected to and cared for by others | 'I belong here and people care' |
When the three needs are met, pupils tend to show more intrinsic motivation, interest and persistence. When they are blocked, pupils feel pressured or helpless, and they either comply without interest or withdraw. These are not the same as Maslow's needs, which are about a ladder of needs from food to self-actualisation; the three needs here are psychological and are thought to matter at all times.
Self-determination theory (Deci and Ryan): motivation grows when the needs for autonomy, competence and relatedness are supported.
Autonomy-supportive and controlling teaching
A teacher can support autonomy by offering real choices, explaining why a task matters, using non-pressuring language and acknowledging pupils' feelings. A teacher controls when she uses threats, deadlines used as pressure, 'should' and 'must' language and public comparison. Autonomy does not mean that anything goes: structure, clear expectations and guidance support competence, and autonomy support works best together with them. A teacher who gives choice but no guidance leaves pupils feeling lost, not free.
| Support | Typical teacher behaviour | Controlling behaviour |
|---|---|---|
| Autonomy | Offers a choice of topics or methods; explains the reason | Gives orders; 'Do it because I said so' |
| Competence | Sets clear, achievable steps; gives informative feedback | Gives vague tasks; only says 'Wrong' |
| Relatedness | Shows interest in pupils; welcomes every child | Ignores some pupils; ridicules mistakes |
Worked example 1: which need is being met?
Classify each action by the need it supports. (a) A teacher lets groups choose which of three animals to study for a project. (b) A teacher tells a pupil, 'Last week you needed my help with this; today you did it alone.' (c) A teacher greets every child by name and sits with a lonely pupil at lunch. Step 1: (a) choice of topic supports autonomy. Step 2: (b) showing growth supports competence. Step 3: (c) caring and belonging support relatedness. Answer: autonomy, competence, relatedness.
Worked example 2: rewrite the instruction
A teacher says, 'You must finish this worksheet or I will tell your parents.' Rewrite it in an autonomy-supportive way. Step 1: remove the threat. Step 2: give the reason: 'Finishing this will help you for tomorrow's test.' Step 3: give some choice: 'You can do the odd questions first or the even ones; which do you prefer?' Step 4: acknowledge feelings: 'I know it is long and Friday afternoon is tiring.' Answer: 'This worksheet will help you for tomorrow's test. It is long, and I know that Friday afternoon is tiring. You may start with the odd or even questions, whichever you prefer.' The task is the same; the pupil's sense of ownership is greater.
Why choice must be real
Choices should be meaningful and within the pupil's ability. 'Choose which of these two equally dull tasks to do' is a weak choice. Offering too many options can overwhelm a young learner, so two or three well-chosen options are enough. A choice that the teacher then criticises or overrides is not a choice at all.
Link with rewards
Self-determination theory explains why a reward felt as control can lower interest: it reduces the sense of autonomy. A reward or praise felt as informative feedback about competence can raise it. This links to the overjustification effect from earlier in the course.
Key takeaways: the three needs are autonomy, competence and relatedness; supporting them raises intrinsic motivation; autonomy support means choice, reasons and acknowledging feelings, together with clear structure; threats, pressure and ridicule are controlling; rewards felt as control lower interest, while informative feedback supports competence.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which three needs are central to self-determination theory?
- Safety, esteem and achievement
- Achievement, affiliation and power
- Attention, retention and reproduction
- Autonomy, competence and relatedness
Show answer
Answer: D. Deci and Ryan named autonomy, competence and relatedness. The other sets belong to Maslow, McClelland and Bandura.
-
2. A teacher lets pupils choose between three project topics. This mainly supports:
- Competence
- Autonomy
- Safety
- Physiological needs
Show answer
Answer: B. Having a say in what to do supports the need for autonomy.
-
3. Which statement is autonomy-supportive?
- 'Do it because I am the teacher and I said so.'
- 'Do it today or I will tell your parents.'
- 'This will help you; start where you like.'
- 'Everyone must do exactly as I show them.'
Show answer
Answer: C. Giving a reason and a choice supports autonomy. Orders and threats are controlling.
-
4. Telling a pupil 'Last month you could not do this, today you did it alone' supports mainly:
- Competence
- Relatedness
- Autonomy
- Fear of failure
Show answer
Answer: A. Showing growth in ability supports the feeling of being effective, which is competence.
-
5. Which description of self-determination theory is most accurate?
- Motivation depends only on external rewards
- Only physiological needs matter at school
- Motivation grows when three needs are supported
- Motivation cannot be changed by any teacher
Show answer
Answer: C. The theory holds that supporting autonomy, competence and relatedness fosters intrinsic motivation. Teachers can influence these conditions.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.