- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Achievement motivation in practice: task choice and the three needs
Apply McClelland's needs for achievement, affiliation and power to classroom choices, predict which task a high achiever picks, and avoid the risk-taking trap.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Questions on achievement motivation usually describe a choice: which project, which game distance, which team, which kind of feedback. Once you know how people high in each of McClelland's needs make choices, these questions become quick. This lesson trains that prediction, adds the related idea of fear of failure, and points out the most common trap.
The three needs as choices
David McClelland described three learned needs. A person high in the need for achievement chooses situations where they can show skill against a standard. A person high in the need for affiliation chooses situations that bring warmth and acceptance. A person high in the need for power chooses situations that bring influence over others. The fastest way to classify a scenario is to ask what the person gains from the choice: excellence, friendship or control.
| Need | Gain sought | Typical choice | Typical feedback wanted |
|---|---|---|---|
| Achievement | Excellence, improving one's own standard | Moderately difficult task, personal responsibility | Quick, specific, task-related |
| Affiliation | Acceptance, friendship | Group work with friends, avoiding conflict | Signs of approval and warmth |
| Power | Influence, control, status | Leadership role, debating, organising others | Recognition of influence |
Why moderate difficulty?
A very easy task gives success but says nothing about skill. A very hard task makes success a matter of luck, so it does not show skill either. A task of moderate difficulty is where effort and skill make the biggest difference to the result, so it gives the most information and the most satisfaction to a person who wants to do well. Research that built on McClelland's work, notably by John Atkinson, added that people driven mainly by fear of failure tend to pick either very easy tasks (to be sure of success) or very hard ones (so that failure is not embarrassing).
Speed rule: high need for achievement means moderate risk, personal responsibility and quick feedback. Very easy or very hard choices point instead to fear of failure.
Worked example 1
Scenario: In a basketball shooting game, four students may choose their distance. Asha chooses 1 metre, Bina 3 metres, Charu 9 metres, and Dev refuses to play. Who most likely has the highest need for achievement? Step 1: 1 metre is near-certain success, which shows little skill. Step 2: 9 metres makes success mostly luck. Step 3: 3 metres is a real but reachable challenge. Answer: Bina. Asha and Charu fit the fear-of-failure pattern, and Dev avoids the task.
Worked example 2
Scenario: For a group project, Mohan asks to be put in the group with his best friends even though the topic bores him; Lata asks to coordinate the whole class's projects and assign roles; Sunil asks for a difficult topic and wants the teacher to check his draft every week. Classify each. Step 1: Mohan's gain is being with friends, affiliation. Step 2: Lata's gain is directing others, power. Step 3: Sunil wants challenge plus regular feedback, achievement. Answer: Mohan affiliation, Lata power, Sunil achievement.
The common trap
Candidates often think a high achiever picks the hardest possible task. That is wrong. The high achiever wants a challenge that skill can win, which means moderate difficulty. Another trap is mixing need for power with need for achievement: a student who wants to win the captaincy to control the team shows power, while one who wants to improve her own batting average shows achievement. Finally, remember that McClelland treated these needs as learned, so a teacher can strengthen the need for achievement through realistic goals, feedback and recognition of improvement.
Key takeaways: classify by the gain sought (excellence, friendship or control); high achievers pick moderate difficulty, take responsibility and want quick feedback; fear of failure leads to very easy or very hard choices; the hardest task is not the high achiever's choice; these needs are learned and can be developed.
Check your understanding
-
1. A student high in need for achievement is offered three projects: very easy, moderately difficult and nearly impossible. Which will she most likely choose?
- Very easy
- Nearly impossible
- Whichever her friends choose
- Moderately difficult
Show answer
Answer: D. Moderate difficulty is where skill and effort make the difference, which is what a high achiever wants.
-
2. A student who mainly fears failure is most likely to choose:
- Always a moderately difficult task
- Only tasks with quick feedback
- Leadership roles
- Either a very easy or a very hard task
Show answer
Answer: D. Very easy tasks guarantee success and very hard tasks make failure unembarrassing; both protect a person who fears failure.
-
3. Kiran wants to become house captain mainly so he can decide who plays in each match. This reflects need for:
- Power
- Achievement
- Affiliation
- Safety
Show answer
Answer: A. Wanting to control decisions about others is need for power.
-
4. Which feedback suits a student high in need for achievement best?
- 'Your second paragraph lacks evidence; add two examples.'
- 'Everyone likes you, well done.'
- A grade given at the end of the year only
- No feedback, to avoid pressure
Show answer
Answer: A. High achievers want prompt, specific, task-related feedback that tells them how to improve.
-
5. McClelland's view that these needs are learned implies that a teacher:
- Cannot change a child's motivation at all
- Can strengthen achievement motivation through realistic goals and feedback
- Should place all children only in friendship groups
- Should give only very easy tasks
Show answer
Answer: B. Because the needs are acquired, classroom experiences such as realistic goals and specific feedback can develop them.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.