| Statement contains | Usually | Why |
|---|---|---|
| 'because it is fun', 'I wonder why', 'I love solving it' | Intrinsic | Payoff is the activity itself |
| marks, rank, prize, certificate, money | Extrinsic | Tangible outcome separate from the task |
| praise, approval, 'parents will be proud' | Extrinsic | Social reward given by others |
| 'so I get a good job', 'to clear the exam' | Extrinsic | Future outcome separate from the learning |
| 'or I will be punished', 'to avoid scolding' | Extrinsic | Avoiding an outside consequence |
Speed rule: ignore the emotional words and locate the payoff. Inside the task means intrinsic; outside the task, including praise, approval, a future job or avoiding punishment, means extrinsic.
Key takeaways: use the remove-the-reward test; intrinsic payoffs are interest, curiosity, enjoyment and mastery; praise, approval, marks, ranks, future jobs and avoiding punishment are all extrinsic; do not be misled by emotional or noble-sounding words.