- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Role play, simulation, case study and field trip in scenarios: telling them apart
Practise naming the experience-based method from a classroom scenario, using four test questions and avoiding the usual look-alike traps.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Exam scenarios for the experience-based methods are short descriptions of pupils doing something, with four methods as options. The methods overlap in what they look like, so a clear test for each helps. This lesson gives four test questions and the traps that catch careless readers.
Four test questions
- Do pupils act as people in a situation, speaking as those people? Then role play.
- Do pupils make decisions in a model of a system and see consequences? Then simulation.
- Do pupils study a written or spoken description of a situation and analyse it? Then case study.
- Do pupils go to the real place or thing outside the classroom? Then field trip.
Traps
- A script is not a role play. Pupils reading a prepared script are performing a play. In role play they improvise a situation.
- A game is not always a simulation. A quiz game ends in a score. A simulation models how a system works, so decisions have consequences that follow the rules of the system.
- A video of a river is not a field trip. A field trip means direct contact with the real place.
- A written case is studied, not acted. If pupils act out the case, the method becomes role play; if they only read and analyse, it is a case study.
- A laboratory experiment is not a field trip. The pupils stay in school.
Worked example 1: three scenarios
(a) Pupils are told that a shopkeeper has overcharged a customer, and two pupils improvise the conversation while the class watches and then discusses. (b) Pupils manage an imaginary village with a given budget, choose how to spend on wells, roads and schools, and see the changes in the village after each year. (c) The teacher hands out a page describing how a small town reduced its plastic waste, and groups list the steps and the reasons it worked. Answers: (a) role play, because pupils improvise the roles of shopkeeper and customer. (b) simulation, because pupils decide in a model of a system and see consequences. (c) case study, because pupils analyse a description.
Worked example 2: planning order and spotting a gap
A teacher plans a field trip to a nearby dairy. The activities are listed in a jumbled order: (i) pupils write a report, (ii) the teacher gets permission and fixes the date, (iii) pupils observe and ask questions at the dairy, (iv) pupils prepare questions in class. Order: (ii) permission and planning, then (iv) preparing questions, then (iii) the visit, and finally (i) the report. So the order is ii, iv, iii, i. If the plan had no (iv) and no (i), the trip would lack its before and after phases and would become only an outing. A common wrong option reverses (i) and (iii), which is impossible because a report follows the visit.
Reading the stem carefully. The words 'improvise', 'decide', 'analyse' and 'visit' are the clues. A scenario may also contain a distracting detail, such as a discussion at the end. Almost every method ends with discussion, so discussion alone does not decide the method; look at what the pupils did before it.
Act as people: role play. Decide in a model: simulation. Analyse a description: case study. Go to the real place: field trip.
Key takeaways
- Use the four test questions to name the method.
- Scripts, quiz games and videos are look-alikes, not the real methods.
- A field trip has planning, preparation, visit and follow-up in that order.
Check your understanding
-
1. Pupils run an imaginary town council, pass budgets and see the effects. This is a:
- Role play
- Case study
- Simulation
- Field trip
Show answer
Answer: C. They decide in a model of a system and see the consequences.
-
2. Two pupils improvise a conversation between a patient and a doctor while the class watches. This is a:
- Role play
- Simulation
- Case study
- Field trip
Show answer
Answer: A. Pupils act as people in a situation.
-
3. Pupils read a description of a village that solved a water problem and analyse the causes. This is a:
- Role play
- Simulation
- Field trip
- Case study
Show answer
Answer: D. Analysis of a described situation is the case method.
-
4. Which activity comes last in a field trip?
- Getting permission from the parents
- Writing a report on the visit
- Preparing questions in the classroom
- Visiting the place and making notes
Show answer
Answer: B. Follow-up comes after the visit.
-
5. Pupils watch a film about a farm in the classroom. This is not a field trip because:
- They do not go to the real farm
- A farm cannot be visited at all
- A film is not allowed in class
- A field trip needs a film as well
Show answer
Answer: A. A field trip needs direct contact with the real thing.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.