• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Attribution, self-efficacy and helplessness: exam drills

Classify any stated cause on Weiner's three dimensions, tell self-efficacy from self-esteem, name the source of self-efficacy in a scenario, and spot learned helplessness.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

This is the most frequently confused area of motivation, because three ideas sit close together: the causes students give for results (Weiner), their belief that they can do a task (Bandura), and giving up after repeated failure (learned helplessness). This lesson gives a fixed three-question routine for attributions and clear contrasts for the others.

The three-question routine for attributions

For any cause, ask three questions in the same order. Locus: is it inside the person or outside? Stability: will it stay the same next time or can it change? Controllability: can the person change it by deciding to? Write the answer as three words, for example internal-unstable-controllable. The table extends the classic four causes with two more that commonly appear in questions.

Attribution grid for quick lookup
CauseLocusStabilityControllability
Ability (aptitude)InternalStableUncontrollable
EffortInternalUnstableControllable
Mood or illness on the dayInternalUnstableUncontrollable
Study method or strategyInternalUnstableControllable
Task difficultyExternalStableUncontrollable
LuckExternalUnstableUncontrollable

Two pairs are worth memorising because options are built from them. Ability and mood are both internal and uncontrollable, but ability is stable while mood is unstable. Effort and luck are both unstable, but effort is internal and controllable while luck is external and uncontrollable.

Worked example 1

Statement: 'I could not concentrate in the exam because I had a high fever.' Locus: the fever is in the student, so internal. Stability: fever passes, so unstable. Controllability: the student did not choose to fall ill, so uncontrollable. Answer: internal, unstable, uncontrollable. Note the trap: many candidates mark 'external' because illness feels like something that happened to them, but it is located in the person.

Worked example 2

Statement: 'I scored low because I only read the notes and never practised writing answers.' Locus: the method was the student's own, internal. Stability: the method can be changed, unstable. Controllability: the student can choose a different method, controllable. Answer: internal, unstable, controllable. This is a helpful attribution, like effort, because it points to something the student can fix.

Routine to remember: Locus (inside or outside?), Stability (same next time?), Control (can I change it?). Encourage effort and strategy attributions; they are internal, unstable and controllable.

Self-efficacy is not self-esteem

Self-efficacy (Bandura) is a belief about capability for a specific task: 'I can solve these equations.' Self-esteem is a general evaluation of one's own worth: 'I am a worthwhile person.' A student can have high self-esteem and low self-efficacy for geometry. In scenario questions, the four sources of self-efficacy are identified by what happened: succeeding oneself is a mastery experience (the strongest source); watching a similar person succeed is a vicarious experience; being told 'you can do it' by someone trusted is verbal persuasion; feeling calm or having a racing heart is the physiological and emotional state.

Learned helplessness

Learned helplessness is the expectation, formed through repeated experiences where effort seemed not to matter, that outcomes are out of one's control, so the person stops trying even when success is possible. It goes with stable, uncontrollable attributions for failure. Do not confuse it with laziness: the helpless student believes effort is useless, while a lazy student simply chooses not to try. The remedy is to give experiences where effort clearly works and to retrain attributions toward effort and strategy.

Key takeaways: apply locus, stability and control in order; illness and mood are internal but uncontrollable; strategy, like effort, is internal, unstable and controllable; self-efficacy is task-specific and different from self-esteem; mastery is the strongest source; learned helplessness is believing effort is useless.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. 'I failed because I was unwell on the day of the test.' On Weiner's dimensions this is:

    1. Internal, unstable, uncontrollable
    2. External, unstable, uncontrollable
    3. Internal, stable, controllable
    4. External, stable, uncontrollable
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Illness is located in the person (internal), passes (unstable), and was not chosen (uncontrollable).

  2. 2. Which two causes are both internal and uncontrollable but differ in stability?

    1. Ability and mood
    2. Effort and luck
    3. Luck and task difficulty
    4. Effort and strategy
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Ability (stable) and mood (unstable) are both internal and uncontrollable. Luck and task difficulty are external; effort and strategy are controllable.

  3. 3. Self-efficacy differs from self-esteem because self-efficacy is:

    1. A general judgement of one's own worth
    2. Fixed at birth
    3. Measured by IQ
    4. A belief about capability for a specific task
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Self-efficacy is task-specific (for example, 'I can solve these equations'), while self-esteem is a general sense of worth.

  4. 4. Seema watches her classmate, who has the same background as her, solve a hard puzzle, and starts believing she can too. The source of self-efficacy is:

    1. Mastery experience
    2. Verbal persuasion
    3. Vicarious experience
    4. Physiological state
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Watching a similar person succeed is a vicarious experience.

  5. 5. How does learned helplessness differ from simple laziness?

    1. The helpless student believes effort is useless; the lazy student chooses not to try
    2. They are the same thing
    3. The lazy student believes effort is useless
    4. Learned helplessness occurs only in very young children
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Learned helplessness is an expectation, learned through repeated uncontrollable failure, that effort makes no difference.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery