- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Project and problem-solving methods: steps, order and induction
Order and identify the steps of the project and problem-solving methods in a scenario, and tell inductive teaching from deductive teaching.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Questions on the project and problem-solving methods often give the steps in jumbled order or describe one step and ask which it is. Others ask whether a lesson is inductive or deductive, which links to the maxim particular to general. These are easy marks once the sequences are clear and the traps are known. This lesson drills both.
The project method in full
Kilpatrick's four central steps are purposing, planning, executing and judging. Many textbooks surround them with two more: providing a situation at the start (the teacher creates conditions in which a purpose can arise) and recording at the end (keeping an account of the project). In questions that list only four steps, use purposing, planning, executing, judging. A key point is that the purpose should belong to the pupils; the teacher guides but should not impose everything.
Worked example 1: name the step
Scenario: 'After the school fair, the class meets to discuss which stalls made a profit, what went wrong with the food stall and what they would do differently next year.' Working: the project has been carried out and the class is evaluating the outcome, so this is judging. If instead they were deciding which stalls to have and who would run each, it would be planning; if they were running the stalls, executing; if they were agreeing that they wanted to run a fair at all, purposing.
The problem-solving method in full
The steps follow the logic of careful thinking: (1) sensing and defining the problem; (2) collecting relevant information; (3) forming possible solutions, often called hypotheses; (4) testing the hypotheses; (5) reaching a conclusion and, where possible, applying it. A trap in ordering items is placing hypotheses before information is gathered; in the standard sequence, information comes first so that hypotheses are informed. Another trap is starting with 'collecting data' when the problem has not been defined.
| Step | In a problem about why the school's tube-well water tastes salty |
|---|---|
| Define the problem | Pupils agree exactly what is wrong and where |
| Collect information | They ask the caretaker, note depth, check nearby wells |
| Form hypotheses | Perhaps the water source is salty; perhaps waste is seeping in |
| Test | They compare samples, ask a local expert, check nearby drains |
| Conclude | They decide the most likely cause and suggest action |
Inductive and deductive teaching
In inductive teaching, pupils study particular examples and arrive at a general rule; it follows the maxim particular to general, and discovery learning is usually inductive. In deductive teaching, the rule is given first and pupils apply it to particular examples. Induction builds understanding and is more learner-centred; deduction is quicker and useful for practice once a rule is known. Many good lessons use both: induction to find the rule, deduction to apply it.
Worked example 2: inductive or deductive?
Lesson A: the teacher writes 'Speed = distance / time' and pupils solve ten questions. Lesson B: pupils time each other walking 20 metres, compare the times and work out that dividing distance by time tells who was fastest, before the teacher writes the formula. Working: A starts with the rule, so it is deductive. B starts with particular measurements and leads to the rule, so it is inductive. B is more suitable for introducing the idea; A is useful for practice afterwards.
A speed method for ordering items
Ordering questions are fastest when you fix the first and last steps before anything else. In the project method, purposing must be first and judging last, so any option that starts elsewhere can be struck out at once; usually only one option survives. In problem solving, defining the problem is first and the conclusion is last, and the only remaining decision is that information comes before hypotheses and hypotheses before testing. Checking just these anchor points removes most wrong options in seconds, and you then confirm the middle of the surviving option.
Project: purposing, planning, executing, judging. Problem solving: define, collect, hypothesise, test, conclude. Inductive goes from examples to the rule; deductive from the rule to examples.
Key takeaways
- In the project method, the purpose should come from the pupils.
- Judging is the evaluation step at the end of a project.
- In problem solving, information is gathered before hypotheses are formed and tested.
- Inductive = particular to general; deductive = general to particular.
Check your understanding
-
1. A class has decided to make a herbal garden. They now divide tasks, list materials and set dates. Which step of the project method is this?
- Planning
- Purposing
- Executing
- Judging
Show answer
Answer: A. The purpose is already chosen; dividing tasks, listing materials and setting dates is planning.
-
2. Arrange the steps of the problem-solving method in the usual order: (1) testing hypotheses (2) defining the problem (3) drawing conclusions (4) collecting information (5) forming hypotheses.
- 4, 2, 5, 1, 3
- 2, 5, 4, 1, 3
- 2, 4, 5, 1, 3
- 5, 2, 4, 3, 1
Show answer
Answer: C. Define the problem, collect information, form hypotheses, test them, then conclude: 2, 4, 5, 1, 3.
-
3. A teacher gives the rule for finding the area of a triangle and then asks pupils to solve problems using it. This approach is:
- inductive
- heuristic
- project-based
- deductive
Show answer
Answer: D. Starting with the general rule and applying it to particular cases is deductive teaching.
-
4. Which situation goes against the spirit of Kilpatrick's project method?
- Pupils choose a real-life purpose
- The class judges its own work at the end
- Pupils work together in a social setting
- The teacher decides every detail of the task and pupils only follow orders
Show answer
Answer: D. A project depends on pupils adopting the purpose and planning it. If the teacher imposes everything, it becomes an assignment, not a project.
-
5. Pupils compare several leaves from different plants and conclude that leaves with more surface area lose more water. This lesson is an example of:
- deductive teaching
- the lecture method
- rote learning
- inductive teaching
Show answer
Answer: D. Pupils move from particular observations to a general conclusion, which is inductive.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.