- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Scientists, ideas and experiments: matching without confusion
Pin each evolution idea to the right scientist or experiment, and avoid the swaps that exam setters count on: Lamarck and Darwin, Darwin and de Vries, Weismann and Lamarck.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Matching questions in evolution are mainly about people: who proposed what, and who did which experiment. The commonest errors are swaps between pairs of names that are taught together. The remedy is to link each name to one key idea and one key example, and then to learn the contrast within each pair of confusable names. This lesson sets out the table, the contrasts and the method of elimination.
The master table
| Name | Key idea or work | Example or evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Lamarck | Use and disuse; inheritance of acquired characters | Giraffe's neck lengthening by stretching |
| Darwin | Natural selection acting on small, inherited variations | Galapagos finches; the book On the Origin of Species |
| Wallace | Reached natural selection independently | Work in south-east Asia |
| Weismann | Germ plasm theory: body changes do not reach the germ cells | Cut the tails of mice for many generations; young still had tails |
| De Vries | Mutation theory: sudden, large, inherited changes make new forms | Evening primrose |
| Mendel | Particulate inheritance: factors are passed unchanged | Pea crosses |
| Malthus | Populations outgrow food supplies | An essay that influenced Darwin and Wallace |
| Kettlewell | Industrial melanism: dark moths survive better on sooty trees | Peppered moth |
| Hardy and Weinberg | Allele frequencies stay constant without evolutionary forces | A mathematical principle |
| Haeckel | Biogenetic law, the idea that the embryo repeats its ancestors' adult stages | Rejected in its strict form |
Three contrasts to hold
- Lamarck versus Darwin: Lamarck said the need of the organism changes it during life and the change is inherited; Darwin said that variation already exists and the environment selects among the variants.
- Darwin versus de Vries: Darwin stressed small, continuous variations; de Vries stressed large, sudden mutations producing a new form in one step.
- Lamarck versus Weismann: Weismann's tail experiment is evidence against Lamarck, since the removal of tails did not change the tails of the young.
A word about 'survival of the fittest'. The phrase was coined by the philosopher Herbert Spencer, and Darwin adopted it in later editions of his book. Do not be surprised to see it attached to Darwin in an exam; the idea is Darwin's, even if the phrase came from Spencer.
Worked example 1: assign the statement
Assign each statement to Lamarck, Darwin or de Vries. (a) The blacksmith's strong arm is passed to his son. (b) Of the many insects, those with a slightly better disguise are eaten less. (c) A new type of flower appeared suddenly in a field and bred true. Answers: (a) Lamarck, because it is an acquired character being inherited. (b) Darwin, because it describes selection among small variations. (c) de Vries, because it describes a sudden mutation that gives a new form.
Worked example 2: using an experiment against an idea
Which experiment was used to show that acquired characters are not inherited? Weismann cut off the tails of mice in each generation for many generations, and the young were still born with tails of normal length. If acquired changes were inherited, the tails should have become shorter. The result fits the view that changes in body (somatic) cells do not alter the germ cells. Compare: Kettlewell's moth work supports natural selection, not any argument about acquired characters.
Worked example 3: eliminating
Which scientist worked on peppered moths? Options: Weismann, Kettlewell, Lamarck, Hardy. Weismann cut mouse tails; Lamarck wrote about use and disuse; Hardy is linked with the allele frequency principle. By elimination the answer is Kettlewell. Always eliminate the names you can place before guessing among the rest.
Lamarck: need and acquired characters. Darwin: variation plus selection. De Vries: sudden mutation. Weismann: tails of mice. Kettlewell: peppered moth.
Key takeaways
- Each name has one idea and one example; learn them as a pair.
- The three key contrasts are Lamarck-Darwin, Darwin-de Vries and Lamarck-Weismann.
- Wallace shares credit with Darwin for natural selection.
- Eliminate names you can place, then decide among the rest.
Check your understanding
-
1. The experiment of cutting off the tails of mice for several generations is associated with:
- Lamarck
- Weismann
- Mendel
- Kettlewell
Show answer
Answer: B. Weismann did this to test inheritance of acquired characters. The young were born with tails, so acquired changes were not inherited.
-
2. The mutation theory of evolution, based on sudden large changes, was proposed by:
- Charles Darwin
- Alfred Wallace
- Hugo de Vries
- Ernst Haeckel
Show answer
Answer: C. De Vries proposed that new forms arise suddenly by mutation, based on his work on the evening primrose.
-
3. 'Industrial melanism' in peppered moths was studied by:
- Kettlewell
- Weismann
- Mendel
- Lamarck
Show answer
Answer: A. Kettlewell showed that dark moths were better hidden on soot-darkened trees in polluted areas, so they were less often eaten.
-
4. The claim that a blacksmith's muscular arms pass to his children is an example of:
- Natural selection of the strongest
- Mutation in the body's muscle cells
- Genetic drift in a small family
- Inheritance of acquired characters
Show answer
Answer: D. Strengthening of muscle through use is an acquired character, and its inheritance was the idea of Lamarck.
-
5. Which pair is correctly matched?
- Malthus: the neck of the giraffe
- Wallace: independent idea of selection
- Haeckel: crosses made on pea plants
- Mendel: dark and light peppered moths
Show answer
Answer: B. Wallace independently conceived natural selection. The giraffe is linked with Lamarck, pea crosses with Mendel and the moth with Kettlewell.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.