• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Evidence of evolution: homology, analogy and common traps

Classify organ pairs quickly, avoid the classic homologous/analogous traps and judge statements about embryology and observed evolution.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The evidence chapter produces many one-mark questions, and almost all of them hinge on one distinction: homologous versus analogous. The traps are pairs that do the same job but come from different origins, and pairs that look different but share an origin. This lesson gives a two-question test, a bank of standard pairs, the history behind embryological evidence and the 'evolution we can see' examples that examiners like.

The two-question test

  1. Question 1: do the organs share the same basic structure and origin? If yes, they are homologous, whatever their jobs.
  2. Question 2: if not, do they do the same job? If yes, they are analogous.
  3. Homologous organs show divergent evolution; analogous organs show convergent evolution.

The common trap is to classify by function. Two wings sound like a homologous pair, but a butterfly wing and a bird wing have nothing in common structurally. Conversely, a whale flipper and a human arm look and work differently but are built from the same bones.

Standard pairs
Homologous (same origin)Analogous (same function)
Forelimbs of whale, bat, cheetah and humanWings of butterfly and bird
Vertebrate hearts; vertebrate brainsEye of octopus and eye of mammal
Thorn of Bougainvillea and tendril of CucurbitaFlippers of penguin and dolphin
Wing of bat and arm of humanSweet potato (root) and potato (stem)

Worked example 1: a 'wrongly matched' question

Which pair is wrongly matched? (i) Butterfly wing and bird wing – analogous. (ii) Human and whale forelimbs – homologous. (iii) Sweet potato and potato – homologous. (iv) Bougainvillea thorn and Cucurbita tendril – homologous. Apply the test to each. (i) different structure, same job: analogous, correct. (ii) same bones: homologous, correct. (iii) one is a root, one is a stem, so the origin differs: they are analogous, and the match is wrong. (iv) both develop from axillary buds of the stem: homologous, correct. Answer: (iii).

Embryological and molecular evidence

Ernst Haeckel noticed that early vertebrate embryos share features, such as a row of gill slits behind the head, that disappear in adults of land animals. He proposed that embryos pass through the adult stages of their ancestors. Careful study by Karl Ernst von Baer did not support this: embryos never pass through the adult stages of other animals, though early embryos of related groups do resemble each other. The safe exam answer is that similar early embryos suggest common ancestry, while the 'recapitulation' claim was disapproved by von Baer. At the molecular level, similarities in proteins and DNA among different organisms point to common ancestry in the same way.

Evolution seen in a human lifetime

In industrial areas of England, tree trunks became dark as smoke killed the pale lichens and soot covered the bark. Lichens are sensitive to pollution and do not grow in polluted areas, which is why they are used as pollution indicators. White-winged moths now stood out against dark bark and were eaten by birds, and dark-winged moths became more common. Similar selection by human action is seen when weeds become resistant to herbicides, pests to pesticides and bacteria to antibiotics. These cases show evolution by natural selection happening over decades, not millions of years.

Worked example 2: an assertion-reason item

Assertion: The eye of an octopus and the eye of a mammal are analogous organs. Reason: They perform the same function but have different origins and structures. Step 1: A is true. Step 2: R is true. Step 3: R gives the defining property of analogous organs, so it explains A. Answer: both true, and R is the correct explanation.

Two further traps are worth a sentence each. Vestigial organs, such as the human appendix and coccyx, are evidence for evolution because they are useful in related animals; they are neither homologous nor analogous by definition, so an option that labels them that way is off-target. And fossils are dated by the age of the rock layer in which they are found, so a fossil in a deeper undisturbed layer is older than one in a layer above it.

Ask about origin before function. Same origin, different job: homologous, divergent. Different origin, same job: analogous, convergent.

Key takeaways

  • Vertebrate hearts and brains are homologous.
  • Sweet potato and potato are analogous (root versus stem).
  • Von Baer disapproved Haeckel's recapitulation claim.
  • Lichens are pollution indicators; their loss darkened tree trunks.
  • Herbicide, pesticide and antibiotic resistance are human-driven selection.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which pair is homologous?

    1. Wings of a butterfly and a bird
    2. Hearts of a frog and a rabbit
    3. Flippers of a penguin and a dolphin
    4. Eyes of an octopus and a cat
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Vertebrate hearts share the same basic origin and plan, so they are homologous. The other pairs serve the same function with different structures: analogous.

  2. 2. Which pair is an example of analogous organs?

    1. Eye of an octopus and eye of a mammal
    2. Forelimbs of a bat and a whale
    3. Thorn of Bougainvillea and tendril of Cucurbita
    4. Brains of a fish and a bird
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The octopus and mammal eye do the same job but evolved separately with different structures: analogous. The other pairs share an origin: homologous.

  3. 3. Haeckel's idea that embryos pass through the adult stages of their ancestors was disapproved by:

    1. Charles Darwin
    2. Hugo de Vries
    3. Stanley Miller
    4. Karl Ernst von Baer
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Careful embryological study by Karl Ernst von Baer showed that embryos do not pass through the adult stages of other animals.

  4. 4. Which pair is wrongly matched?

    1. Sweet potato and potato – homologous
    2. Butterfly wing and bird wing – analogous
    3. Human and whale forelimbs – homologous
    4. Bougainvillea thorn and Cucurbita tendril – homologous
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Sweet potato is a modified root and potato a modified stem. Different origins with the same function make them analogous, so calling them homologous is wrong.

  5. 5. Why did light-coloured peppered moths become easy for birds to see in polluted areas?

    1. Smoke bleached the moths' wings
    2. Pollution killed pale lichens and soot darkened the tree trunks
    3. Birds' eyesight improved in polluted air
    4. The light moths changed their resting place
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Lichens do not grow in polluted areas, and soot covered the bark. Light moths then stood out on dark trunks and were eaten more.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery