- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Mixed practice: choosing a method from the aim, group size, time and resources
Practise choosing and defending a teaching method by looking at the aim, the learners, the group size, the time and the resources, and check that the plan fits the period.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The most useful exam question on methods is the plain one: which method is best here, and why? No method is best in every situation. The right choice depends on what the lesson is for and on practical limits. This lesson gives a short decision routine and works two problems that combine the choice with arithmetic.
A decision routine
- Aim: is the aim to give information, to build a skill, to develop thinking, or to change attitudes?
- Learners: how old are they, and what do they already know?
- Size and time: how many pupils, and how many minutes?
- Resources: what materials, space and technology are available?
- Check: does the method make pupils active, and is there a way to see whether the aim was met?
| Aim | Methods that suit it |
|---|---|
| Give information quickly to a large group | Lecture, with questions and a blackboard summary |
| Show how something is done | Demonstration followed by practice |
| Develop thinking and speaking | Discussion, questioning, Socratic method |
| Build teamwork and joint responsibility | Cooperative learning, project |
| Understand people's feelings | Role play |
| Practise decision making in a safe model | Simulation, case study |
| See the real thing | Field trip |
| Make practice self-paced | Programmed instruction, e-learning |
Worked example 1: three choices
(a) A teacher wants Class 10 to understand how a bill becomes a law in a short period with 60 pupils. (b) A teacher wants Class 3 to learn the table of 2 happily. (c) A teacher wants Class 8 to weigh the effects of a new road on a village. Working: (a) a large group, an information aim and little time: a lecture with questions, perhaps with a chart, and a short question round at the end. (b) young children, practice, enjoyment: the play-way method with counting games and songs. (c) a real problem with several views and no single answer: a case study or a discussion, possibly with role play of villagers, planners and farmers.
Worked example 2: fitting the plan to the period
A teacher plans a 40-minute period on 'Why save water?' with the discussion method. The plan is: introduction 5 minutes, group discussion 12 minutes, group reports 8 minutes, teacher's summary 10 minutes, and a short written check 5 minutes. Total: 5 + 12 + 8 + 10 + 5 = 40 minutes, so the plan fits. The class has 45 pupils in groups of 5. Number of groups: 45 / 5 = 9. If each group reported for 2 minutes, the reports would take 9 x 2 = 18 minutes, which is 10 minutes too long for the 8 minutes planned. Solution: only 4 groups report, since 4 x 2 = 8 minutes, and the other groups add one new point each in the summary or report in the next lesson. The teacher keeps the aim and the time together by using one report from each of four different groups.
Choose the method from the aim first, then check the learners, the size and time, and the resources. Always add up the minutes.
Key takeaways
- No method is best for everything; the aim leads the choice.
- Large groups and short times favour lecture with questions; young learners favour play-way; real problems favour discussion, case study or project.
- A plan is checked by adding up its parts.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which method best suits teaching Class 1 pupils to count with songs and games?
- The play-way method
- The lecture method
- A symposium
- The Dalton plan
Show answer
Answer: A. Play, songs and games suit young children.
-
2. A teacher plans 5 + 10 + 15 + 5 minutes for four parts of a 40-minute period. How many minutes are left?
- 0
- 10
- 5
- 15
Show answer
Answer: C. 5 + 10 + 15 + 5 = 35, so 40 - 35 = 5 minutes remain.
-
3. A class of 36 pupils is put into groups of 4. How many groups are there?
- 8
- 9
- 10
- 12
Show answer
Answer: B. 36 / 4 = 9 groups.
-
4. Which aim is best served by a field trip?
- Giving information to a very large group
- Practising problems alone
- Preparing for a written test
- Seeing the real thing at first hand
Show answer
Answer: D. A trip gives direct contact with the real place or object.
-
5. A teacher wants pupils to weigh up several views on a village problem with no single right answer. Which is the best choice?
- A one-way lecture with notes
- A case study or a discussion
- A drill on facts from the book
- Copying notes from the board
Show answer
Answer: B. Such an aim needs analysis and the exchange of views.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.