- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Experience-based methods: role play, simulation, case study and field trips
Learn how role play, simulation, the case method and field trips give pupils experience of real situations, and what makes each of them work and fail.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Some things are hard to learn from words alone: how a market works, how a council decides, how it feels to be in another person's place, what a river looks like. Experience-based methods give pupils a chance to act in, study or visit a real or realistic situation. This lesson covers four of them, with the steps each follows and a note on how they are told apart.
Role play
In role play pupils act out the parts of people in a situation, such as a customer and a shopkeeper, a patient and a doctor, or two villagers arguing over a well. The teacher sets the situation, assigns the roles, lets the scene run for a few minutes and then leads a discussion on what happened and why. It builds communication, empathy and understanding of other points of view. It needs a clear aim, a safe atmosphere and time for discussion; without the discussion it may be only entertainment.
Simulation
A simulation is a model of a real process or system, in which pupils take decisions and see the results. Examples are a mock parliament, a classroom 'bank' with pretend money, or a computer model of a farm in which pupils choose crops and see the harvest. It is wider than role play, because it imitates a whole system with rules and consequences, and pupils learn by making choices without real-world risk. Its limits are the time for preparation and the risk that pupils treat it as a game and forget the learning aim.
The case method
A case study is a detailed account of a real or realistic situation, such as a school with falling attendance or a village that changed its crop. Pupils study the facts, analyse the causes, consider alternatives and suggest what should be done. There is often no single right answer. The method trains analysis and decision making, and is common in management, law and teacher education. It needs well-written cases and a teacher who guides rather than gives the solution.
Field trips
A field trip (excursion or educational visit) takes pupils out of the classroom to see things at first hand: a farm, a post office, a museum, a river bank. For a trip to teach well it has three phases. Before: the teacher sets the purpose, gets permission and arranges safety, and pupils prepare questions. During: pupils observe, ask, sketch and note. After: the class discusses, writes a report and links what was seen to the syllabus. A trip without preparation and follow-up becomes a holiday.
| Method | What pupils do | Key difference |
|---|---|---|
| Role play | Act out people in a scene | Focus on a person's point of view |
| Simulation | Make decisions in a model of a system | A whole process with rules and results |
| Case study | Analyse a described situation | Study and discuss, without acting it out |
| Field trip | Visit the real thing | Direct experience outside the classroom |
Worked example 1: name the method
(a) Pupils run a 'class shop' for a week, set prices, keep accounts and see profit and loss. (b) Two pupils act as a farmer and a moneylender, and the class discusses their feelings. (c) The teacher gives a two-page description of a school that stopped bullying, and groups list the causes of the change. (d) Pupils walk to a nearby pond to collect samples of water. Answers: (a) simulation, because a system with decisions and consequences is modelled; (b) role play; (c) case study; (d) field trip.
Worked example 2: planning the phases
A teacher plans a visit to a post office for Class 4. Before: explain the purpose (to learn how a letter travels), obtain permission, and prepare three questions such as 'Who sorts the letters?' During: pupils watch, ask the questions, and draw the route of a letter. After: pupils write a short account, make a flow chart of the letter's journey and discuss what surprised them. If the teacher had skipped the first and third phases, pupils would walk through the building without a purpose and would not connect it to the syllabus.
Experience needs reflection: role play needs discussion, simulation needs a link to the aim, a case needs analysis, and a trip needs preparation and follow-up.
Key takeaways
- Role play acts out a person's part; simulation models a system; a case study analyses a described situation; a field trip is a visit.
- Each method needs a clear aim and a discussion after the activity.
- A field trip has before, during and after phases.
Check your understanding
-
1. Pupils run a pretend bank for a week and take lending and saving decisions. This is a:
- Case study
- Field trip
- Simulation
- Lecture
Show answer
Answer: C. A whole system with rules and consequences is modelled.
-
2. What is the main aim of a role play?
- To help pupils see another person's viewpoint
- To give the teacher a rest period in class
- To test the pupils' memory of facts alone
- To reduce the size of the syllabus overall
Show answer
Answer: A. Acting in a role helps pupils see how others think and feel.
-
3. Which phase of a field trip includes preparing questions and getting permission?
- During the trip
- After the trip
- None of the phases
- Before the trip
Show answer
Answer: D. Planning and preparation come before the visit.
-
4. A teacher gives a written account of a school that improved its results and asks groups to analyse why. This is a:
- Role play
- Case study
- Field trip
- Simulation
Show answer
Answer: B. A described situation is analysed and discussed.
-
5. What mainly makes a field trip an effective method?
- Preparation before and follow-up after
- Visiting as many places as possible
- Choosing a place far from the school
- Giving pupils complete freedom to roam
Show answer
Answer: A. Without purpose and follow-up, a trip is only an outing.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.