- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Rewards, praise and the overjustification effect: classroom decisions
Predict when rewards help or harm motivation, choose the best form of praise, and solve mixed scenario questions on classroom motivation.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Many questions in teaching-aptitude papers are framed as 'what should the teacher do?'. The options often include a reward, a punishment, a competition, and a strategy that builds interest. To choose correctly, you need to know when rewards work, when they backfire through the overjustification effect, and which kinds of praise build lasting motivation. This lesson ends with mixed scenarios that use the whole course.
When do rewards undermine interest?
The overjustification effect is the drop in intrinsic interest that can follow when a person receives an external reward for an activity they already enjoyed. The person comes to see the reward as the reason for doing it, so when the reward stops, so does much of the activity. Three conditions make the effect most likely, and they are easy to check:
- The activity was already interesting to the learner.
- The reward is expected: promised in advance as a condition ('if you do this, you get that').
- The reward is tangible: money, sweets, stickers, certificates, prizes.
When all three are present, expect interest to fall later. When the activity was dull to begin with, an extrinsic reward has little intrinsic interest to damage and can help the learner start. Unexpected rewards, given after the event without having been promised, are much less likely to undermine interest. Sincere, specific verbal feedback that tells learners about their competence tends to support interest rather than harm it.
Speed rule for rewards: already interesting + expected + tangible = risk of the overjustification effect. Dull task, unexpected reward, or informative praise = little or no risk.
Which praise works?
Praise is most useful when it is specific (it names what was done well), sincere, and directed at effort and strategy rather than at fixed traits. 'You tried three methods before finding one that worked' tells the learner what to repeat and supports an effort attribution. 'You are so clever' points to ability, which the learner cannot control, and may make the learner avoid hard tasks to protect the label. Praise that is vague, constant or given for very easy work loses its value and can even signal that the teacher expects little.
Worked example 1
Scenario: Students in Class 4 love the class garden and water it every day. The headteacher proposes paying each child 5 rupees per watering. What is the likely long-term effect? Step 1: already interesting? Yes, they love it. Step 2: expected? Yes, promised per watering. Step 3: tangible? Yes, money. All three conditions hold. Answer: when payments stop, watering is likely to fall, because of the overjustification effect. Better: thank the children and let them show the garden to visitors.
Worked example 2
Scenario: Class 8 find spelling drills boring and rarely complete them. The teacher introduces a sticker chart for completed drills for a few weeks, while also making drills shorter and turning some into word games. Is the sticker chart a mistake? Step 1: already interesting? No, the drills were boring. Step 2: so the reward has little intrinsic interest to undermine and helps students start. Step 3: the teacher also makes the task more interesting, which can grow intrinsic interest over time. Answer: not a mistake; this is an appropriate use of extrinsic rewards.
Choosing the best teacher response
When a question asks for the best response, prefer options that build intrinsic motivation and self-efficacy: arousing curiosity, giving choice, setting moderately challenging goals, giving specific feedback, linking learning to students' lives, and creating a safe, accepting classroom. Be wary of options built on public ranking, prizes only for the top few, punishment, threats, or comparison with others. These can raise effort briefly for some students but tend to discourage the majority.
Key takeaways: the overjustification effect needs an already interesting activity and an expected, tangible reward; rewards help start dull tasks; specific, sincere praise for effort and strategy is best; choose responses that build curiosity, choice, challenge and self-efficacy over punishment and ranking.
Check your understanding
-
1. In which case is the overjustification effect most likely?
- A child who dislikes drills gets a sticker for finishing them
- A child receives an unexpected thank-you note after helping
- A child who loves painting is promised money for every painting
- A child is told specifically what was good about her essay
Show answer
Answer: C. Here the activity is already enjoyed and the reward is expected and tangible, the three conditions for the effect.
-
2. Which praise is most likely to build lasting motivation?
- 'You are a genius.'
- 'You checked each step and found your own error; that is good work.'
- 'Good.' said after every answer
- 'Even you got it right this time.'
Show answer
Answer: B. Specific praise for effort and strategy tells the learner what to repeat and supports an effort attribution.
-
3. Using a sticker chart to get students started on a task they find dull is:
- Always harmful because of overjustification
- Acceptable, because there is little intrinsic interest to undermine
- A form of punishment
- An example of self-actualisation
Show answer
Answer: B. The overjustification effect concerns activities already found interesting; for dull tasks, rewards can help learners begin.
-
4. A teacher wants every student, not only the toppers, to try harder in mathematics. Which approach is best?
- Announce a prize for the top three scorers
- Set each student a goal to improve on their own last score and give specific feedback
- Display marks in descending order on the wall
- Give extra homework to low scorers as a penalty
Show answer
Answer: B. Personal improvement goals with feedback let everyone succeed and build self-efficacy; prizes and rankings motivate only the few likely to win.
-
5. Rewards given unexpectedly, after the activity, without having been promised, are:
- Less likely to undermine intrinsic interest
- The main cause of the overjustification effect
- A sign of learned helplessness
- Always more harmful than expected rewards
Show answer
Answer: A. The effect depends on the reward being expected as a condition; unexpected rewards are much less likely to change why the learner does the activity.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.