- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Naming the method from a classroom scenario
Identify the teaching method in a classroom description using a short set of test questions, and avoid the traps that make one method look like another.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Most method questions in teaching aptitude papers do not ask for a definition. They describe a classroom for three or four lines and ask which method is being used. The descriptions are written so that two options look possible: pupils in groups may or may not be cooperative learning; pupils doing something may or may not be a project. This lesson gives a fast test sequence and practises it on scenarios with built-in traps. It assumes you know the methods from the foundation course.
A five-question test
- Who is most active? If only the teacher talks or shows, it is lecture or demonstration. If pupils act, go on.
- Is there a real-life purpose that pupils adopt and carry through? If yes, with planning, carrying out and judging, it is the project method.
- Is each pupil working alone at their own pace on set assignments? That is the Dalton plan.
- Are pupils finding out like scientists, told almost nothing? Heuristic method. Are they deriving a principle from arranged examples? Discovery learning.
- Are pupils in groups with each member needed and each accountable? Cooperative learning. Is learning through games, songs or role play? Play-way.
The order matters. Ask first who is active, because a large number of options can be removed at once. Then look for the one feature that only one method has: a real purpose (project), self-pacing (Dalton), the pupil as discoverer in science (heuristic), a principle reached from examples (discovery).
Trap 1: group work is not automatically cooperative learning
If pupils sit in groups but one pupil does the task while others watch, there is no positive interdependence and no individual accountability. The method is group work at best. Look for evidence that each member has a role and that each is assessed or responsible.
Trap 2: an activity is not automatically a project
Making a model of a volcano in one period because the teacher said so is an activity. A project needs a purpose the pupils adopt, a plan they make, execution over time, and judging of the result, usually in a real social setting. The word 'project' in a question does not prove it is the project method; schools often call any assignment a project.
Trap 3: demonstration versus discovery
If the teacher performs the experiment and pupils watch, it is a demonstration, even if the teacher asks questions. If pupils perform it and work out the conclusion themselves, it is discovery or heuristic. The test is who handles the materials and who reaches the conclusion.
Worked example 1
Scenario: 'The teacher shows a picture of a dam, asks pupils what they think the dam does, writes their answers on the board and then explains the correct uses.' Working with the test: the teacher asks questions, but the knowledge comes from the teacher's explanation, and pupils neither investigate nor reach a principle themselves. There is no real-life purpose and no individual assignment. This is a lecture-cum-discussion led by the teacher, teacher-centred in essence. If the options were lecture, project, heuristic and Dalton plan, the lecture would be the best answer because the teacher supplies the knowledge.
Worked example 2
Scenario: 'Pupils are given ten pairs of numbers and their products. Working in pairs, they notice that whenever both numbers are odd, the product is odd, and they state the rule. The teacher then asks them to test it with new numbers.' Working: pupils are active; there is no real-life purpose or self-pacing; they derive a general principle from examples arranged by the teacher. This is (guided) discovery learning. It is not heuristic in the classic sense, because the teacher arranged the examples and the content is a mathematical pattern rather than finding out through one's own experiment in science; in an item listing both, discovery is the better fit.
Ask who is active first, then look for the single feature only one method has: real purpose, own pace, discoverer in science, principle from examples, or each member needed.
Key takeaways
- Use the test in order: who is active, real purpose, own pace, discovery, groups.
- Groups without roles and accountability are not cooperative learning.
- An activity done to order is not a project; a project has purpose, planning, execution and judging.
- If the teacher handles the materials and draws the conclusion, it is a demonstration.
Check your understanding
-
1. Pupils sit in groups of five to draw a map, but in each group the best artist draws while the others chat. What is the strongest reason this is NOT cooperative learning?
- The pupils are sitting in groups
- There is no individual role or accountability for the other members
- The task involves drawing
- The teacher set the task
Show answer
Answer: B. Cooperative learning needs each member to have a part and be responsible. Here one pupil does everything, so neither condition is met.
-
2. A teacher performs an experiment showing that light travels in straight lines, explaining each step as pupils watch and answer her questions. The method is best described as:
- heuristic
- demonstration
- project
- Dalton plan
Show answer
Answer: B. The teacher handles the materials and leads to the conclusion while pupils watch. Asking questions does not change that it is a demonstration.
-
3. Which detail, if added to a scenario, would most clearly make it the project method?
- The class adopts a real purpose, plans it, carries it out and judges the result
- The teacher calls the task a 'project'
- Pupils make a model in one period
- Pupils copy notes about a topic
Show answer
Answer: A. The project method is defined by a purposeful real-life task carried through purposing, planning, executing and judging, not by the label 'project'.
-
4. Each pupil receives written assignments for the month and moves between subject rooms when ready, seeking help from subject teachers as needed. Which method is this?
- Team teaching
- Play-way method
- Dalton plan
- Lecture method
Show answer
Answer: C. Self-paced individual assignments in subject rooms define the Dalton plan.
-
5. Pupils are asked to find out, by their own tests, which of five liquids is the best at dissolving sugar. The teacher answers questions only with further questions. This is closest to:
- the demonstration method
- team teaching
- the lecture method
- the heuristic method
Show answer
Answer: D. Pupils act as discoverers through their own experiments with minimal telling, which is the heuristic method.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.