- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Self-determination theory in practice: supportive or controlling?
Judge teacher statements and classroom set-ups as supporting or blocking autonomy, competence and relatedness, and rewrite controlling instructions.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Items on self-determination theory follow a pattern. A short classroom event is described, and you are asked which need it supports, whether it is autonomy-supportive or controlling, or how to improve it. Because the theory has only three needs, the work is quick if you ask three questions in turn. This lesson drills the method.
Three questions for any event
- Autonomy: did the pupil have a choice, a reason, or room to take initiative? Or was she ordered, threatened or pressured?
- Competence: was the task matched to her ability, with informative feedback and visible progress? Or was it too hard, too easy or answered only with 'wrong'?
- Relatedness: did she feel accepted and cared about? Or ignored, ridiculed or excluded?
Ask three questions: choice and reason (autonomy), success and informative feedback (competence), acceptance and care (relatedness). Controlling words: must, should, or else; supportive words: because, you may choose, I understand.
Language of control and support
| Controlling | Autonomy-supportive |
|---|---|
| 'You must do this now.' | 'You can choose when to begin; it is due on Friday.' |
| 'If you fail I will call your parents.' | 'This will help you in the next unit; how can I help?' |
| 'Stop complaining and start.' | 'I see this is dull; here is why it matters and what you can change.' |
| 'Do it my way.' | 'Here are two methods; pick the one that suits you.' |
Worked example 1: which need is blocked?
Find the need blocked in each case. (a) A teacher laughs when a pupil gives a wrong answer and the class joins in. (b) Pupils are given the same hard worksheet, and half of them cannot start. (c) Every project topic is assigned with no discussion, and a pupil asks if she may choose a topic about her village. The teacher says no. Step 1: (a) ridicule blocks the sense of belonging, so relatedness. Step 2: (b) the task is far above some pupils' ability, so competence. Step 3: (c) no choice is allowed, so autonomy. Answer: relatedness, competence, autonomy.
Worked example 2: rewrite it
Rewrite 'Everyone will copy this map exactly as I have drawn it, or lose marks.' in an autonomy-supportive and competence-supporting way. Step 1: give a reason: 'A clear map will help you in the geography test.' Step 2: offer choice: 'You can copy my map or draw one in your own style using the same key.' Step 3: give informative feedback criteria: 'I will check that rivers, borders and labels are clear.' Step 4: acknowledge feelings: 'I know that drawing takes time.' Answer: 'A clear map helps you in the test. You may copy mine or draw your own style, as long as rivers, borders and labels are clear. I know it takes time, so you have two periods.'
Worked example 3: structure and autonomy together
A teacher says: 'You may do anything you like today; I will not help.' A student says this is autonomy support. Is it? Working: giving total freedom without guidance leaves pupils without the structure they need to feel competent, and a 'no help' stance can reduce relatedness. Autonomy support combines choice with clear expectations, resources and help. Answer: no; it is neglect, not autonomy support.
Rewards through the SDT lens
A reward promised for doing a task that the pupil already likes, such as a sweet for every drawing, can be felt as control and may reduce the pupil's interest. A reward given unexpectedly or praise that gives specific information about what the pupil did well is felt as informative and supports competence. In an item, look at whether the reward is described as 'controlling' or 'informational'.
Traps
- Choice does not mean letting pupils decide everything; limits and reasons are part of support.
- Relatedness is about feeling accepted, not about being friends with every classmate.
- Competence support includes challenging tasks, as long as the help is there.
- Praise that is vague ('good') gives little information, but praise that names what was done well supports competence.
Key takeaways: use the three questions; controlling language pressures, supportive language gives reasons and choice; autonomy support works with structure; rewards felt as control lower interest and informative feedback supports competence.
Check your understanding
-
1. A teacher laughs when a pupil gives a wrong answer. Which need is most directly blocked?
- Autonomy
- Competence
- Physiological needs
- Relatedness
Show answer
Answer: D. Ridicule damages the pupil's sense of being accepted, which is relatedness. It may harm the others too, but this is the most direct effect.
-
2. Which instruction is autonomy-supportive?
- 'Copy my map exactly as drawn or lose marks.'
- 'A clear map helps you; choose your own style.'
- 'Stop complaining and start drawing at once.'
- 'I have no time for any questions today.'
Show answer
Answer: B. Giving a reason and a choice supports autonomy. The other statements pressure or dismiss the pupil.
-
3. The whole class receives an extremely hard worksheet and half cannot start. The need most affected is:
- Relatedness
- Autonomy
- Competence
- Self-actualisation
Show answer
Answer: C. A task far above the pupils' ability makes it impossible to feel effective, so competence is blocked.
-
4. 'Do whatever you like today; I will not help anyone.' This is:
- Neglect, not true autonomy support
- The best form of autonomy support
- A strong form of competence support
- A form of relatedness support
Show answer
Answer: A. Autonomy support combines choice with structure and help. Total freedom without help leaves pupils without guidance.
-
5. Praise saying exactly what the pupil did well, such as 'Your labels are clear and complete', mainly supports:
- Fear of failure
- Controlled behaviour
- Competence
- Learned helplessness
Show answer
Answer: C. Informative feedback shows what was done well and supports the feeling of being effective.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.