- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Methods that make pupils active: discussion, cooperative learning, play-way and activities
Describe the discussion method, cooperative learning, the play-way method and activity-based learning, and say when each suits a class.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The previous lesson divided methods into teacher-centred and learner-centred. This lesson looks at four learner-centred methods that are used every day in primary and middle schools. In each one, pupils are doing something: talking, working together, playing or handling materials. Knowing what makes each method distinct helps you recognise it in a question and choose it for the right purpose.
The discussion method
In the discussion method, pupils exchange ideas on a topic under the teacher's guidance. The teacher poses a good question, makes sure many voices are heard, keeps the talk on track and helps the class sum up at the end. Discussion develops thinking, listening, speaking and respect for other views. It works best on topics where there is something to think about, such as 'Why should we save water?', rather than on simple facts. Forms of discussion include whole-class discussion, small-group discussion, debate and panel discussion.
Cooperative learning
In cooperative learning, pupils work in small groups towards a shared goal, and each member has a part to play. Two features make it different from simply sitting in a group. Positive interdependence means the group succeeds only if every member does their part. Individual accountability means each pupil is responsible for their own learning, so nobody can leave all the work to others. A common technique is the jigsaw: each member of a group studies one part of a topic, meets with members of other groups who studied the same part, and then teaches it back to their own group.
The play-way method
The play-way method uses play, games, songs, rhymes and stories to teach. Play is natural to children, so learning through it is enjoyable and holds attention. The idea has deep roots; Froebel's kindergarten, for example, was built around play and activity. A counting game with seeds, a shop role play to learn money, or an action song to learn the parts of the body are all play-way activities. The method suits young children especially, but games can be used with older pupils too.
Activity-based learning
Activity-based learning means pupils learn by doing: measuring, making models, collecting leaves, conducting simple experiments, drawing maps. The idea of learning by doing is strongly associated with John Dewey. Activities make abstract ideas concrete and let pupils discover things for themselves. They must be planned with a clear learning aim, otherwise they become busy work that is fun but teaches little.
| Method | What pupils do | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Discussion | Share and question ideas | Topics needing reasoning and opinions |
| Cooperative learning | Work in groups, each with a part | Building understanding and social skills together |
| Play-way | Learn through games, songs, role play | Young children, practice made enjoyable |
| Activity-based | Learn by doing and handling things | Making ideas concrete |
Worked example 1: name the method
Situation: a Class 4 teacher divides the class into groups of four to study animals. In each group one pupil reads about food, one about homes, one about movement and one about young ones. Then each pupil explains their part to the group, and every pupil takes a short quiz on all four parts. Working: the group needs every member's part (positive interdependence), and each pupil is tested individually (individual accountability). This is cooperative learning, using the jigsaw technique.
Worked example 2: choosing for the aim
A Class 1 teacher wants pupils to learn the numbers one to ten. Which method suits best: a lecture on numbers, a debate, or counting games with beads and a number song? Working: six-year-olds learn best through play and concrete handling. A lecture is too abstract, and a debate needs reasoning beyond the topic. So the counting games and song, a play-way and activity approach, suit best.
In every active method the pupils do the work. Cooperative learning needs both a shared goal and each pupil's own responsibility.
Key takeaways
- Discussion: guided exchange of ideas; the teacher poses questions and sums up.
- Cooperative learning: positive interdependence plus individual accountability.
- Play-way: learning through play, games and songs, natural for young children.
- Activity-based learning: learning by doing, with a clear aim.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which feature most clearly separates cooperative learning from simply seating pupils in groups?
- Pupils sit facing each other
- The teacher leaves the room
- Each member has a part and is individually responsible, and the group succeeds only together
- The fastest pupil does all the work
Show answer
Answer: C. Positive interdependence and individual accountability are the defining features. Sitting together alone does not make learning cooperative.
-
2. A teacher uses a 'shopkeeper and customer' role play with toy coins to teach Class 2 about money. This is an example of:
- the lecture method
- the play-way method
- the heuristic method
- the Dalton plan
Show answer
Answer: B. Learning through a game and role play is the play-way method, well suited to young children.
-
3. Which topic is best suited to the discussion method?
- The spelling of 'necessary'
- Should children have homework every day?
- The date written on the board
- The number of days in a week
Show answer
Answer: B. Discussion suits topics where pupils can reason and hold different views. The other options are simple facts with nothing to discuss.
-
4. The idea of 'learning by doing' is most closely associated with:
- B. F. Skinner
- Noam Chomsky
- John Dewey
- Helen Parkhurst
Show answer
Answer: C. Dewey's pragmatism stressed learning by doing and experience. Skinner is linked with reinforcement, Chomsky with language, and Parkhurst with the Dalton plan.
-
5. Why must an activity in activity-based learning have a clear learning aim?
- Activities are not allowed without written permission
- Without an aim, the activity can be enjoyable but teach little
- An aim makes the activity shorter
- An aim removes the need for pupils to do anything
Show answer
Answer: B. Activity-based learning is meant to produce learning; an activity without a clear aim risks becoming busy work.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.