- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Goal orientation and mindset in practice: reading the teacher's words and the pupil's choices
Identify mastery or performance goals and growth or fixed mindsets from pupils' choices and teachers' comments, and choose the better teacher response.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Items on goals and mindsets give short quotations: what a pupil says, which task she chooses, or what a teacher writes in a notebook. You must label the goal or the mindset and then pick the better response. The labels come from three clues: what the learner compares herself with, how she treats mistakes, and what she does when the work gets hard. This lesson drills those clues.
The three clues
| Clue | Mastery goal / growth mindset | Performance goal / fixed mindset |
|---|---|---|
| Compares with | Own earlier work | Other pupils |
| Mistakes | 'What can I learn?' | 'I look stupid; hide it' |
| Hard task | Chosen or accepted as a chance to grow | Avoided, or chosen only if success is certain |
| Help | Asked for readily | Avoided as a sign of weakness |
| Praise wanted for | Effort, progress, strategy | Marks, ability, being best |
Self-referenced progress and learning from mistakes = mastery/growth. Comparison with others and hiding mistakes = performance/fixed.
Worked example 1: label the quotation
Label each. (a) 'I do not want to ask the teacher; everyone will think I am slow.' (b) 'My last essay had four mistakes; this one has two, so I am improving.' (c) 'I chose the easy sheet so that I can finish first and get full marks.' (d) 'I cannot draw; I was born without that talent.' Working: (a) avoiding help to protect image, so performance goal. (b) comparing with her own earlier work, so mastery goal. (c) choosing for marks and speed, so performance goal. (d) ability seen as fixed, so fixed mindset. Answer: performance, mastery, performance, fixed mindset.
Worked example 2: counting the improvement
A teacher wants to show a pupil her progress. Her spelling tests in four weeks scored 12, 14, 15 and 18 out of 20. How should the teacher present it? Step 1: find the improvement: 18 - 12 = 6 marks. Step 2: express it against the starting point: 6 is half of 12, so the score rose by 50 percent. Step 3: connect it to effort: 'You practised the word lists every night and your score went up by six marks.' Answer: a self-referenced, effort-based message. Comparing with the class average would make this a performance message.
Worked example 3: choose the better comment
Which comment on a pupil's poor result supports a growth mindset better? (A) 'Maths is not your subject.' (B) 'Compare with Anil, who got full marks.' (C) 'Let us look at which steps went wrong; you have not yet learned the second method, and with practice you will.' Working: (A) declares ability fixed. (B) uses comparison with another pupil. (C) focuses on strategy and says the skill is not yet learned, which implies it can be. Answer: (C). The word 'yet' is a useful sign of a growth message.
Worked example 4: redesign the classroom practice
A teacher displays a chart of marks in rank order on the notice board. What is the likely effect and what is a better practice? Working: ranking makes comparison with others the standard and encourages performance goals and fear of mistakes, particularly for lower-ranked pupils. A better practice is to give private feedback, to show each pupil's own progress, and to celebrate improvement and effort. Answer: replace the public ranking with private, self-referenced progress records.
Goal-setting items
For goal-setting items, remember the features of an effective goal: specific, challenging but attainable, accepted by the learner, and supported by feedback. 'Do your best' fails the first test; 'finish the whole syllabus this week' fails the second; a goal set without the learner's agreement fails the third.
Traps
- Mastery goals do not mean that marks are unimportant; they mean that understanding is the aim.
- A pupil may work very hard for a performance goal; effort alone does not decide the goal.
- Growth mindset does not mean praising everything; praise should be honest and linked to what the pupil did.
- Mindsets are tendencies, not labels for people.
Key takeaways: read the clues - comparison, mistakes, hard tasks, help; prefer comments on effort, strategy and 'not yet'; avoid public ranking; effective goals are specific, attainable, accepted and followed by feedback.
Check your understanding
-
1. 'I do not want to ask for help because everyone will think I am slow.' This shows:
- A mastery goal
- A growth mindset
- A performance goal
- Intrinsic interest in the topic
Show answer
Answer: C. Avoiding help to protect one's image is typical of a performance goal.
-
2. A pupil compares this week's essay with her own essay of last month. This is typical of:
- A mastery goal
- A performance goal
- Learned helplessness
- Extrinsic motivation only
Show answer
Answer: A. Comparing with her own earlier work is the self-referenced standard of a mastery goal.
-
3. Which teacher comment best supports a growth mindset?
- 'You are just not a maths person, I am afraid.'
- 'Look at how much better Anil did than you.'
- 'You are naturally gifted, so do not worry at all.'
- 'You have not learned this method yet; let us practise.'
Show answer
Answer: D. A comment about a skill not yet learned and practice to come shows ability as developable.
-
4. A pupil's tests in four weeks were 8, 10, 11 and 14 out of 20. By how many marks did she improve from the first test to the last?
- 3 marks
- 6 marks
- 4 marks
- 14 marks
Show answer
Answer: B. 14 - 8 = 6 marks. Showing a pupil such a self-referenced gain supports a mastery goal.
-
5. Which practice is most likely to encourage performance goals and fear of mistakes?
- Displaying a public rank list of marks
- Giving private feedback on each pupil's progress
- Praising effort and improvement
- Treating mistakes as chances to learn
Show answer
Answer: A. Public ranking makes comparison with others the standard. The other options support mastery goals.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.