• Foundation
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Questioning, storytelling, the Socratic method and brainstorming

Learn four methods built on talk: the questioning method, storytelling, the Socratic method of leading questions, and brainstorming, with the strengths and limits of each.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Some of the oldest and most useful teaching methods need no equipment at all, only the teacher's voice and the pupils' minds. This lesson covers four of them. Exam questions ask you to name the method from a classroom description, and to say what makes each one work.

The questioning method

In the questioning method the teacher teaches mainly by asking questions that lead pupils to think. Good questions are clear, short, one at a time, and fit the pupils' level. Questions range from recall ('Name the capital of a state'), to understanding ('Explain why the days are longer in summer'), to higher-order ('What would happen if the Earth were not tilted?'). A teacher should ask the question first and then name a pupil, so everyone thinks; give a few seconds of silence, called wait time, before taking an answer; and respond to wrong answers without ridicule, often by asking another question. The method keeps pupils alert but fails if the questions are only yes or no, or if a few pupils answer every time.

The storytelling method

Stories hold attention, are easy to remember and carry values and facts together. A teacher might tell the story of a scientist's discovery, a historical event, or a folk tale to teach honesty. A good story has a clear beginning, a middle and an end, uses expression and gesture, and is linked to the aim of the lesson at the end by a few questions. The method suits young children most, and works for history, languages and moral education. Its limit is that pupils may remember the story and miss the idea it was meant to teach, so the follow-up matters.

The Socratic method

The Socratic method is named after the Greek thinker Socrates, who taught by conversation. The teacher asks a chain of questions that lead the pupil to examine his own beliefs, find a contradiction or a gap, and then reach a better idea by his own reasoning. The teacher does not simply tell the answer. For example, to lead a pupil to see that heavier things do not always fall faster, the teacher might ask, 'Does a heavy stone fall faster than a light one? What about a stone and a leaf? What makes the leaf slow?' The method develops critical thinking, but it needs skill, time and a small group, and it can embarrass a pupil if used harshly.

Brainstorming

In brainstorming a group produces as many ideas as possible on a problem in a short time. The method is linked with Alex Osborn, who set out its rules: no criticism while ideas are being produced; the more ideas the better; welcome unusual ideas; and combine and improve the ideas of others. Only after the generating stage are the ideas sorted and the best chosen. It promotes creativity and participation, and is useful for projects and problem solving, but ideas still need to be tested, and a dominant pupil can take over.

MethodMain featureBest forLimit
QuestioningTeacher teaches through questionsChecking and deepening understandingPoor questions give poor thinking
StorytellingNarrating a story linked to the aimYoung children, values, historyMessage may be missed
SocraticChain of leading questions to expose gapsCritical thinkingNeeds skill and a small group
BrainstormingMany ideas, no criticism at firstCreative solutionsIdeas need testing later

Worked example 1: name the method

(a) A teacher asks, 'What is the difference between weather and climate?', waits, and then chooses a pupil. (b) A teacher tells the story of a child who returned a lost purse and ends with three questions. (c) Pupils are asked to list every possible use of an old newspaper in two minutes, and the teacher says, 'No ideas will be rejected yet.' (d) A teacher asks, 'Is a tomato a fruit or a vegetable? What is a fruit? Does a tomato contain seeds?' to lead pupils to revise their idea. Answers: (a) questioning; (b) storytelling; (c) brainstorming; (d) Socratic method.

Worked example 2: improving a question

A teacher asks the class, 'Does a plant need water?', and a chorus replies, 'Yes.' Why it is weak: it is a yes-or-no question, the answer is obvious and everyone calls out together. Improved version: 'What do you think would happen to a plant that is given sunlight but no water for two weeks? Think for a moment, then tell your partner.' This asks for reasoning, gives wait time and shares the thinking. The teacher then calls a few pupils to report, a better use of questioning.

Ask first, then name the pupil; wait; follow up. Story needs a link to the aim; Socratic questions expose a gap; brainstorming postpones judgement.

Key takeaways

  • Questions can be recall, understanding or higher-order; wait time improves answers.
  • A story must be linked to the lesson's aim by follow-up questions.
  • The Socratic method leads pupils by questions to examine and improve their own ideas.
  • Brainstorming separates the generating of ideas from judging them.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A teacher asks a question, pauses for a few seconds and then calls on a pupil. The pause is called:

    1. Recitation time
    2. Wait time
    3. Rest time
    4. Drill time
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Waiting gives every pupil time to think before an answer is taken.

  2. 2. Which question is at the highest level?

    1. Name the planet that is nearest the Sun
    2. What is the SI unit of force in physics?
    3. Which gas do green plants take in daily?
    4. What if the Earth did not rotate at all?
    Show answer

    Answer: D. It asks pupils to reason about a new situation.

  3. 3. Which rule belongs to brainstorming?

    1. No criticism while ideas are produced
    2. Reject unusual ideas as soon as they come
    3. Aim to produce one best idea only at once
    4. Let the teacher choose the ideas first
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Judgement is postponed so that many ideas come out.

  4. 4. A teacher leads a pupil by a chain of questions to find a contradiction in his belief and revise it. This is the:

    1. Storytelling method
    2. Brainstorming method
    3. Socratic method
    4. Lecture method
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Leading questions that expose gaps are the mark of the Socratic method.

  5. 5. What is the main limit of the storytelling method?

    1. It cannot be used with young children
    2. It needs expensive equipment
    3. It allows no use of expression
    4. Pupils may remember the story but not the idea
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Without a link to the aim, the message may be lost.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery