- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Seminar, workshop, symposium, panel discussion and tutorial: group formats
Tell apart the common group formats used in teaching and training, learn what each one involves, and plan the timing of a session.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Besides classroom methods, teachers and trainers use group formats with their own names and rules: seminar, workshop, symposium, panel discussion, tutorial and conference. They are often listed together in exam questions, which ask you to identify one from its description. This lesson explains each and shows how to tell them apart.
The formats
| Format | What happens | Main features |
|---|---|---|
| Seminar | Participants prepare papers or topics on a theme, present them and discuss | Prepared presentations followed by discussion, led by a chair |
| Workshop | Participants work together on a practical task or skill to produce something | Learning by doing, hands-on, small groups |
| Symposium | Several speakers, each an expert, give short talks on different aspects of one topic | A series of prepared talks, then questions |
| Panel discussion | A small group of experts discuss a topic in front of an audience under a moderator | Spontaneous exchange among the panel; the audience listens, then questions |
| Tutorial | A tutor works with one student or a small group on difficulties and questions | Personal attention, follow-up of lectures |
| Conference | A larger meeting of many people, with several sessions and papers | Wide scope, many speakers and delegates |
A simple way to remember them: seminar is presentation plus discussion; workshop is doing; symposium is a set of short talks on parts of a topic; panel is a conversation among experts; tutorial is personal help.
Seminar and workshop in teaching
In a school or college, a seminar helps students research a topic, organise ideas and speak; the teacher or a student chairs, and the others question and add. A workshop might be held for teachers to prepare low-cost teaching aids: each participant leaves with something made. The two differ in that the first is mainly about ideas and talk, while the second is mainly about practice and products.
Planning a session
Formats need a plan of timing. A symposium has an opening by the chairperson, short talks by each speaker with a time limit, a period for questions and a summing up. If speakers keep to their times the session ends on time; if one speaker takes too long, the discussion is cut.
Worked example 1: name the format
(a) Four invited experts each give a ten-minute talk on a different aspect of 'the use of ICT in schools', one after another, and then take questions. (b) A group of trainees spends a day in a hall, preparing charts and models for teaching science. (c) Three experts sit on a stage and discuss 'Should homework be abolished?' with a moderator, while the audience listens and later asks questions. (d) A teacher meets three students weekly to go through their difficulties in algebra. Answers: (a) symposium, since several short talks on aspects of one theme; (b) workshop, because people make things by working; (c) panel discussion; (d) tutorial.
Worked example 2: timing a symposium
A symposium on 'Reading in primary schools' has a chairperson who opens for 5 minutes, four speakers of 10 minutes each, 15 minutes for questions and a 5-minute summing up. Total: 5 + (4 x 10) + 15 + 5 = 65 minutes. If the hall is booked for 60 minutes, 5 minutes must be cut. The organisers could shorten each talk to 9 minutes (4 x 9 = 36 instead of 40, saving 4 minutes) and shorten the opening to 4 minutes, which brings the total to 4 + 36 + 15 + 5 = 60 minutes. The times are only an example.
Seminar: papers and discussion. Workshop: doing. Symposium: several short talks on one theme. Panel: experts converse. Tutorial: personal help.
Key takeaways
- Each format has its own structure, and exams ask you to identify them from a description.
- A workshop is practical; a seminar is mainly presentation and discussion.
- A symposium has separate speakers; a panel is a discussion among experts.
- Good sessions are timed in advance.
Check your understanding
-
1. Several experts give short talks on different aspects of one topic. This is a:
- Workshop
- Tutorial
- Panel discussion
- Symposium
Show answer
Answer: D. A series of prepared talks on parts of a topic is a symposium.
-
2. A group of teachers makes low-cost teaching aids in a one-day programme. This is a:
- Seminar
- Workshop
- Symposium
- Lecture
Show answer
Answer: B. Participants learn by making something.
-
3. In which format do experts converse among themselves before an audience under a moderator?
- A seminar with papers
- A tutorial for one student
- Panel discussion
- A workshop on practical tasks
Show answer
Answer: C. The panel members talk to each other, while the audience listens.
-
4. A seminar session has 3 papers of 12 minutes each and 24 minutes of discussion. How long does it last?
- 60 minutes
- 36 minutes
- 48 minutes
- 72 minutes
Show answer
Answer: A. 3 x 12 = 36, and 36 + 24 = 60 minutes.
-
5. A tutorial is best described as:
- A large meeting with many separate papers
- A hands-on practical programme for teachers
- Personal help to a student or small group
- A series of short talks by invited experts
Show answer
Answer: C. The tutor works closely with one student or a few.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.