• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Group formats and technology methods: quick identification and timing

Practise telling apart seminar, symposium, panel and workshop, and linear from branching programmes, and solve the short timing and counting problems that go with them.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Group formats and technology methods are tested mostly through definitions, so the exam skill is to separate near-identical words. This lesson gives a list of identifying questions and traps, and two worked timing problems.

Identifying questions

Ask...If yes
Do participants present prepared papers and then discuss?Seminar
Do several experts each speak briefly on a different part of one topic?Symposium
Do a few experts converse before an audience, led by a moderator?Panel discussion
Do participants work together to make something or practise a skill?Workshop
Does one tutor help a small group with its difficulties?Tutorial
Do learners go through small frames with immediate feedback at their own pace?Programmed instruction
Does the path change according to the learner's answers?Branching programme
Is the new content studied at home and practice done in class?Flipped classroom

Traps

  • Symposium versus panel. In a symposium, speakers give prepared talks one after another; in a panel, experts talk with each other.
  • Seminar versus workshop. A seminar is mainly papers and talk; a workshop is mainly doing and making.
  • Linear versus branching. The linear programme is the same for all; the branching programme sends the learner to extra frames after an error.
  • Blended versus flipped. Blended mixes face-to-face and online learning in general; flipped specifically moves the first meeting with the content out of class and uses class time for practice.

Worked example 1: timing a seminar

A seminar is to last 90 minutes. The chair speaks for 10 minutes in all, four papers are each presented for 15 minutes, and there is a 5-minute discussion after each paper. Total: 10 + (4 x 15) + (4 x 5) = 10 + 60 + 20 = 90 minutes. The plan fits. If the discussions were extended to 8 minutes each, the total would be 10 + 60 + 32 = 102 minutes, which is 12 minutes too long, so either the papers would have to be cut or the discussion shortened. Always check that the parts add up to the time.

Worked example 2: frames in a branching programme

A branching programme has 40 main frames. A learner answers 85 percent correctly. Each wrong answer sends the learner to 2 extra help frames. Correct answers: 85 percent of 40 = 34, so there are 40 - 34 = 6 errors. Extra frames: 6 x 2 = 12. Frames seen in total: 40 + 12 = 52. A learner who answers every frame correctly sees 40, so the learner who made errors has seen 12 more, but at his own pace and with the extra explanation exactly where needed. In a linear programme, all learners would see the same 40 frames. (The numbers are made up for practice.)

Why the distinctions matter. The format shapes who does the talking. In a seminar the participants are the main speakers; in a symposium and a panel, invited experts speak and the audience mostly listens; in a workshop everyone is busy with a task; in a tutorial the student's own difficulties set the agenda. A teacher chooses the format by asking who should be active and what should come out of the session.

Papers and discussion: seminar. Short talks by experts: symposium. Experts converse: panel. Doing: workshop. Path changes with answers: branching.

Key takeaways

  • Use identifying questions for each format and each programme type.
  • Symposium and panel differ in whether the experts speak in turn or converse.
  • Add up the parts of a session to check its timing.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Experts speak in turn on different aspects of one topic and then take questions. This is a:

    1. Panel discussion
    2. Workshop
    3. Tutorial
    4. Symposium
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Prepared talks one after another are a symposium.

  2. 2. In a panel discussion, the experts:

    1. Read prepared papers one after another
    2. Talk with each other under a moderator
    3. Make models and charts in groups
    4. Sit an examination set by the chair
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The exchange is among the panel members.

  3. 3. A session has 2 papers of 20 minutes and 10 minutes of discussion after each, with 5 minutes for the chair. How long is the session?

    1. 50 minutes
    2. 60 minutes
    3. 65 minutes
    4. 70 minutes
    Show answer

    Answer: C. 2 x 20 = 40; 2 x 10 = 20; 40 + 20 + 5 = 65 minutes.

  4. 4. A branching programme sends a learner to 3 help frames after each error. A learner makes 4 errors in a 30-frame programme. How many frames does he see?

    1. 42
    2. 34
    3. 33
    4. 46
    Show answer

    Answer: A. 4 x 3 = 12 help frames, and 30 + 12 = 42.

  5. 5. Which is the best description of a flipped classroom?

    1. All lessons are delivered entirely online
    2. The teacher and the pupils swap places daily
    3. New content is met at home; practice is in class
    4. The class meets together only once a term
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The usual order of home and class work is reversed.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery