- Foundation
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Methods of finding out: project, problem solving, heuristic, discovery and the Dalton plan
Describe the project method (Kilpatrick), the problem-solving method, Armstrong's heuristic method, Bruner's discovery learning and the Dalton plan, and tell them apart.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Some methods go further than making pupils active: they make pupils find knowledge out for themselves. The teacher sets up a purpose, a problem or a question, and pupils investigate. These methods appear often in teaching aptitude questions, usually with the name of the person linked to each. This lesson introduces five of them one at a time, with what makes each one distinct.
The project method
The project method is linked with William Heard Kilpatrick, a follower of John Dewey. A project is a purposeful activity that pupils carry out wholeheartedly, in a real-life social setting. Pupils choose or accept a purpose, plan how to achieve it, carry out the plan and then judge the result. These four steps are usually given as purposing, planning, executing and judging. For example, a class running a small school vegetable garden learns science (plants, soil, water), mathematics (measuring plots, recording growth) and cooperation, all through one real task.
The problem-solving method
In the problem-solving method, pupils are faced with a real or realistic problem and work through it step by step: recognising and defining the problem, collecting information, suggesting possible solutions (hypotheses), testing them and reaching a conclusion. For example: 'Why do the plants on the classroom window-sill keep wilting?' Pupils might check water, light and soil, try changes, and conclude. The method trains logical thinking that pupils can use outside school too.
The heuristic method
The heuristic method was put forward by H. E. Armstrong, a chemistry teacher, for teaching science. The word comes from a Greek word meaning 'to find out'. The pupil is placed in the position of a discoverer and is told as little as possible; they find facts out through their own experiments and observation, with the teacher asking guiding questions. Its strength is independence and a scientific attitude; its limit is that it takes a great deal of time and is hard for young or weaker pupils without support.
Discovery learning
Discovery learning is most associated with Jerome Bruner. Pupils are given examples, materials or questions and work out the underlying principle themselves, rather than being told it. For instance, pupils measure the angles of many triangles and discover that they add up to 180 degrees. Bruner believed that knowledge discovered by the learner is better understood and remembered. Guided discovery, where the teacher arranges the examples and asks leading questions, is the form most used in schools.
The Dalton plan
The Dalton plan was developed by Helen Parkhurst. Pupils receive monthly assignments, sometimes thought of as contracts, and work through them at their own pace in subject rooms or laboratories, with teachers available for help. It emphasises individual work, freedom to organise one's own time, and responsibility for completing the assignment. Its focus on the individual pupil's pace is what sets it apart.
| Method | Usually linked with | Key idea |
|---|---|---|
| Project method | Kilpatrick | Purposeful real-life task: purposing, planning, executing, judging |
| Problem solving | (general method) | Define problem, gather data, hypothesise, test, conclude |
| Heuristic method | H. E. Armstrong | Pupil as discoverer, especially in science |
| Discovery learning | Jerome Bruner | Pupil works out the principle from examples |
| Dalton plan | Helen Parkhurst | Individual assignments at the pupil's own pace |
Worked example 1: name the method
Situation: Class 8 decides to organise a school exhibition on clean water. They plan stalls, divide work, build models, run the exhibition and afterwards discuss what went well and what did not. Working: there is a real purpose chosen by the class, then planning, execution and judging in a social setting. This is the project method.
Worked example 2: heuristic or Dalton?
Situation A: each pupil receives a month's assignment in science and mathematics and decides which days to work on which subject, going to the subject room when ready. Situation B: in a chemistry period, pupils are asked to find out what happens to the weight of iron when it rusts, and must design their own test. Working: A centres on self-paced individual assignments, so it is the Dalton plan. B puts the pupil in the place of a discoverer in science, so it is the heuristic method.
Project: a purposeful real task (Kilpatrick). Heuristic: pupil as discoverer (Armstrong). Discovery: find the principle (Bruner). Dalton plan: individual assignments at own pace (Parkhurst).
Key takeaways
- Project method steps: purposing, planning, executing, judging.
- Problem solving runs from defining a problem to testing solutions and concluding.
- Heuristic method: pupils find out for themselves, like scientists.
- Discovery learning: pupils derive the principle from examples.
- Dalton plan: individual, self-paced assignments.
Check your understanding
-
1. The project method is most closely associated with:
- H. E. Armstrong
- Helen Parkhurst
- Jerome Bruner
- W. H. Kilpatrick
Show answer
Answer: D. Kilpatrick developed the project method from Dewey's ideas. Armstrong is linked with the heuristic method, Parkhurst with the Dalton plan, and Bruner with discovery learning.
-
2. The word 'heuristic' comes from a Greek word meaning:
- to play
- to remember
- to find out
- to listen
Show answer
Answer: C. Heuristic means 'to find out'; the method puts the pupil in the position of a discoverer.
-
3. Which method gives each pupil monthly assignments to complete at their own pace?
- The lecture method
- The play-way method
- The Dalton plan
- The demonstration method
Show answer
Answer: C. Self-paced individual assignments are the defining feature of the Dalton plan.
-
4. Pupils are given many examples of words like 'hopping', 'running' and 'sitting', and asked to work out when the last consonant is doubled before '-ing'. This is an example of:
- discovery learning
- the lecture method
- the Dalton plan
- rote learning
Show answer
Answer: A. Pupils derive the rule from examples instead of being told it, which is discovery learning.
-
5. Which is the usual order of steps in Kilpatrick's project method?
- Planning, purposing, judging, executing
- Judging, executing, planning, purposing
- Executing, planning, purposing, judging
- Purposing, planning, executing, judging
Show answer
Answer: D. A purpose comes first, then a plan, then carrying it out, and finally judging the result.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.